The Milwaukee Brewers are World Series champions, and that achievement brings an old Cardinals regret back into sharp focus: Christian Yelich was right there for the taking.
Back in the 2017-2018 offseason, St. Louis was searching for a middle-of-the-order bat.
Three Marlins outfielders were in play, and the Cardinals had their sights set on the best of the group. Giancarlo Stanton was the first target, but after the Cardinals and San Francisco Giants both reached agreements with Miami, Stanton used his no-trade protection and blocked both destinations before eventually landing with the Yankees.
That left Yelich and Marcell Ozuna as the realistic options. St.
Louis made Yelich the priority, viewing him as one of the game’s best young players. But the Marlins pushed hard, the Cardinals felt pressure to land that impact bat, and the front office shifted to Ozuna instead, sending prospects Zac Gallen and Sandy Alcantara in the deal.
Ouch!
The Brewers stayed patient and eventually got Yelich. From there, he became the centerpiece of their rise - MVP in 2018, runner-up in 2019, and a driving force behind a lineup that turned Milwaukee into a National League heavyweight.
St. Louis, meanwhile, got respectable production from Ozuna, but not the kind of franchise-altering return they were chasing.
That’s what makes this sting. Yelich in a Cardinals uniform could have altered more than one team’s path.
If St. Louis had landed him, the club would have added an MVP-level bat to a roster that later paired Paul Goldschmidt with Ozuna during the 2019 NLCS run.
Goldschmidt arrived after the 2018 season, and a Goldschmidt-Yelich tandem would have given the Cardinals a far more imposing heart of the order. Yelich’s 2019 season was outrageous - a 1.100 OPS - while Ozuna delivered a solid .800 OPS in St.
Louis, though his defense was a problem.
There are ripple effects too. With Goldschmidt and Yelich tied up on major contracts, it’s fair to wonder whether the Cardinals would have pursued Nolan Arenado.
Yelich also tailed off after 2019. And because Ozuna departed in free agency, St.
Louis received a compensation draft pick and used it to select Alec Burleson, meaning that piece of the puzzle likely disappears as well if the original trade goes another way.
Even so, the Cardinals’ alternate timeline isn’t as simple as “Yelich fixes everything.” If you’re not convinced he would have changed the outcome in 2019, then the trade may not have shifted St.
Louis’ results all that much. It would have mattered more to Milwaukee’s roster construction, though the Brewers still didn’t reach World Series glory until Yelich was in the later stages of his career.
That’s part of what makes Milwaukee’s title feel so pointed from a Cardinals perspective. The Brewers are a well-run organization and would likely have found another way forward, but replacing what Yelich gave them in 2018 and 2019 would have been no easy task. They probably would have found another strong player somewhere along the line, but they’re certainly happy with the one they got - their first captain in franchise history.
So yes, congratulations are in order for the Brewers. They earned it.
And for the Cardinals, this is another reminder of how close they came to landing a player who could have changed a lot. They’ve done good work building things back over the last few years, and this has a chance to become a real rivalry again soon.
In Other News...
Cardinals Suddenly Face One Offseason Problem They Can't Ignore
The Cardinals are heading into another winter with the attention shifting away from deadlines and toward the kind of roster repair work that can shape the next couple of seasons. After missing the postseason for the fourth straight year, St. Louis appears poised to lean more heavily on free agency than trades as it tries to patch obvious holes at third base, in the starting rotation and in the bullpen.
That makes the pitching side especially hard to ignore, because the clubs hopes of being more competitive in 2027 will depend on how much it can raise the floor of the staff. Internal options will get a look, but the front office is also expected to explore outside help, with names such as Dustin May and Shane Bieber in the mix as the Cardinals search for arms that can stabilize both the rotation and relief corps. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Face A Bullpen Decision That Could Frustrate Fans
The Cardinals have another offseason call to make on a bullpen arm, and it comes with a price tag that could push the organization toward a familiar kind of calculus. By Nov. 2, St. Louis has to decide whether to pick up veteran reliever Ryne Staneks $6 million club option for the 2027 season, a figure that sits squarely in the range of decisions that tend to test a front offices willingness to pay for reliability.
Stanek gave the Cardinals plenty of innings in 2026, working in 70 games and finishing with a 4.02 ERA after settling in following a rough opening stretch. Even so, the cost of bringing him back at the option number could make the club hesitate, especially if the belief is that he might return on a lower deal once the market resets. For a bullpen that will always be judged on both effectiveness and efficiency, this is the kind of move that can leave fans wondering whether the safe choice and the smart one are the same thing. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Head Into A Pivotal Offseason With Familiar Names At Risk
With the 2026 season in the books, the Cardinals are already shifting into a winter defined by hard choices and familiar names. Nolan Gorman, Ryan Stanek, Yadier Herrera and Juan Yepez are all among the players the front office may have to weigh against roster fit and future needs as St. Louis starts mapping out its 2027 plan.
The biggest pressure points are easy to spot: third base, catcher and designated hitter all loom as spots the Cardinals may want to address. That leaves this offseason with a familiar St. Louis feel, where the decisions are less about chasing new faces than deciding which current pieces still belong in the conversation and which ones could be moved on from. [Read more 🡒]