The St. Louis Cardinals may have another familiar name on their radar as they look back into the starting pitching market.
Dustin May, who spent last season in St. Louis, declined his mutual option on Thursday and is back on the open market after winning a World Series with the Brewers. That naturally puts the Cardinals in the conversation again, especially with the club once more needing help in the rotation.
Jeff Jones of the Belleville News-Democrat said the sides could at least check in.
"I’m not certain the fit will work for either party but I would expect May and the Cardinals to have at least a conversation about a reunion," Jones wrote on X on Thursday.
That idea has already been floating around for a while, including from MLB.com's Will Leitch, and it makes some sense on the surface. May is only 29, and Spotrac has his projected value at a little more than $46 million over three years. He took a prove-it deal last winter with a mutual option, and the Cardinals could be in position to consider something similar again - or something closer to that Spotrac range.
His year in St. Louis gave the team what it wanted from a veteran arm with upside. May posted a 4.38 ERA across 21 starts before being sent with JoJo Romero to the Brewers in exchange for No. 5 prospect Alexander Frias and No. 11 prospect Josiah Ragsdale.
The bigger selling point for the Cardinals is that May actually stayed on the mound. Health has followed him around as a question throughout his career, but he made 21 starts for St.
Louis and remained available. He also logged back-to-back seasons with at least 132 innings pitched.
And when he was out there, he usually gave the Cardinals a shot. In 21 outings, he allowed more than three runs just six times and gave up more than four runs only five times.
If St. Louis is looking for a starter it already knows, May fits that description.
By the time the 2027 season arrives, he’ll be another year removed from missed time and still familiar with the organization. If a team can get May looking like a stud again, the source material makes clear where that team would be: St.
Louis.
In Other News...
Cardinals Offseason Pitching Search May Come Down To One Veteran Fit
The Cardinals offseason checklist is already taking shape, and pitching sits near the top of it after another year of searching for more stability on the mound. The bullpen in particular needs attention, and one name that fits the clubs need for experience and flexibility is Nick Martinez, the 36-year-old right-hander who turned in a strong 2026 season with the Tampa Bay Rays.
Martinez declined a mutual option for 2027, which puts him on the market as a possible one-year fit for a team looking to patch multiple holes without overcommitting. For St. Louis, the appeal is obvious: he can work either as a starter or out of the bullpen, and that kind of versatility could matter if the Cardinals want to add one veteran arm who helps them cover a lot of ground at once. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Fans Can Dream On Tarik Skubal But Bloom Faces One Test
The idea of Tarik Skubal in St. Louis is the kind of offseason daydream that can get Cardinals fans talking, especially with ESPN floating the fit. Skubal has built a rsum that would make him one of the most coveted arms on the market, and any club looking to accelerate a rebuild has to at least consider what a pitcher of that caliber could mean at the front of a rotation.
For the Cardinals, though, the conversation quickly turns from fantasy to reality under Chaim Bloom. Payroll remains a central issue as the organization tries to balance long-term planning with short-term competitiveness, and the cost of landing a premium free-agent starter would be steep even before factoring in Skubals injury history. The bigger question for St. Louis may not be whether he would fit, but whether Bloom is willing to break from the clubs current path to chase a name that big. [Read more 🡒]