Cardinals Face One Big Jackson Holliday Trade Problem

Despite the Cardinals' interest in Jackson Holliday, reuniting him with his father's former team hinges on the Orioles adjusting their steep trade demands.

Jackson Holliday makes obvious sense for the Cardinals on paper. He’s a left-handed bat, a former No. 1 overall pick, and the son of Cardinals Hall of Famer Matt Holliday.

He could step in at third base and also has a path to second base or shortstop depending on how St. Louis sorts out its infield long term.

The problem is the price tag.

If Baltimore still values Holliday like the elite prospect he was a few years ago, this is the kind of deal that never gets off the ground. The Orioles are listening on just about everyone on their major league roster not named Pete Alonso, and with so many young infielders in the mix, Holliday is one of the more obvious names to move as they reshape the roster. But the Cardinals are not going to empty the cupboard for a player whose major league track record has been uneven and whose long-term offensive ceiling comes with real questions.

Holliday has logged 1,211 plate appearances at the major league level and hit .229/.300/.354 with an 86 wRC+. That’s a long way from the production expected when he was ranked the sport’s top prospect before his debut.

The deeper numbers haven’t helped his case, either. Since 2024, he has had trouble consistently driving the ball, and his below-average bat speed has raised doubts about how much power he can realistically produce in the majors.

Even with that, there’s still plenty to like about the bet. Holliday is only a few weeks away from turning 23, and if Baltimore’s asking price became reasonable, the Cardinals would be an intriguing landing spot simply because of the hitting group they have in place.

St. Louis has built a reputation for helping young hitters take a step forward.

Dalton Hurd and Brock Hammitt are widely praised for their work, both inside and outside the organization. Casey Chenoweth has earned respect on the major league side and is credited with helping Jordan Walker get his career back on track.

New coach Joel McKeithan has also helped young hitters find success in the majors and has seen power gains from the clubs he has coached.

That group has already had a hand in the development of Walker, Joshua Baez, Jesus Baez, and Tai Peete, with Walker and Joshua Baez improving after the new hitting staff arrived and Jesus Baez and Peete showing gains after joining the organization with that group already in place. The question is whether Holliday could be next.

A deal would not come cheap. Right now, it would likely take one of the Cardinals’ best prospects and more to land him.

But if Baltimore were willing to accept a strong package that didn’t begin with St. Louis’ top five prospects, or if the framework included some major league talent, the conversation changes.

From the Cardinals’ side, a package built around Michael McGreevy, Jimmy Crooks, and perhaps another smaller prospect is the kind of structure that makes sense. The Orioles are looking for cost-controlled pitching for their rotation, outfield help, and possibly a catcher, which lines up with what St. Louis could offer.

Baltimore would need to be realistic, though. Unless it is adding pieces to the deal along with Holliday, it is not going to get a pitcher with cost control and high upside in return. What it could get is a dependable starter like McGreevy, plus additional pieces, to help round out the roster.

If the asking price drops, the Cardinals could be in position to take the swing. There are people in the organization who would love to bring Holliday in, and that’s what makes this one worth watching.

In Other News...

Cardinals Bullpen Need Makes This Available Strikeout Arm Hard To Ignore

The Cardinals bullpen issues have lingered throughout the 2026 season, and that has kept the front office looking for arms that can miss bats and handle leverage. One name that fits the profile is a recently available right-handed reliever who just finished a strong year with the Yankees, where he worked to a 3.13 ERA and showed the kind of strikeout ability that can change late innings in a hurry.

For St. Louis, the appeal goes beyond the surface numbers. The club needs help in a relief mix that has not been steady enough, and this pitchers style suggests he could slot into that conversation quickly if the Cardinals decide to get aggressive in free agency. The question now is whether they see him as the kind of arm worth prioritizing, especially with other teams likely to be eyeing the same sort of upside. [Read more 🡒]

Cardinals Face A Tough Catching Decision As Young Depth Keeps Rising

The Cardinals have already made one notable roster move this winter by non-tendering Nolan Gorman and pitcher Max Rajcic, and the next decisions could be just as revealing about where the organization thinks its depth is strongest. Catching is one of those spots, with the club continuing to sort through which players fit long term and which ones may be squeezed out as the pipeline keeps getting deeper.

Pedro Pages is part of that conversation, but not an easy one. His offensive production has been inconsistent enough to leave his standing in question, even as other catchers in the system keep pushing for bigger roles. St. Louis does not appear ready to settle the issue yet, and the way it handles the position could say plenty about how it views the balance between present need and future upside. [Read more 🡒]

Cardinals Suddenly Have A Buy-Low Rotation Gamble Worth Watching

The Cardinals have spent plenty of time looking for rotation help, and a new name has quietly entered the conversation: Luis Gil. The right-hander was one of the more intriguing arms in the American League not long ago, winning Rookie of the Year in 2024 after a strong season that showed why so many clubs once viewed him as a potential difference-maker. For a St. Louis team that could use starting pitching, he fits the kind of buy-low profile that tends to draw real interest this time of year.

Gils appeal is obvious, but so is the risk, which is why he is the sort of gamble worth watching rather than a clean fit. He did not get many chances in 2026, and the command issues that surfaced there are the same ones that can make a talented arm hard to trust in a major-league rotation. If the Cardinals are serious about adding upside without paying full freight, this is the kind of pitcher they will at least have to consider. [Read more 🡒]