The St. Louis Cardinals may be headed into the winter with a better long-term feel than the standings suggest, but that doesn’t mean free agency is about to deliver a dramatic makeover.
St. Louis finished with a losing record for the second straight season, a stretch that created unwanted franchise history.
Still, there were real signs of progress. Alec Burleson and Jordan Walker took important steps toward becoming stars, and JJ Wetherholt, Joshua Báez and Leo Bernal all flashed the kind of upside that points toward a stronger future.
That future, though, is still probably a year or two away from championship territory. And because of that timing, this may not be the offseason to chase a headline-grabbing splash. The combination of a possible lockout and a thin market makes big spending look especially unlikely.
As The Athletic's Tim Britton wrote on Thursday, "It’s not a great time in Major League Baseball to spend money," The Athletic's Tim Britton wrote on Thursday. "Uncertainty surrounding a likely lockout and the new rules that will emerge after it are good enough reasons to be conservative with your cash. But the bigger problem is an upcoming free-agent class largely bereft of game-changing talent.
"While the starting pitching market can hold its own, this year’s position-player class is almost unprecedentedly bad. The best bats available - Randy Arozarena, Seiya Suzuki and Brandon Lowe - are entering their age-32 seasons.
The players who in the spring were thought to be the most likely to cash in, such as Bo Bichette and Jazz Chisholm Jr., had subpar seasons. (Bichette will probably turn down his opt-out clause and remain with the Mets.)"
That lines up with what already seemed likely for St. Louis. A major free-agent swing never appeared to be the plan, and the most realistic big-picture move may be an extension for one of the club’s young standouts, such as Walker or Burleson.
If the Cardinals do shop this winter, the more sensible approach is probably a series of smaller additions, especially on the pitching side. A short-term deal for a veteran with upside would fit the pattern, much like the move they made with Dustin May this year.
Shane Bieber stands out as one option St. Louis should consider.
For now, though, the most probable outcome is simple: a few modest roster tweaks, not a franchise-altering shopping spree.
In Other News...
Cardinals Face A Crucial Winter With Too Many Holes To Ignore
The Cardinals winter has already taken shape around a familiar problem: there are too many places on the roster that need help, and not enough certainty to feel comfortable standing pat. St. Louis finished 77-85 and missed the postseason for the fourth straight year, even as several young players showed encouraging development. The reset now falls to Chaim Bloom and the front office, who are trying to push the club toward a younger core without ignoring the obvious pressure points.
The bullpen was shaky, third base didnt produce enough offense, and the rotation never quite had an established ace to anchor it. Those are the kinds of gaps that can make a rebuild stall if they are left to chance, which is why the Cardinals may need to balance patience with a more aggressive move or two before 2027. The challenge is finding the right mix of long-term growth and short-term stability, because this roster still looks like one that needs more than internal improvement alone. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Face A Big Third Base Question With Blaze Jordan
The Cardinals turned one of last summers deadline deals into a longer look at their future in the infield when they brought in Blaze Jordan for Steven Matz. Matz had done solid work in Boston before moving on in free agency, while Jordan arrived with a reputation built on strong minor league production and the kind of upside that can keep a front office interested even after a rough introduction to the majors.
Now the real question is where Jordan fits, and whether third base can become his path to regular at-bats in St. Louis. His big-league stint did not go smoothly before a season-ending injury cut it short, but the organization still has to sort out what comes next at a spot that remains unsettled for future seasons. [Read more 🡒]
Jordan Walker Just Made The Cardinals' Offseason Much Tougher
Jordan Walkers breakout season changed the conversation around the Cardinals almost overnight. After slugging 29 home runs and earning his first All-Star selection, he no longer looks like just another young piece in the rebuild, but the kind of player a front office has to think about differently when winter decisions come due.
That is where the complication starts for St. Louis. Walker is heading into the kind of offseason where the Cardinals have to weigh a long-term extension against the risk of waiting, with arbitration eligibility looming and his price likely to rise if he keeps producing. Chaim Bloom has already signaled caution about big spending, so Walkers next contract question may become one of the defining choices of the clubs offseason. [Read more 🡒]