Jimmy Crooks may not have given the Cardinals the big-league breakout they were hoping for this season, but his place in the organization is still very much alive.
The 25-year-old was sent back to Memphis after St. Louis brought up Leo Bernal, and that move says plenty about how the Cardinals view him. Rather than treating him like a lost cause, they seem to see a catcher who still deserves real playing time and a real look.
His numbers in St. Louis this year were rough: a .179/.255/.336 line with five home runs in 52 games.
That’s not the production the Cardinals wanted when they promoted him in May. But the story has looked much better since the demotion.
Entering play on Sunday, Crooks was hitting .391/.482/.587 at Triple-A with two home runs and five extra-base hits in just 12 games.
The appeal is pretty clear. Crooks can swing it, and he can handle himself behind the plate. That kind of profile matters, even when the strikeouts pile up.
And they do pile up. The biggest issue in his game remains the swing-and-miss, especially in the zone.
In Triple-A, he did a better job cutting down on chasing and drew a lot of walks, which helped soften that concern. In the majors, though, he rarely walked and got too aggressive with his zone, which led to a 32.2 K% overall.
Even so, the quality of contact has been strong at both levels.
That leaves the Cardinals with a real decision to make. Depending on how they sort out Bernal, Ivan Herrera and the looming arrival of Rainiel Rodriguez, Crooks could still have a meaningful role. At the same time, he also fits the profile of a player who could be used to land starting pitching, help solve a need in center field or at third base, or even be flipped for different prospects.
There’s no shortage of paths here.
What the Cardinals should avoid, though, is forcing a Crooks deal just to make one. They’ve got a crowded catching picture, so choices are coming soon, but there’s no reason to settle if the market doesn’t line up.
It’s possible Herrera brings back an offer so strong that it changes the whole equation. It’s also possible the Cardinals decide to keep their current options together and let Crooks stay in the mix next year if nothing appealing shows up.
If Bernal and Herrera split time in St. Louis to open the season, Crooks and Rodriguez could split time in Memphis and get work at other spots as well.
And in a game where most catchers don’t handle more than 60% of the games, there’s room for more than one path.
Even if Crooks isn’t the long-term answer in St. Louis, he still looks like the kind of player another club would want badly.
There were already rumors at the trade deadline that he could be moved. Left-handed pop and above-average defense behind the plate are tough to find, and the Cardinals know that.
He could wind up as a key piece in a bigger trade for a more established player. He could also be the sort of prospect another team targets to build up its own system, giving St.
Louis more ammunition for later. And yes, he could even headline a deal for a solid player at another position of need.
However the Cardinals handle it, Crooks’ status this offseason is going to be one of the major stories to follow.
In Other News...
Cardinals Prospects Flashed Promise But One Problem Ruined The Ending
Springfields bid to defend its Texas League title ended in Game 3 against Amarillo, but the night did not lack for reasons to keep watching. Rainiel Rodriguez supplied the big swing with a two-run homer, and Liam Doyle did his part on the mound with five scoreless innings, giving the Cardinals top prospects a chance to show why the organization remains bullish on the next wave of talent.
The frustration came from the other side of the game, where defensive mistakes helped swing the championship series finale away from Springfield. For a club that had spent the season building toward another run, the loss closed the door on a title defense and shifted the focus back to what comes next, including a rebrand that is scheduled to arrive ahead of the 2027 season. [Read more 🡒]
Jordan Walker Just Made A Cardinals Decision Much Tougher
Jordan Walkers 2026 season gave the Cardinals plenty to weigh, and not just because of the way he flashed in the first half. He looked like a player trending toward a long-term future in St. Louis before the season turned uneven, with his production slipping badly down the stretch and his September numbers leaving a much shakier impression than the one he built early.
That kind of volatility is exactly why the Cardinals have been careful about talking extension before Walker even reaches arbitration eligibility in 2027. The club has a history of exploring early deals with young players, but Walkers case feels trickier than most, because the talent is obvious while the consistency still isnt there. For now, his future with the team remains open, and the front office has a decision it does not seem eager to rush. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals May Already Be Telling Fans Victor Scott IIs Future
Victor Scott IIs path back to meaningful playing time has been awfully narrow since the Cardinals brought him back up Sept. 1. After being demoted to Triple-A on June 7, he has started only one game since returning, a sign that the clubs current outfield picture is leaning in a different direction as the season winds down.
Nathan Church now appears to be the preferred everyday center fielder, and Scotts underwhelming season has only sharpened the questions around his place on the roster. Even if the Cardinals are not saying anything publicly, the way they have used him suggests an offseason decision is coming, with his future likely tied to whether St. Louis wants to clear room elsewhere on the 40-man roster. [Read more 🡒]