The Cardinals’ rebuild has already sent a few familiar names out the door, but if St. Louis could undo just one move from the offseason, Sonny Gray would be the obvious pick.
That’s not a knock on the direction of the teardown. The Cardinals moved Willson Contreras, Nolan Arenado, Brendan Donovan and Gray to contending clubs, then brought back a wave of prospects to fuel what comes next.
Most of those pieces have fit the long-term plan. But if the question is who would help the 2026 Cardinals most right now, the answer starts on the mound with Gray.
St. Louis dealt Gray and $20 million to the Boston Red Sox, landing pitching prospects Richard Fitts and Brandon Clarke in return.
Fitts opened the year at Triple-A Memphis and posted a 1.76 ERA in three starts before a lat strain in mid-April shut him down. Clarke, 23, began the season injured as well, but he has since worked 22 innings across Low-A and High-A, striking out 31 batters with a 3.68 ERA.
The Cardinals also got Patrick Galle as the player to be named later. He has appeared in 40 games for St. Louis and carries a 6.35 ERA.
There’s an argument to be made for some of the other names, too. Arenado has delivered league-average offense with a 100 OPS+ and plus defense at third base, production the Cardinals have not consistently matched this season.
Contreras has also been a real force in Boston, putting up a .900 OPS with 26 home runs and 79 RBIs. Still, his departure has been easier to absorb because Jordan Walker has broken out and Alec Burleson has risen at first base.
Even with those performances, Gray is the one who would change the most for St. Louis this year.
He has steadied Boston through a season that swung from frustration to momentum. The Red Sox spent the first couple of months underperforming, then turned into one of baseball’s best teams since July. Through it all, Gray has been rock solid.
His line says plenty: a 2.82 ERA with 128 strikeouts in 143.2 innings. With Garrett Crochet out for an extended stretch and an otherwise inexperienced rotation around him, Gray has handled the leadership role. He’s also the lone right-hander in Boston’s rotation, which only heightens his value heading into the postseason.
The Cardinals’ rotation has been respectable on its own. Their starters rank 13th in staff ERA at 4.09, and Kyle Leahy (3.13), Andre Pallante (3.57) and Michael McGreevy (3.98) have all kept their ERAs under 4.00. But dropping Gray into that group would add a different gear - the kind of strikeout arm and dependable presence that could swing a couple more games.
From a long-term standpoint, the trade made sense. St.
Louis needed to trim payroll with uncertainty around its TV deal, and the return from Chaim Bloom has helped deepen an already strong farm system. Even so, it’s fair to wonder how different this year might look if the Cardinals still had a veteran ace like Sonny Gray at the front of the rotation.
In Other News...
Cardinals Prospect Story Just Sparked A Perfect Umpire Troll
Hancel Rincns major league debut on Sept. 4 came with a detail that quickly outgrew the box score, when umpire Doug Eddings told the young pitcher to adjust the angle of his hat. The moment drew plenty of attention, and it also gave Rincns former Double-A club in Springfield a clean opening to lean into the joke.
So on Sept. 10, the Springfield Cardinals announced a giveaway of Crooked Caps, turning a one-night oddity into a bit of minor league theater. It also fit the mood around a club that has already clinched a Texas League playoff berth and keeps stocking the pipeline with players who could matter to St. Louis down the road, which only makes the timing of the promotion feel even more on-brand. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Fans Still Have One Tradition Other Teams Are Starting To Copy
St. Louis has long treated returning former Cardinals a little differently than most ballparks do, turning Busch Stadium into a place where past service still matters even when a player is wearing the other uniform. Albert Pujols celebrated return in 2019 remains the standard-bearer for that tradition, and it has helped define how Cardinals fans respond when a familiar face comes back as an opponent.
The custom has not faded even with attendance down in recent years, and it has continued with players such as Willson Contreras, Nolan Arenado and Paul Goldschmidt drawing warm welcomes. More recently, Baltimore fans gave Adley Rutschman a standing ovation when he returned with the Red Sox, another sign that the Cardinals old-school habit is starting to look less unusual around the league, even if St. Louis has been doing it for years. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Rookie Debut Got Hijacked By A Bizarre Umpire Controversy
Hancel Rincons major league debut was supposed to be a simple first look at a Cardinals rookie pitcher against the Rockies, but the first inning quickly turned into something else entirely. Umpire Doug Eddings stopped play to have Rincon adjust his cap, turning an otherwise routine start into a strange early detour that drew immediate attention from St. Louis manager Oli Marmol and briefly overshadowed the moment for the young right-hander.
The interruption helped set an uneasy tone for Rincons first outing, and the inning only got messier from there as he gave up three runs before being removed after one frame. Even with the debut getting hijacked and the dugout irritated by the whole sequence, the Cardinals still found a way to hang on and beat Colorado 7-6, leaving the unusual cap dispute as one of the nights more memorable footnotes. [Read more 🡒]