Umpire chaos nearly swallowed the whole night for the Cardinals, but Ivan Herrera made sure the story ended somewhere better.
That Friday matchup with the Colorado Rockies had already turned messy by the time the ninth inning arrived. St. Louis was down 6-4, and the game had been pushed into the kind of uproar that makes everyone in the ballpark feel like they’re losing track of the rules as fast as the calls are coming.
Then Herrera stepped in and changed everything.
He launched a three-run homer in the top of the ninth, flipping the Cardinals ahead 7-6 and rescuing what had become a wild, frustrating night. In the Dealin' the Cards podcast countdown of the 10 best moments from the Cardinals’ 2026 season, that swing landed at No. 7 for exactly that reason: it didn’t just win the game, it wiped away a mess that had taken over the entire contest.
The controversy had already been building. Nolan Gorman appeared to tag a runner out at third base, but the call on the field was safe. The Cardinals asked for a review, and while the original ruling was confirmed, Doug Eddings’ reaction drew attention on its own, including a response from the Cardinals broadcast.
From there, things got stranger. Eddings stopped Hancel Rincon, who was making his Major League debut, in the middle of a 2-0 count and told him to straighten his cap because it was tilted to the side. That drew frustration because, as the story went, there is no rule against that kind of cap angle.
Oliver Marmol then confronted the umpiring crew while making a pitching change, and Eddings said Marmol took too much time. After Marmol left the field, Just Bruihl was hit with a pitch clock violation, and Marmol was quickly ejected after that.
The situation kept getting worse for St. Louis.
After the Cardinals had already used up their challenge on the Gorman play, Eddings called a runner safe at the plate right in front of him on a tag that looked clearly out, and this time the Cardinals had no way to contest it. That sequence helped put Colorado in position before Herrera’s home run changed the scoreboard.
Major League Baseball later told Eddings that he went too far in how he handled Rincon, and Rincon received an apology the next day.
The Cardinals even responded with a bit of unity of their own, with their hats tilted in solidarity with Rincon. And after everything that happened that night, it’s easy to see why this one still stands out: the Cardinals found a way to win a game that threatened to turn into a complete disaster.
In Other News...
Cardinals Reunion Idea Hinges On One Big Question About A Familiar Arm
Jordan Montgomerys name is back in circulation again, and it comes with the kind of familiar appeal that can tempt a front office looking for stability. The left-hander once pitched for the Cardinals, later won a World Series with the Rangers and now is heading toward free agency at 33, with a recent track record shaped as much by injuries and uneven performance as by the promise he still occasionally flashes.
For St. Louis, the fit is easy to understand: a veteran arm who could help anchor a rotation in 2027 and perhaps become a movable piece if things go well by summer. The question, though, is the same one that follows Montgomery around now, and it will shape how seriously the Cardinals can pursue the idea of a reunion. [Read more 🡒]
Jordan Walker Just Changed A Big Cardinals Decision
Jordan Walkers 2026 season gave the Cardinals exactly the kind of long-term answer they have been searching for. He put together a full workload, powered his way to 29 homers, swiped 22 bases and drove in 102 runs across 158 games, then added an All-Star nod and a Home Run Derby title to a year that firmly raised his profile in St. Louis. For a club trying to build around a young core, Walker only strengthened the sense that he belongs at the center of the conversation.
Even with the late-season dip, there is now a different kind of uncertainty around him, and it has less to do with whether he is part of the future than where the Cardinals fit him within it. Chaim Bloom confirmed Walker was playing through hip pain in September, a reminder that the final impression of the season came with some context attached. Walker and JJ Wetherholt are viewed as key pieces for what comes next, and the Cardinals suddenly have a big decision to make about how to handle that promising pairing. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Face An Offseason Decision That Could Box In Their Youth
The Cardinals enter the winter with a familiar kind of tension: a 77-85 finish, a young roster, and enough in-house talent to make the next step feel possible without a full reset. St. Louis has promising pieces already in the majors, along with high-upside names working their way up the farm system, including Jesus Baez and Rainiel Rodriguez, so any offseason shopping list has to account for both present need and future flexibility.
Bullpen help and a veteran starter make sense, and theres also a case for bringing in another option at third base. But thats where the organization has to be careful, because a heavy commitment there could crowd out the younger players the Cardinals are trying to develop. With so much of the roster still in the making, this winter may be less about solving everything at once and more about avoiding a move that blocks the very youth the club is counting on. [Read more 🡒]