The Cardinals made their deadline move with an eye on the future, but the one piece they chose to keep may have been the most logical trade chip of all.
St. Louis dealt away veterans to help restock the farm system, a direction that fit the way the second half has unfolded. What looked like a possible buy-or-sell debate early on tilted toward selling after the club stumbled coming out of the break.
Among the players moved were Dustin May, Lars Nootbaar and JoJo Romero. But while the Cardinals parted with those names, they held onto Iván Herrera, their 26-year-old catcher and designated hitter who has put together a solid season and earned his first All-Star nod.
Herrera has hit .240/.357/.373 with 12 home runs and 46 runs batted in, production that only adds to the curiosity around St. Louis keeping him.
With Jimmy Crooks and Pedro Pagés already on the roster, and Rainiel Rodriguez and Leo Bernal moving up through the system, the Cardinals had plenty of catching depth to work with. In a market where catchers were especially valuable, Herrera looked like the kind of player who could have returned a significant haul, particularly with multiple years of team control still ahead of him.
As MLB.com's Will Leitch wrote on Wednesday, "There was much speculation that the Cardinals, who have a catching surplus throughout their organization, would deal from that strength to clear up a theoretical logjam, especially with catchers being one of the most in-demand positions on the market," MLB.com's Will Leitch wrote on Wednesday. "This makes a lot of sense. The last two months may be Herrera’s last chance to establish himself as at least a part-time catcher before the Cardinals start thinking about other positions for him.
"Pagés still has value as a backup and a well-liked pitching staff whisperer and, most intriguingly, the Cardinals clearly still believe in Crooks’ underlying metrics despite some wobbly numbers at the plate this season. The Cardinals still have questions these catchers all need to answer. They’ve given them all more time to do so."
That uncertainty around Herrera’s long-term defensive home is the real issue. He has been productive at the plate, but he has only caught 42 games this season and has appeared behind the plate in fewer than half of his games over the last three seasons. With no guarantee he stays at catcher, the argument for moving him at peak value was right there.
In Other News...
Jess Bez Is Making The Ryan Helsley Trade Look Different
When the Cardinals moved Ryan Helsley at the 2025 trade deadline, the immediate reaction was about the price of dealing away a proven late-inning arm. The Mets expected to plug Helsley into a bullpen need, while St. Louis turned the deal into a longer-term play by bringing in shortstop Jess Bez, a young infielder whose upside was always going to be judged more by what came next than by any quick return.
One year later, the contrast is getting harder to ignore. Helsleys stint with New York did not go the way the Mets hoped, and Bez has quietly built a case in the Cardinals farm system with his production across High-A and Double-A. He has also climbed into the organizations prospect conversation, which only adds to the sense that this deal may end up being measured very differently on the St. Louis side than it was the day it was made. [Read more 🡒]
Alec Burleson Had Cardinals Fans Wondering About His Deadline Future
The Cardinals were among the busier teams at the 2026 trade deadline, moving several players while keeping first baseman Alec Burleson in the fold. For a club trying to sort out its direction, that left Burleson in the middle of the kind of speculation that can linger around deadline day, even when a player is not actually dealt.
Manager Oli Marmol later made it clear Burleson did not need to sit with that uncertainty for long. The conversation that followed the deadline brought immediate relief for the 25-year-old, who wanted to remain in St. Louis and continue being part of the Cardinals plans as they try to build something more stable over the next couple of years. [Read more 🡒]