The Cardinals have a decision coming fast on Nolan Gorman, and it lands before the Nov. 20 deadline to tender contracts to arbitration-eligible players. With that date set for the final Friday before Thanksgiving, and a possible lockout hanging over the sport, this week is shaping up to be a busy one across Major League Baseball.
For St. Louis, the question is simple: do they keep Gorman in the fold, or move on after another rough year?
One clear argument for a non-tender is financial. Gorman has only two seasons of team control left, and MLB Trade Rumors projected his arbitration salary at about $3.4 million for the 2027 season. That number is not massive in a vacuum, but for a club still rebuilding and operating in a year when the league’s financial picture is unsettled, every bit of savings matters.
The 2026 season didn’t exactly make the case for a raise. Gorman earned just over $2.6 million and produced 85 games in the majors, along with nine home runs and a .184 batting average. If the Cardinals don’t see him as a real infield answer for 2027, non-tendering him is one of the cleanest ways to trim payroll.
Still, there’s a reason this decision isn’t cut and dried. Gorman’s bat was rough in 2026, both in St.
Louis and after his Triple-A demotion, but his defense took a noticeable step forward. He went from -8 outs above average in 2025, when he ranked in the 6th percentile, to the 61st percentile in 2026 with zero outs above average.
And then there’s the upside. Gorman hit 27 home runs in 2023, and that version of him still matters.
If the Cardinals non-tender him, he’d head to free agency and almost certainly be gone for good. They’d also lose any chance to trade him later.
The Cardinals just watched Jordan Walker rebound in 2026 after a couple of difficult seasons, and that kind of turnaround is part of the case for keeping Gorman around. If the club believes there’s still a real bounce-back waiting, it makes sense to hold on.
If Thomas Saggese or Blaze Jordan looks like a better fit at the hot corner, or if St. Louis thinks a trade can be worked out, then tendering him is the move.
If not, it may be time to walk away.
In Other News...
Cardinals Just Sent A Tough Message With This 40-Man Decision
The Cardinals made a clear roster call in advance of the Rule 5 draft, adding infielder Jess Bez and right-hander Jacob Odle to the 40-man roster to keep both prospects in the organization. Bez, ranked as the clubs sixth-best prospect, gives St. Louis another young infield option worth protecting, while Odle remains more of a developmental arm, but one the front office clearly did not want exposed to the winter market.
To create the room, St. Louis designated Max Rajcic for assignment, a move that underscores how difficult the roster math can get when a team is trying to balance present needs with future depth. Rajcic has already had Tommy John surgery and is expected to miss the 2027 season, so his path back is a long one, and the Cardinals could still try to keep him in the system if he clears waivers and returns on a minor league deal. [Read more 🡒]
Jordan Walker Just Set Up A Much Bigger Cardinals Question
Jordan Walkers 2026 season was the kind that made it easy to see why the Cardinals still believe in the bat. He put together a .269/.327/.466 line with 29 home runs, 102 RBIs and a 119 wRC+, a clear step forward from his earlier seasons and enough production to put him in the conversation among the leagues better young outfielders.
Still, the finish left a different kind of question hanging over St. Louis. Walker did not come away with the National League Silver Slugger outfield honor, and the late-season dip in his production took some shine off what had been a breakout year for much of the summer. For the Cardinals, the bigger issue now is whether this version of Walker is the new baseline or just the start of something even better. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Eye Another Short-Term Rotation Bet This Offseason
The Cardinals are again looking at the kind of rotation move that has become a familiar offseason lane for them: a short-term bet on a pitcher who could help now and carry some trade value later. One name on their radar is a 29-year-old left-hander who spent time with the Royals and Dodgers in 2026, a profile that fits a club trying to add pitching without locking itself into a long commitment.
For St. Louis, the appeal is obvious. A one-year arrangement would give the team a chance to see whether the arm can stabilize the staff and rebuild his market at the same time, with the deadline looming as a possible pivot point if things go well. It is the sort of calculated gamble the Cardinals have been willing to explore as they try to keep flexibility while still addressing a clear need. [Read more 🡒]
