The Cardinals may need help at third base this winter, but Alec Bohm is hardly the cleanest answer.
St. Louis cycled through options at the hot corner this season, and none of them really stuck.
Nolan Gorman didn’t seize the job after Nolan Arenado was traded away, and the club also failed to find much consistency with Blaze Jordan or Thomas Saggese. That leaves the Cardinals with a real offseason question, especially with the free-agent market at third base looking thin.
Derrick Goold of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch didn’t dismiss the Bohm fit outright, though he made clear there’s a major obstacle. As he put it:
"The Cardinals are in open to a short-term answer at third base that clears the way for their next homegrown player to take over there. That is where the Bohm-Cardinals speculation will rest and has rested and it will continue if Bohm is interested in a 'pillow deal' to restore his value through playing time he’ll need and performance."
He added:
"The catch isn’t the Cardinals reluctance to sign a position player as a free agent; it’s what he’d bring and what they value and the questions on his defense, which as you know by now the Cardinals are still going to value. That needs to be part of any speculation connecting the two."
That defensive piece is the sticking point. Baseball Savant has Bohm at minus-8 Outs Above Average at third base and minus-9 in run value defensively. For a Cardinals team that still places real weight on glove work, that’s a tough profile to sell as a true upgrade.
The bat is solid, but not exactly loud enough to erase the concerns. Bohm hit .249/.315/.383 with 15 home runs, 88 RBI and a .698 OPS. He does bring right-handed power, yet the overall offensive line doesn’t separate him much from the pack.
Even if St. Louis were interested, Bohm would only fit as a short-term stopgap.
He could also be a trade candidate at the deadline, especially if players like Jesus Baez are close to the majors by then. The Cardinals are also giving Rainiel Rodriguez a shot at third base, which underscores that Bohm would not be viewed as the long-term answer.
So the idea isn’t dead, but it comes with plenty of baggage. The Cardinals can look at Bohm. Whether they actually go there is another matter, and his defense will be a big part of that decision.
In Other News...
Jordan Walker Just Raised A Big Cardinals Question
Jordan Walkers 2026 season gave the Cardinals plenty to feel good about, and maybe even a little urgency to think bigger. The young outfielder became an All-Star and a Hank Aaron Award finalist while playing a career-high 158 games, finishing with a .269 batting average, 22 home runs and 102 RBIs. For a player who has already been viewed as a central piece of the franchises future, that kind of year changes the conversation from promise to expectation.
The next step for St. Louis is figuring out what Walkers production means in practical terms, especially with his growth still ongoing and his profile continuing to evolve. There is still room for improvement in key areas, but seasons like this tend to force teams to confront tougher questions about timing, value and whether a long-term deal makes sense before the price gets even higher. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Fans Just Got A Painful Reminder About That Brewers Trade
The Brewers 2-0 NLCS lead over the Dodgers came with a sharp reminder for Cardinals fans of how much the deadline deal has meant in Milwaukee. Former St. Louis pitchers Dustin May and JoJo Romero were part of a bullpen effort that delivered a record-setting run of perfect relief innings, exactly the kind of October performance that can make a trade look especially costly in the moment.
From the Cardinals side, though, the move was never just about this postseason. St. Louis turned those veterans into young talent for the future, and the organization still views the swap as a win-win even if the optics right now favor Milwaukee. October has a way of amplifying every deadline decision, and this one is no exception. [Read more 🡒]
Victor Scott II Faces A Big Cardinals Test This Winter
Victor Scott IIs path with the Cardinals has taken an unexpected turn after he lost the starting center field job to Nathan Church, a reminder of how quickly young players can find themselves squeezed by performance and roster timing. Scotts defensive speed still gives him a chance to matter in St. Louis, but two straight seasons of offensive struggles have forced the organization to look elsewhere for steady production in the outfield.
This winter is his next opportunity to reset. Scott is heading to the Dominican Professional Baseball League to get more at-bats and try to sharpen the part of his game that has lagged behind his tools, while the Cardinals keep moving forward with a crowded future outfield picture. With playing time looking harder to come by, the bigger question may not be just whether Scott bounces back, but whether there will still be a clean path for him in St. Louis if he does. [Read more 🡒]