Cardinals Face A Tough Catching Decision As Young Depth Keeps Rising

Despite a crowded roster and a lackluster performance, the Cardinals surprisingly held onto their struggling veteran catcher amidst roster changes.

The Cardinals made one clean cut on Friday, moving on from Nolan Gorman and pitcher Max Rajcic, but the roster decision that really stands out is the one they didn’t make.

Every other player who was up for a contract was tendered for the 2027 season, yet there’s a strong case that St. Louis should have added one more name to the non-tender list.

The issue isn’t just performance. It’s the logjam behind the plate.

The 28-year-old catcher was the Opening Day starter and handled a large share of the work for most of the 2025 season. Inside the organization, his game-calling and pitch framing drew praise, and he also brings a solid arm. But the bat never gave the Cardinals enough.

He finished at .217/.275/.312 with four home runs, 12 RBI and a .588 OPS, production that left too much to be desired for a team looking for more offense from the position.

The bigger problem is what comes next. St.

Louis has too many catchers and not enough innings to spread around. Leo Bernal broke through late in the season, and as a switch-hitter with power, he has started to look like the catcher of the future.

Ivan Herrera’s defense may be shaky, but his bat profiles as everyday material, and he’ll be needed behind the plate whenever Bernal gets a day off.

Then there’s Rainiel Rodriguez, who is moving quickly through the farm system and doesn’t appear far from pushing for a roster spot himself.

That leaves Pages in an awkward spot. There just doesn’t seem to be enough room for him to carve out an everyday role in St. Louis, and that kind of squeeze can bury a player in a crowded catching group.

If the Cardinals had cut him loose, another club in need of catching help might have been able to give him a chance to play every day. St.

Louis may still be keeping him around in hopes of finding a trade partner, but any return would likely be modest. For now, Pages remains a name to watch as the Cardinals sort through an overloaded position.

In Other News...

Cardinals Could Chase Gunnar Henderson For One Huge Reason

The Cardinals offseason may end up looking more like a trade hunt than a free-agent shopping spree, and thats where Gunnar Henderson has entered the conversation. St. Louis has roster needs to address, and if the front office decides to chase impact talent on the market, Henderson fits the kind of player who would instantly change the discussion around the lineup and the long-term outlook.

There is a catch, of course, and it is the kind that usually decides whether these ideas stay in the rumor file or become real. Hendersons recent performance makes him exactly the sort of target a team would want, but prying him loose would not be simple, and any serious pursuit would force the Cardinals to weigh how much of their prospect depth they are willing to move for one player. [Read more 🡒]

Cardinals Dream 2027 Roster Hinges On One Aggressive Pitching Bet

A lot can change between now and 2027, but the Cardinals long-view roster exercise starts with a simple idea: build around the core pieces already in place, then get aggressive where the pitching still needs help. The projection keeps familiar names in the mix on the position-player side while treating the staff as the area most likely to be reshaped, with the bullpen picture already sketched out around Riley OBrien, Luis Gastelum and a new face in Sean Newcomb.

The real swing factor is whether St. Louis is willing to make a bold move to land the kind of arm that changes the ceiling of the whole group. In this version of the future, that means exploring a trade market that could cost a notable young catcher and pairing it with another major addition to stabilize the rotation, a plan that would make the Cardinals 2027 outlook look a whole lot more ambitious if it ever came together. [Read more 🡒]

Nolan Gorman Just Reached A Cardinals Crossroads

Nolan Gormans 2026 season left the Cardinals with more questions than answers, and not just about his bat. The 26-year-old struggled to produce in both St. Louis and Triple-A, a frustrating follow-up for a player the organization has long viewed as part of its future core, even as the results have lagged behind the expectations.

Now the club is weighing what comes next for a hitter whose development has been under close scrutiny for a while. President of baseball operations Chaim Bloom has acknowledged Gormans struggles and said the organization is still evaluating where he stands, which puts the Cardinals in a familiar but uncomfortable spot with a young player who still has talent, but no clear safety net. [Read more 🡒]