The Cardinals may have a clear answer staring them right in the face if they decide to chase starting pitching at the trade deadline: Sonny Gray.
St. Louis has room to add, and the rotation is the obvious place to look.
The club has plenty of pieces it could move, but the expectation around the industry is that the Cardinals are more likely to buy than sell. If that’s the path they take, Jim Bowden of The Athletic believes Gray is one of the cleanest fits.
"The Cardinals have been the NL’s biggest surprise, and they believe that their biggest need is a starting pitcher," Bowden wrote. "Without giving up any of their very top prospects, their most realistic trade targets are a reunion with Sonny Gray or acquiring Robbie Ray."
Gray is already a familiar name in St. Louis.
The Cardinals dealt him to the Boston Red Sox over the winter as part of their rebuild, and the return wasn’t especially notable. Because of the way his contract is set up, bringing him back likely wouldn’t require a massive prospect package.
And Gray has backed up the interest with production in Boston. He’s 10-1 with a 2.61 ERA in 16 starts, though he was left off the American League All-Star roster.
Even so, he still looks the part of a front-line starter and would give St. Louis the kind of arm it needs if it chooses to make a move.
The complication is that Gray is also exactly the kind of pitcher the Cardinals have said they don’t want to chase. Owner Bill DeWitt Jr. has made it clear the team will be active, but not for a short-term rental.
"When the Trading Deadline comes up, teams have a tendency to [think] 'Well, if I get one more guy, I’ll give them two of my draft choices, then I can make the playoffs.' That’s kind of not our model," DeWitt said at the time.
“We’ll obviously engage at the Deadline, but it will not be for a two-month hopeful. It will be a good reason to make the deal, regardless of where we happen to be."
That stance makes a reunion with Gray feel far from certain. The Cardinals may like the fit, but whether they’re willing to bend their deadline approach is the real question.
In Other News...
Ivan Herrera Found A Wild Way To Solve The Brewers' Flame Thrower
Facing a Brewers pitcher who has been piling up strikeouts at the top of the league, Ivn Herrera had to get creative before first pitch. The Cardinals slugger spent pregame work on a pitching machine cranked to 107 mph, a deliberate attempt to make Jacob Misiorowskis fastball feel a little less overwhelming once the real thing arrived.
The approach paid off in the moment, as Herrera turned on a Misiorowski pitch and gave St. Louis a temporary edge with a solo shot. It was the kind of at-bat that can change the feel of a game and reinforce why Herrera remains such an intriguing middle-of-the-order piece for the Cardinals, even against one of the sports most electric young arms. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Face A Trade Deadline Mistake Fans Know Too Well
With the trade deadline closing in, the Cardinals find themselves in one of those familiar in-between spots, close enough to the race to feel the pull of adding help, but still far enough from finished to remember how fragile that kind of push can be. St. Louis is hanging just behind the third National League wild card spot, which makes the next few days more than a routine checkpoint for a club still trying to turn its rebuild into something more lasting.
Derrick Goold of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch has argued the Cardinals should not simply sit on their hands and hope the standings sort themselves out. Instead, the front office may need to choose a path that reflects both the present and the future, whether that means buying, selling, or finding a way to do both at once. For a team trying to become a legitimate contender again, the danger is not just making the wrong move, but making none at all. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Are Running Out Of Reasons To Keep Quinn Mathews Waiting
Quinn Mathews has spent 2026 making a much stronger case for himself after a rough 2025, and the Cardinals have to be paying attention. The left-hander has cleaned up enough of the mess from last season to move into the conversation for a major league promotion later this year, giving St. Louis a young arm worth tracking as the roster picture starts to tighten.
The timing still feels like the real question. The Cardinals may be waiting for the trade deadline to pass before making any move, when a little more roster flexibility could open up, and Mathews could be the kind of pitcher who forces the issue once that window arrives. Whether his first look comes in a short-term role or as part of a more direct path to the rotation, the organization is getting closer to a decision it can keep putting off only so long. [Read more 🡒]