Quinn Mathews didn’t come with the loudest spotlight in St. Louis this year, but his first major league run gave the Cardinals something they can actually build on.
The left-hander made nine starts after his Aug. 1 debut and put together a 3.83 ERA over 49.1 innings. He struck out 46 and walked 20, a line that looks solid on its face and gets even more interesting once you dig a little deeper.
On 101 ESPN’s “BK & Ferrario,” Brandon Kiley pointed out that the last Cardinals pitcher to have his first nine career appearances all come as starts was Joe Kelly in 2012. Kelly posted a 2.96 ERA in that stretch.
Kiley also noted three other Cardinals pitchers from the last 20 years who managed a sub-4 ERA in their first nine appearances while making at least five starts: Kwang Hyun Kim, Anthony Reyes and Tim Cooney. Cooney’s case was a little different - he only appeared in six games in his brief career, and every one of them was a start.
That kind of company matters, because Mathews has already done something a lot of young pitchers in this organization haven’t managed: he’s looked stable right away. The Cardinals’ new player development staff deserves a share of the credit here, especially since Mathews was drafted in 2023 under the John Mozeliak regime, back when the club was looking for different traits from its pitchers than it is now. The fact that this group still got real results out of him says plenty about its flexibility.
The biggest issue for Mathews in the minors was always command. In 2025, he walked 6.7 batters per nine innings across three levels, and then during his time in Triple-A Memphis in 2026, that number sat at 5.5 per nine.
Once he reached the majors, though, the walks came down to a far more manageable 3.6 per nine. Something clearly changed when he got to the top level.
That matters because Mathews doesn’t look like a temporary fix. The Cardinals are expected to have Andre Pallante, Kyle Leahy and Michael McGreevy in next season’s rotation, with Matthew Liberatore as the wild card. That puts Mathews in position for the final spot, and if this first season is any indication, he could move up the ladder fast.
There’s also reason to believe what he did in 2026 was real. His FIP matched his ERA exactly, which makes it harder to write off the results as a lucky stretch. And with McGreevy fading down the stretch and his numbers settling closer to expected outcomes, Mathews could end up jumping both him and Liberatore.
For the Cardinals, that’s the kind of development they’ve been waiting to see. The organization’s last truly successful pitcher drafted and developed by the club may be Lance Lynn, taken in 2008, with Alex Reyes serving as the painful reminder of how much can go wrong. Mathews has a chance to change that story.
He might deserve even more buzz than he’s gotten so far. The Cardinals’ future is starting to take shape, and Mathews’ first season suggests he belongs in the rotation when the next competitive club takes the field.
In Other News...
Cardinals May Have Found A Brendan Donovan Trade Prize After All
Tai Peete has started to make the Brendan Donovan deal look a little more interesting for the Cardinals, even if the real payoff is still ahead. The 21-year-old center fielder came over in that trade and has spent the season turning heads in the organizations minor league system, where his offensive upside and speed have stood out despite some injury interruptions along the way.
Now hes carrying that momentum into the Arizona Fall League, which is often where clubs get a clearer read on just how loud a prospects tools can play against advanced competition. For St. Louis, Peetes rise adds another layer to a trade that already had plenty of intrigue, because if he keeps building on this stretch, he could eventually factor into a lineup looking for athleticism, on-base ability and impact in the outfield. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Suddenly Have A Real Rotation Reason To Watch Tekoah Roby
Tekoah Robys return to the mound gave the Cardinals something they have been waiting to see for a long time. After missing the entire 2026 season following Tommy John surgery, the right-hander made his first appearance in the Arizona Fall League and offered a reminder of why he had been regarded as one of the organizations more promising arms before the injury interrupted his climb.
There is still plenty of road ahead before St. Louis can treat Roby as a factor in its rotation picture, but the early signs were encouraging. Coming back from a major arm procedure is one thing, looking like the same pitcher is another, and Roby at least looked like a prospect worth tracking again as he works his way back into the conversation. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Could Face A Real Sonny Gray Decision In 2027
Sonny Grays time in St. Louis is heading toward another crossroads after the 2026 season, and the Cardinals may soon have to decide how badly they want to keep the right-hander around. Gray has been a steady presence on the mound and in the clubhouse, the kind of veteran arm a team can lean on when it wants both stability and a little credibility in the rotation.
The possibility of a one-year return in 2027 feels like the sort of move the Cardinals could at least explore if they want pitching depth and veteran leadership in one package. Gray remains the sort of pitcher whose value goes beyond the box score, and his situation sets up an intriguing offseason conversation for a team that will have to weigh short-term usefulness against longer-term planning. [Read more 🡒]