The St. Louis Cardinals are heading into the second half of the 2026 season with a real chance to play their way into October, and that alone says plenty about how their offseason has gone.
They’ll open the stretch run Friday night on the road against the Arizona Diamondbacks and old friend Nolan Arenado. At 50-45 through 95 games, the Cardinals sit third in the National League Central behind the Milwaukee Brewers and the Chicago Cubs. They’re also just one game back of the Miami Marlins for the final National League Wild Card spot.
That’s a far cry from what many expected when the Cardinals spent the winter stripping things down and leaning hard into a youth movement under Chaim Bloom, now in charge as president of baseball operations. The front office moved veterans out, took its medicine, and committed to the reset. So far, that approach has put the club in the thick of the race.
If you’re sorting through the offseason now that the first half is over, one move stands out as the best work the Cardinals did - and another has been the roughest.
The brightest swing came in the three-team deal that sent away homegrown All-Star Brendan Donovan. It was a painful move on its face, but St.
Louis came out of it with a strong haul: No. 4 prospect Jurrangelo Cijntje, No. 17 prospect Tai Peete, Triple-A outfield prospect Colton Ledbetter, and two Competitive Balance Round B picks. The Cardinals used those picks on outfielder Andrew Williamson out of Central Florida and pitcher Dawson Montesa out of West Virginia.
Donovan’s season hasn’t helped soften the blow for Seattle, either. He’s been limited to just 25 games because of injury, while St.
Louis has already added five total prospects from the transaction, with Cijntje looking like the headliner. He’s now one step away from the majors in Triple-A.
The Gray trade, though, has been a tougher sell so far. The Cardinals still might end up liking it in the long run, and the logic behind dealing veterans remains sound. But through the first half, this one has hurt.
St. Louis landed No. 7 prospect Brandon Clarke in the swap, and he’s an intriguing piece, but he missed the first few months of the season.
Clarke has started a minor league rehab assignment and has made one start with the FCL Cardinals. The Cardinals also got Richard Fitts, but he was injured and later had season-ending lat surgery.
On top of that, the Cardinals sent $20 million to the Red Sox to help cover part of Gray’s contract. Gray has responded by pitching like a Cy Young contender, going 11-1 with a 2.54 ERA in 17 starts. That’s a lot of money to pay for two pitchers who haven’t been able to give the Cardinals much this season in return for a true frontline arm.
In time, Clarke and Fitts could still make this deal look a lot better. For now, though, it’s the offseason move that has stung the most.
In Other News...
Cardinals Had The Perfect Response After A Rival Took A Shot
Paul Sewalds frustration over a weather-related Cardinals postponement did not stay buried for long, and the Arizona closer wound up seeing St. Louis again soon after in a series that carried a little extra edge. The Diamondbacks and Cardinals have already been through one round in Arizona, and the matchup has had the feel of a team response game ever since the complaint surfaced.
Sewalds return to the mound did not exactly settle the matter, either. He was tagged with the loss in the opener and then picked up a save in the next game, leaving his numbers a bit shakier as the clubs move toward more meetings, including a makeup game on a four-city road trip that keeps this one from fading away anytime soon. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals May Have A Bigger Pitching Problem Than Fans Realize
With the Cardinals hanging around the playoff chase and the trade deadline closing in, the pitching staff is starting to look like the area most likely to be reshaped. St. Louis is expected to explore changes on the mound, including moving pitchers on expiring contracts and reworking the rotation as it tries to stay competitive through the second half.
The bigger issue is that the fixes may not stop with one or two roster moves. Michael McGreevy and Andre Pallante have become important pieces, but the club may still need help covering innings and sorting out who fits where going forward, especially if the current mix gets thinned by deadline activity. If that happens, the Cardinals could be leaning on prospects sooner than planned, which makes the next few weeks about more than just adding depth. [Read more 🡒]
Quinn Mathews Is Forcing His Way Into A Cardinals Debate
Quinn Mathews keeps making the Cardinals decision tree a little more complicated. The left-handed prospect turned in another solid outing for Triple-A Memphis, working six innings and allowing one run with four strikeouts, the kind of start that keeps him in the conversation as St. Louis sorts through its pitching depth.
Mathews has been especially sharp in July, and his overall work at Memphis has only strengthened the case for a bigger opportunity. The Cardinals are weighing whether they need another starter for a demanding stretch, and while no move has been made, Mathews has done enough to stay near the front of the line if the club decides to tap into its upper-level arms. [Read more 🡒]