Jordan Walker’s September slide has turned a breakout season into a cautionary tale for the Cardinals.
For most of 2026, the St. Louis right fielder looked like he was announcing himself in a big way.
He hit .294 with an .887 OPS and 22 home runs in the first half, then went into the Home Run Derby looking every bit like the player ready to become a problem for the rest of the league. But the finish has been rough.
Over the past month, Walker has hit just .176 with a .519 OPS and 28 strikeouts in 68 at-bats in September.
That downturn matters because, before the skid, Cardinals media was already floating the idea of an extension for Walker along the lines of the one given to JJ Wetherholt. President of Baseball Operations Chaim Bloom has not gone there, and after this collapse, that hesitation looks a lot more reasonable.
The concern isn’t just one bad month. FanSided pointed to Walker’s struggles in 2024 and 2025 and described him as "a disappointing outfielder prone to the occasional hot streak."
Cardinals fans may not be that low on him, but the streaky label is hard to ignore now. His season has once again shown how quickly the wheels can come off when the hits stop falling.
The Cardinals have spent years trying to reshape Walker’s swing, and the changes did help this season. Even so, he still drifted back into old habits in 2026, including opening his stance and chasing sliders low and away. Prehension Athletics also noted on X that his swing has shifted over the last few months.
Jordan Walker has a .672 OPS in the 2nd half….He had a .885 OPS in the 1st half….
Jordan secured the bat with muscles that originate on the palm of his left hand for a lot of the 1st half….
He’s using muscles that originate on his left forearm a lot in the 2nd half…
Watch… pic.twitter.com/JuAIJ2S1Fs
- Prehension Athletics (@tommym8) September 23, 2026
That’s what makes this stretch so unnerving for St. Louis.
The work the Cardinals put into Walker’s approach produced real results, but it still doesn’t look fully natural. And when a slump like this lands at the end of the year, it raises obvious questions about whether 2026 was the real version of Walker or just a one-off peak.
There is still reason to believe he can be productive if he keeps adjusting to how pitchers attack him. If he does, there should be more hot stretches ahead.
The bigger question is how many of those stretches will come in St. Louis.
MLB.com’s Will Leitch laid out what a Walker extension could look like if the Cardinals decide to commit long term. It would not come cheap, especially with Walker set to become arbitration eligible in 2027 and his price likely rising sharply from there. Even so, the Cardinals would be wise to think hard before handing him a pre-arbitration deal.
That caution fits the organization’s history. Spotrac lists nine Cardinals who signed extensions before arbitration, a group that included Adam Wainwright, Allen Craig, Matt Carpenter, Kolten Wong, Stephen Piscotty, Paul DeJong and José Martínez, along with the Wetherholt extension crafted by Bloom. Most of those earlier deals came under John Mozeliak.
Some worked beautifully. Wainwright and Carpenter became two of the best extension wins the franchise could hope for, with both in line for possible Cardinals Hall of Fame consideration. Wong’s deal also paid off, as he gave the team solid production and won two Gold Gloves.
Others did not age nearly as well. Craig and DeJong fell off quickly after signing, while Piscotty and Martínez were traded soon after being extended. Piscotty was dealt to the Oakland Athletics at his request so he could be closer to his mother, who had ALS, and Martínez went to the Tampa Bay Rays with Randy Arozarena in the trade that brought first-round pick Matthew Liberatore.
Bloom’s approach suggests he may have a better read on these situations than his predecessor did. Walker’s first half made an extension seem like a no-brainer.
His second half, and especially his September, changed that. For now, Bloom’s decision to hold off looks like a smart one - and maybe the kind of restraint the Cardinals needed with a player whose talent is obvious, but whose consistency is still very much in question.
In Other News...
Cardinals Prospects Flashed Promise But One Problem Ruined The Ending
Springfields bid to defend its Texas League title ended in Game 3 against Amarillo, but the night did not lack for reasons to keep watching. Rainiel Rodriguez supplied the big swing with a two-run homer, and Liam Doyle did his part on the mound with five scoreless innings, giving the Cardinals top prospects a chance to show why the organization remains bullish on the next wave of talent.
The frustration came from the other side of the game, where defensive mistakes helped swing the championship series finale away from Springfield. For a club that had spent the season building toward another run, the loss closed the door on a title defense and shifted the focus back to what comes next, including a rebrand that is scheduled to arrive ahead of the 2027 season. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals May Already Be Telling Fans Victor Scott IIs Future
Victor Scott IIs path back to meaningful playing time has been awfully narrow since the Cardinals brought him back up Sept. 1. After being demoted to Triple-A on June 7, he has started only one game since returning, a sign that the clubs current outfield picture is leaning in a different direction as the season winds down.
Nathan Church now appears to be the preferred everyday center fielder, and Scotts underwhelming season has only sharpened the questions around his place on the roster. Even if the Cardinals are not saying anything publicly, the way they have used him suggests an offseason decision is coming, with his future likely tied to whether St. Louis wants to clear room elsewhere on the 40-man roster. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Still Need One Veteran Arm And This Winter Target Fits
The Cardinals are still looking ahead to a rotation that could use one more proven arm, and the need becomes even clearer when the focus shifts past this season. With a young pitching staff already in the mix, St. Louis has a case for adding a veteran starter who can steady things without blocking the longer-term plan, especially if the club wants someone who has been through the grind of pitching in a pennant race.
Zac Gallen fits that profile as a potential free-agent target after the 2026 season, even with a difficult year behind him. He brings the kind of experience and past track record that can make a short-term deal appealing for a team like the Cardinals, who need reliability as much as upside, and how aggressive they choose to be in that market could say plenty about how quickly they want to fortify the staff. [Read more 🡒]