The Cardinals have a clear opening at third base, and one name that could make sense is Casey Schmitt.
San Francisco has reportedly said it will listen on offers for the 27-year-old utility player, and the fit in St. Louis is obvious enough to at least ask the question.
Schmitt broke out in 2026, batting .271 with a .784 OPS and 21 home runs while bouncing all over the diamond. He logged time in left field, first base, second base, shortstop and, most importantly for the Cardinals, third base.
That’s where the appeal starts. Schmitt was at his best defensively at the hot corner, where he posted five outs above average.
The problem for the Giants is that Matt Chapman is locked in there, and the rest of Schmitt’s possible homes are crowded too. Willy Adames, Bryce Eldridge, Rafael Devers and Marcelo Mayer are expected to get the first cracks at shortstop, first base, designated hitter and second base, respectively.
Left field is more open, but Schmitt didn’t grade well there defensively in 2026.
The bat is the bigger swing factor. Schmitt has plenty of red on his Baseball Savant page, and his plate discipline is the glaring issue. Even while he was putting together a strong offensive season before tearing his meniscus in July, he had the lowest walk rate in the majors among hitters with at least 400 plate appearances, checking in at just 2.7%.
That kind of number can scare teams off fast, but St. Louis may believe it can do something with him.
The Cardinals’ new development staff gives them a better chance than most clubs to smooth out that flaw, and Schmitt’s 7.8% walk rate in 2025 suggests there’s at least a more workable version of the hitter in there. The Giants, after all, had the worst walk rate in baseball last season, so the problem might not be entirely Schmitt’s alone.
If the Cardinals want a stopgap at third, they can look elsewhere. Schmitt would be more of a longer-range play, and that could ripple through the roster.
In that scenario, Jesús Báez could move to shortstop when he reaches the majors, while Masyn Winn could become trade bait. With President of Baseball Operations Chaim Bloom appearing less defense-first than manager Oli Marmol, St.
Louis could be willing to trade some middle-infield polish for more offense.
A deal could also line up cleanly with what San Francisco needs. The Giants are looking for rotation help, and the Cardinals have a pitcher who fits that ask.
Michael McGreevy for Casey Schmitt could satisfy both the Cardinals and the Giants
Logan Webb and Landon Roupp are projected to anchor the Giants’ rotation, but after that the picture gets murky. McGreevy, meanwhile, gave the Cardinals a steady season in 2026, finishing with a 3.95 ERA and 1.9 fWAR, the same fWAR total Schmitt posted.
After that year, the “Dealin’ the Cards” podcast made the case for moving McGreevy because of St. Louis’ pitching depth.
There are reasons a team might hesitate on McGreevy. His pitch-to-contact style can make clubs nervous, just as Busch Stadium can.
But Oracle Park is also known as a pitcher-friendly environment, which makes the match more interesting. The Cardinals, though, were much better defensively than the Giants in 2026, and that kind of support could matter for McGreevy.
If St. Louis did move him, the early-season rotation picture would likely include Kyle Leahy, Andre Pallante, Quinn Mathews and Matthew Liberatore, with a low-cost free agent such as former Cardinals prospect Zac Gallen potentially filling a temporary role in the first half a la Dustin May until Tekoah Roby, Richard Fitts or another arm is ready.
Schmitt is entering his first year of arbitration eligibility and is projected to make around $2.5 million, a price the Cardinals can handle even with several players headed for arbitration raises.
A one-for-one trade is not the usual way baseball works, but this one has the ingredients. Both clubs have young, controllable players who could help the other side right away. If the Cardinals trust their new hitting setup under Joel McKeithan to clean up Schmitt’s approach, he could be a useful piece in 2027 and beyond.
In Other News...
Cardinals Just Gave Fans Two New Prospects To Watch Closely
The Cardinals used their latest minor league honors to shine a light on a pair of rising names in the system, with catcher Rainiel Rodriguez and left-hander Mason Molina earning the organizations top player and pitcher awards for 2026. It is the kind of recognition that usually says as much about steady development as it does about raw production, and both players spent the season giving St. Louis plenty to like as they moved through Double-A Springfield and High-A Peoria.
Rodriguezs bat made him impossible to ignore, while Molina drew notice for the way he handled his work on the mound. For a Cardinals organization that always seems to be balancing the present with the next wave of talent, these awards are another reminder that there are prospects worth tracking closely, even if the bigger league picture still has a few layers to sort out. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Add Lefty Bullpen Depth With A Real Chance To Push This Spring
The Cardinals appear to be adding another left-handed arm to the mix, with social media reports indicating the club has agreed to a minor league deal with Steven Perez and invited him to spring training. Perez, a former Cleveland Guardians prospect, has worked his way as high as Triple-A but has not yet made his major league debut, giving St. Louis a low-risk look at a pitcher who is still trying to carve out his path.
For a bullpen that is always in search of useful depth, the appeal is obvious: a live lefty with some upper-level experience and a chance to make an impression in camp. The Cardinals have not officially announced the signing, but if the report holds, Perez will get an early opportunity this spring to show whether he can turn that minor league invitation into something more meaningful. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Face A Telling Alec Burleson Decision This Offseason
Alec Burlesons offseason has already become a meaningful subplot for the Cardinals, with Greg Amsinger of MLB Network reporting that St. Louis has put an extension offer on the table. The sides have not reached an agreement yet, but the fact that the club is engaging Burleson now says plenty about how it views him as part of its longer-term picture.
For a Cardinals team trying to sort out its next wave of core pieces, the timing matters. Burleson is the kind of player whose future can shape how the roster is built around him, and the uncertainty leaves one of the organizations cleaner decisions hanging in the balance. Around the game, there is also a familiar Cardinals name in Albert Pujols, who was a finalist for the Astros managerial opening before Brad Ausmus got the job, and who is now working in the Angels organization as another vacancy could soon open there. [Read more 🡒]
