Cardinals’ Catching Strategy: A Three-Headed Approach to Start the Season
As the Cardinals kick off the 2026 season, they’re taking a strategic approach to managing their catching duties, potentially starting with three different catchers in their first three games. It’s a move that highlights both the depth of their roster and the need to carefully manage Ivan Herrera’s workload.
The Catching Carousel Begins
Opening Day saw Pedro Pagés behind the plate, leading the Cardinals to a thrilling 9-7 victory over the Rays. On Saturday, Iván Herrera took over catching duties with Michael McGreevy on the mound. As we look to Sunday, Yohel Pozo might get his shot, catching for newcomer Dustin May.
This rotation isn’t just about mixing things up; it’s a calculated effort to ease Herrera back into action. After offseason elbow surgery and knee issues during Spring Training, Herrera’s health is a top priority. With Steven Matz starting for the Rays on Sunday, the Cardinals are likely to mix in their right-handed bats, including Pozo and Herrera.
Keeping Herrera Fresh and Effective
Herrera, at 25, is seen as a cornerstone of the Cardinals’ lineup with All-Star potential. His 2025 season was hampered by injuries, limiting him to just 107 games, yet he still managed an impressive .284/.373/.464 slash line, with 19 homers and 66 RBIs. The goal this year is to keep him healthy and maximize his presence in the lineup.
Manager Oliver Marmol emphasized the importance of monitoring Herrera’s physical recovery. “We want to ensure he’s ready for the long haul,” Marmol noted, highlighting the need to balance game time with recovery. Herrera’s performance as a designated hitter, including a key RBI sacrifice fly, shows his versatility and importance to the team.
Defensive Improvements on the Horizon
While Herrera’s offensive skills are undeniable, his defensive game, particularly controlling base stealers, needs work. In 2024, he struggled with throwing mechanics, allowing 55 successful steals out of 59 attempts. In 2025, that challenge persisted with zero caught stealings in 14 games.
Despite limited Spring Training action, Marmol is optimistic about Herrera’s defensive growth. “His game-calling is sharp, and most importantly, he’s pain-free,” Marmol stated, underscoring the potential for improvement as Herrera gains more experience this season.
Join the Cardinals Conversation
For fans eager to dive deeper into Cardinals discussions, our CARDINALS on ROUNDTABLE community is the perfect place. Share your thoughts, engage with fellow fans, and stay connected with all things Cardinals. It’s free and easy to join!
As the Cardinals navigate the early season, their approach to managing catchers reflects a blend of caution and ambition, aiming to keep their roster healthy and competitive.