Since Leo Bernal was called up, the Cardinals have already started showing what a different first-base picture could look like. Bernal has opened two games there with Alec Burleson on the bench, and that setup could become a lot more common in 2027 whenever a left-handed starter is on the mound.
The logic is straightforward: Burleson has become a real problem in those matchups, while the Cardinals also have a growing group of younger bats who need places to play. Against lefties this season, Burleson has produced a 54 wRC+, which ranks fifth-worst among 194 qualified hitters.
That isn’t just a one-year blip, either. His career 64 wRC+ against left-handed pitching is the fourth-worst mark among 203 hitters with at least 450 plate appearances against lefties since 2022.
There’s no denying the other side of the split. Burleson has been one of baseball’s best hitters against right-handers this year, putting up a 157 wRC+ that ranks sixth among qualified hitters. That kind of production is too good to ignore, and with roughly 70% of pitchers throwing right-handed, he’ll still get the bulk of the chances.
The Cardinals have not had much reason to take Burleson out of the lineup this season. But as the roster adds more talent, especially right-handed hitters who can handle first base, the team has a chance to get more out of the position by using it more selectively.
Looking ahead, Bernal is an obvious option to pick up first-base reps so his bat stays in the lineup while also giving Burleson a breather against lefties. Ivan Herrera fits into the conversation too.
His catching workload may be shrinking, and the Cardinals probably want to keep designated-hitter opportunities open for more players. With Joshua Baez and Jordan Walker in the corner outfield spots, Herrera moving out there looks even less likely than it did before.
Rainiel Rodriguez could also enter the mix. The Cardinals’ top prospect has one of the most exciting bats in the minors, and while he’s mainly a catcher right now, he has already logged some first base this season. The club could add yet another position for him this offseason.
That kind of alignment would do two things at once: create more at-bats for young players battling for time, and give the Cardinals a better look against left-handed starters. It would also turn Burleson into a useful bench weapon later in games when right-handed pitchers come in, giving Oli Marmol another way to use him.
Later this week, a deeper look is coming on how the Cardinals can keep consistent at-bats available for Herrera, Bernal, and Rodriguez, and this first-base shift is a big part of that puzzle.
In Other News...
Cardinals Are Suddenly One Loss From A Brutal New Low
A night that already carried plenty of frustration ended with the Cardinals locking themselves into a place this franchise has worked hard to avoid. The loss to the Pirates dropped St. Louis to 76-81, officially eliminating the club from postseason contention and ensuring there will be no finish above .500 in 2026.
With five games still to play, the only thing left for the Cardinals to chase is damage control. They need to win out just to avoid a losing season, and if they cannot, it would leave them with back-to-back losing years for the first time since 1958 and 1959, another stark marker in a stretch that now includes a fourth straight missed playoff berth. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Are Finally Facing The Arenado Debate They Knew Was Coming
The Cardinals spent the winter making a clear bet on the future, moving on from Willson Contreras, Sonny Gray, Brendan Donovan and Nolan Arenado before the 2026 season in exchange for a package that included Jack Martinez. It was the kind of sweeping reset that signals more than a roster shuffle, and it also left St. Louis leaning harder into development and playing time for younger pieces such as Blaze Jordan and Nolan Gorman.
Arenado, meanwhile, has been productive in Arizona, which only sharpens the conversation around what the Cardinals gave up and why they were willing to do it. For St. Louis, though, the move was never just about one player's numbers. It was about choosing a long-term path, even if the short-term optics make the debate around Arenado feel a lot more complicated than the front office would probably like. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Rebuild Could Stall Fast Without One Crucial Offseason Fix
The Cardinals have spent much of this season looking more competitive than their record might suggest, which is part of what makes the next step so important. Even with a losing season likely to follow last years, St. Louis has had enough bright spots to keep the rebuild from feeling stalled, thanks in part to breakout turns from Jordan Walker, JJ Wetherholt and Alec Burleson and a 50-45 mark heading into the All-Star break.
But the offenses progress can only carry so much weight if the pitching picture stays this shaky. St. Louis needs a true front-end starter and help for a bullpen that has dealt with blown saves and an inflated ERA, and the pressure on the front office is obvious because another offseason without those fixes could leave the clubs encouraging first half feeling much less meaningful. [Read more 🡒]