The St. Louis Cardinals are facing a pivotal moment in 2026, with Ivan Herrera's role behind the plate poised to shape the team's future.
Known for his impressive bat, Herrera is on the cusp of becoming a star if he can solidify his position as a catcher. His journey has been hampered by defensive challenges and injuries, but the potential payoff is immense if he can overcome these hurdles.
Herrera's spring training debut behind the plate is highly anticipated, especially after offseason elbow surgery limited his throwing ability. This marks the beginning of a crucial evaluation period for the Cardinals.
In 2025, Herrera showcased his offensive prowess with a 137 wRC+, 19 home runs, and 66 RBIs in 107 games. His bat ranks among the best, and if he can maintain this production from the catcher position, his value skyrockets. Only Cal Raleigh has outperformed him offensively among catchers since his debut.
The Cardinals boast a wealth of catching talent. Pedro Pages is a defensive standout, while prospects Leonardo Bernal and Jimmy Crooks are highly regarded.
Additionally, 19-year-old phenom Rainiel Rodriguez presents an exciting future option. This depth gives the Cardinals flexibility, allowing them to explore trades or position shifts if Herrera secures a catching role.
Herrera's potential impact extends beyond his position. Even if he transitions to a designated hitter or another field position, his offensive contributions remain invaluable. The Cardinals' ability to adapt and maximize Herrera's talents will be key to their success.
Chaim Bloom and the Cardinals are set to give Herrera every opportunity to prove himself behind the plate. If he succeeds, it could redefine the team’s trajectory, offering both immediate and long-term benefits. Whether Herrera becomes the cornerstone catcher or thrives elsewhere, his journey will be one to watch closely this season.