For a Cardinals team that spent 2026 squarely in rebuild mode, Dustin May turned into one of the season’s most surprising payoffs. What began as a big offseason swing on a free agent ended with a trade deadline return, but the moment that made it all click came in one electric start against the Padres.
May’s outing in San Diego is the kind of game that sticks. He took a perfect game into the seventh inning, then finished a complete-game shutout on one hit, striking out nine and walking only one batter. Fernando Tatis Jr. and Manny Machado were the only Padres to break through at all in the seventh, and May still needed just 101 pitches to get through the night.
That was a sharp turn from the way his Cardinals career opened. After two starts, he owned a 15.95 ERA, the worst mark by a Cardinal in his first two outings since Alan Benes in 1995.
But he settled in fast. Over his next 11 starts before facing San Diego, he posted a 2.89 ERA and, for the first time in his big league career, stayed healthy.
In that stretch, he finished the sixth inning eight times, and his run lined up with St. Louis holding the first National League Wild Card at 38-31 entering play on June 15.
The Padres gem also came on the heels of another near miss. Three starts earlier, May carried a no-hitter into the eighth in Milwaukee before Garrett Mitchell lined a ball just beyond Bryan Torres in left field. This time, there was no escape hatch for the opposition.
For the Cardinals, the lesson was bigger than one dominant night. May showed that the club can attract pitchers with upside, build a plan around them, and get them performing at a level that creates value.
It also proved that when St. Louis takes that kind of swing, the payoff can come twice: on the mound and later in the trade market.
That was the real win here. The Cardinals not only got the kind of season-changing performance they hoped for, they also turned it into a deadline haul that included two top prospects from the Milwaukee Brewers, with various outlets viewing them as top 100 prospects. According to people within the organization, the club expected May’s market to be strong once contenders started chasing starting pitching.
So while May’s shutout lands at No. 10 on the Cardinals’ 2026 moments list, the broader story is even bigger. St.
Louis found a pitcher who delivered, stayed healthy, and brought back real value. That’s a pretty strong return on a gamble.
In Other News...
Cardinals Face A Catching Decision That Could Reshape Their Depth Chart
As the Cardinals sort through the back half of their 2026 roster picture, the catcher situation has become one of the more important items on the docket for 2027. Rookie Leo Bernal has moved into position as the likely starter, which gives St. Louis at least one clear answer behind the plate, but the rest of the depth chart is still taking shape.
What happens next could have ripple effects beyond just one position. Pedro Pages is among the names being weighed for a backup role, but his limited offensive value and the clubs catching depth, which also includes Jimmy Crooks and Ivan Herrera, could make him a trade candidate as the Cardinals look to streamline the group before making their final call. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Face A Rebuild Defining Choice At Third Base
Third base is shaping up as one of the more important decisions on the Cardinals road map to 2027, with the front office already looking ahead to how the position can help lift the offense. St. Louis is expected to explore both internal answers and outside help as it tries to improve the lineup, and the fit there will say plenty about what kind of roster it wants to build next.
Two very different names sit near the center of that conversation. Eugenio Suarez brings the kind of power that can change a game with one swing, while Luis Arraez offers a contact-heavy profile and the flexibility to move around the infield. The Cardinals do not have to choose immediately, but the direction they take at third could become a defining part of this rebuild. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Face An Uncomfortable Nolan Gorman Decision This Offseason
The Cardinals go into the offseason with a roster that looks far less ripe for turnover than it did a year ago, which makes their decisions more pointed than plentiful. Most of the club is young and under team control through 2027, leaving St. Louis with only a handful of obvious avenues to reshape the roster, and that puts a spotlight on the players who no longer fit cleanly into the long-term picture.
Nolan Gorman sits at the center of that conversation after an uneven season that ended with a Triple-A demotion. With other internal options available at third base, the Cardinals are weighing whether to try to move him in a trade rather than let the situation drift toward a non-tender and free agency, a choice that would say plenty about how quickly the organization is willing to pivot from a once-promising bat. [Read more 🡒]