The St. Louis Cardinals have already lived through the wreckage of their 2026 season, so the conversation has shifted to what comes next. Free agency won’t offer a gold rush, and the market is described as thin, but there are still a few places where the Cardinals can patch obvious holes without lighting money on fire.
Three names stand out as practical targets: Jason Adam for the bullpen, Tyrone Taylor for center field, and Ryan Yarbrough for depth with a little more versatility than the average arm.
Adam is the cleanest fit if St. Louis wants to stabilize the ninth inning.
Since Ryan Helsley was sent to the Mets, the Cardinals have been sorting through a closing mess. Riley O’Brien handled the role last year and finished with 38 saves, but his walk issues and late-season performance left plenty of questions about how real that total was.
Adam would give the Cardinals something they badly lacked: reliability.
He has been one of the league’s best relievers since 2022 and just posted a 2.62 ERA last season. He also has 26 career saves, so the job would not be foreign territory.
What makes him especially appealing is that he isn’t built on pure heat. Tyler Glasnow once described Tampa Bay’s ability to find “black swans,” and Adam fits that mold: funky, hard to square up, deceptive, and excellent at keeping walks in check.
Sportrac projects him at one year and $8.7 million, a number St. Louis could live with if he’s being brought in to close right away. The Cardinals do not need to chase the priciest arm on the market, but the bullpen does need real attention, and Adam would not come with a scary price tag.
Taylor is the more interesting fit in the outfield, especially if the Cardinals want a player who could slot into a platoon and still help in the field. He was dealt to the Cubs from the Mets at the deadline and turned in a strong finish, including a career-best .827 OPS and 11 home runs. Against lefties, he was especially dangerous, putting up a .921 OPS.
He also comes with traits that make sense in center: 92nd-percentile sprint speed and 85th-percentile arm strength. That makes him a natural partner for Nathan Church, who is currently the frontrunner.
The Cardinals would not have to force Taylor into an everyday role, and that matters. If he cools off, Church is right there as the fallback.
Sportrac has Taylor at roughly one year and $7.5 million. Other center-field possibilities include free-agent Trent Grisham and trade candidate Steven Kwan, but both come with bigger concerns.
Grisham is coming off a rough year, especially defensively, and Kwan would cost significantly more than Taylor. Signing Taylor would also preserve room for Church, which appears to matter to the organization.
Yarbrough is the kind of under-the-radar signing that can pay off when the staff gets stretched thin. The Cardinals got worn down by injuries late in the year, and innings became precious.
That is where Yarbrough fits. He brings a different look from the left side, and unlike a lot of soft-tossing types, he has stayed healthy.
He has not missed a season since his debut in 2018.
Last season with the Yankees, he threw 63.1 innings and finished with a 3.69 ERA. He also made two starts.
That flexibility is part of the appeal. So is the style itself: he does not give up much hard contact, and his sweeper carried an xBA of .084 in 2026.
There is even a case that his profile would travel well to St. Louis. Busch Stadium and an infield full of Gold Glove-level defense would support a run-avoidant pitcher like Yarbrough.
If all of this sounds light on starting pitching, that is because the Cardinals’ rotation picture is already crowded with internal options. FanGraphs’ roster resource projects the 2027 rotation as Kyle Leahy, Michael McGreevy, Quinn Mathews, Andre Pallante, and Matthew Liberatore. The only real way to add is to subtract, and Liberatore is the one most obviously in jeopardy after what is described as an egg of a 2026 season.
Even then, the system may keep pushing its way into the picture. Jurrangelo Cijntje, Liam Doyle, Tanner Franklin, Brandon Clarke, and Tekoah Roby are all mentioned as prospects on the way, though not all of them will debut and not all of them are guaranteed to begin as starters. The larger point is simple: why block the lane with placeholders if the pipeline is already filling up?
Some external names linked to that rotation spot include Dustin May, Shane Bieber, and Tyler Mahle, but the broader shopping list looks modest. St. Louis is not in a position to patch every hole with outside help, and the roster does not appear ready for a heavy round of starting-pitcher spending.
The one way that changes is if Pallante, Liberatore, McGreevy, or Leahy gets traded. Bernie Miklasz recently floated McGreevy in a discussion on the DealintheCards podcast with Josh Jacobs, Andrew Wang, and Sandy McMillan.
If that kind of move happens, free agency opens up. Until then, it is all speculation station.
For now, the Cardinals seem likelier to improve by tightening the margins, not by swinging big. And if the path back to competency really starts as soon as 2028, these are the kinds of moves that make sense: useful, affordable, and aimed at keeping the roster from slipping any further.
In Other News...
Cardinals Could Revisit A Risky Rotation Reunion This Offseason
As the Cardinals look for ways to strengthen a rotation that has been part of their rebuild conversation, one familiar name is already being floated as a possible fit. Jack Flaherty, who once fronted St. Louis staff before moving on to the Detroit Tigers in 2026, has the kind of history with the organization that makes a reunion easy to imagine, even if the path back would come with plenty of caution attached.
The appeal is obvious: a pitcher the Cardinals know well, available in a market where they need upside without losing sight of the bigger picture. But Flahertys recent performance and injury history make any reunion a calculated gamble, and any deal would likely have to land in the same general range as the kind of contract Dustin May previously received from St. Louis. For a club trying to balance ambition with restraint, that is the sort of decision worth watching all winter. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Fans Found A New Reason To Feel Good All Season
For Cardinals fans, the good feelings this season did not stop on the field. The clubs television broadcast team drew a bigger audience across the board, with Chip Caray and Brad Thompson landing third in baseballs broadcast rankings while posting a 4.98 household rating and a 29% jump in total viewership.
The numbers got even stronger around the edges of game day, with pregame and postgame shows also seeing meaningful gains along with streaming subscriptions. Caray helped frame the seasons early success and some of the biggest moments along the way, and the audience response suggests Cardinals viewers stayed locked in from first pitch to the final wrap. [Read more 🡒]