The Cardinals have a real chance to come away with more than just a Rookie of the Year finalist nod for JJ Wetherholt.
Major League Baseball announced its 2026 National League Rookie of the Year finalists, and Wetherholt landed on the three-man list alongside Reds infielder Sal Stewart and Mets outfielder Carson Benge. The award will be decided by one voter from each of the 30 Baseball Writers Association of America chapters.
With the Prospect Promotion Incentive in play, the race carries consequences for all 30 clubs. For St.
Louis, Wetherholt’s finish could determine whether the organization adds a pick at the end of the first round. Even with the eight-year extension he signed shortly after his debut, he remains eligible for the reward, just as Corbin Carroll and Julio Rodríguez were in previous seasons after signing similar deals.
The competition looks wide open. There is no obvious favorite, and both Wetherholt and Benge finished with at least 4.0 WAR on Baseball-Reference and FanGraphs. That makes this one of those races where the ballot could split in a few different directions.
Wetherholt, 24, debuted on Opening Day and put together what may have been the strongest all-around rookie season in the group. He hit .242/.339/.365 with 17 home runs, a 102 OPS+, and 4.5 bWAR.
His value went beyond the bat, too. Strong defense at second base and quality baserunning helped turn an average offensive line into a profile that looks much more like a future All-Star.
Benge, though, has a strong case of his own. He owns the best offensive line of the finalists, posting a 118 wRC+.
He also brings a 20-homer, 20-steal season and solid defense in right field. He was a Gold Glove finalist, just like Wetherholt, before losing out to the Diamondbacks’ Corbin Carroll.
Stewart gives voters another path. The Reds rookie put up the loudest traditional counting numbers in the group, finishing with 32 home runs, 112 RBIs and 15 stolen bases.
For some voters, that kind of production could carry the day, especially if they lean heavily on offense. The question is how much weight defense will receive, since the other two finalists were in Gold Glove consideration.
That’s where Wetherholt may have the edge. He plays an up-the-middle position, provides the best defense and baserunning of the trio, and adds value in ways that don’t always jump off the page. Those run values away from the plate could end up mattering a lot in a race this tight.
The most likely outcome, according to the shape of the ballot, is a split decision that comes down to first- and second-place votes. Benge could very well edge Wetherholt for the top spot.
Even if Wetherholt doesn’t win Rookie of the Year, the Cardinals still have another path to a reward. He could become an MVP finalist before reaching three years of service time, which would also make him eligible for a PPI pick.
Brice Turang, a similar player, reached that level with a 7.3 bWAR season and was named a finalist in 2026. St.
Louis can also look to Bobby Witt Jr. as an example, since he did it in 2024.
For Wetherholt to get there, he would likely need to be an elite defender and baserunner while posting at least a 120 OPS+. He already checks two important boxes, having been worth +12 fielding runs and +3 baserunning runs on Baseball-Reference. If he can pair that with +20 batting runs and +20 defense, he could work his way into the conversation.
And if none of that leads to a PPI pick, the Cardinals still have the long view working in their favor. Wetherholt is under an eight-year, $112.5 million extension that keeps him in St.
Louis through the 2034 season. Alongside shortstop Masyn Winn, he gives the Cardinals one of the better double-play combinations in baseball.
In Other News...
Cardinals May Have A Low Cost Answer To Their Lefty Problem
The Cardinals have been weighing a familiar roster fix as they look for ways to balance out their lineup against left-handed pitching, and the search has centered on a right-handed bat who can handle first base. Alec Burleson has given them a useful lefty option, but the need for a complement on the other side has kept that spot on the radar as St. Louis continues sorting through its offseason priorities.
Ryan Mountcastle has surfaced as one possible fit, bringing the kind of power production that once made him an appealing bat in Baltimore. Injuries slowed him last season, which adds some risk to the idea, and the Cardinals still may lean more heavily toward pitching help as they keep building out the roster. Even so, offensive upgrades remain part of the conversation, and first base looks like one place where a relatively modest move could make a real difference. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Just Made A Trade Fans May Second Guess Later
The Cardinals added another arm to the organization by landing left-hander Eduardo Rivera from the Red Sox in exchange for minor league right-hander Juan Garcia. Rivera has already seen time in both the majors and minors since debuting in 2026, and his mix of experience gives St. Louis some flexibility as it looks for help in either the bullpen or the rotation.
For Boston, the move comes with a longer view in mind, since Garcia is only 18 and has already begun his professional career in the Dominican Summer League. Deals like this often look straightforward at first glance, but the kind of pitcher Rivera has been can become more valuable once a contender starts sorting out innings in the middle of a season. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Take A Low-Risk Bullpen Shot With Real Upside
The Cardinals have added another arm to their bullpen mix, acquiring Rivera from the Red Sox in a move that comes with little downside and a chance for meaningful payoff. Boston had designated Rivera for assignment because of roster constraints, even though his track record has been uneven in the majors and more encouraging in the minors, which made him the kind of available pitcher a team like St. Louis can circle back to when it is looking for depth without paying a premium.
For the Cardinals, the appeal is obvious: a fresh bullpen option with some real upside if the change of scenery helps unlock more consistency. Boston, meanwhile, gets 18-year-old Garcia in return, a young pitcher who has already begun his pro career in the Dominican Summer League, underscoring how both clubs approached the deal with different timelines in mind. [Read more 🡒]