The Cardinals may not have many catching questions left, but Pedro Pages sits right at the center of the one that matters most.
St. Louis spent the 2026 season trying to sort out its roster, and the club can at least say it learned something at almost every spot.
That includes catcher, where the picture has shifted from a crowded mix to something much clearer. Leo Bernal has surged since his debut and has moved ahead of the rest of the organization’s backstops, putting himself in position as the option 1a for 2027.
That leaves the Cardinals with a real decision this winter. The catching group that opened the year with Ivan Herrera, Pages, and Yohel Pozo has already been reshaped once, and it may be headed for another change.
At the start of the season, the Cardinals planned to split time fairly evenly between Herrera and Pages, with Pozo handling late-game offense. They stuck with that arrangement for a long stretch before finally turning to Jimmy Crooks to give the lefty hitter a shot at the starting job. That move came as the Cardinals fell in the standings and Herrera’s throwing issues kept lingering.
Crooks then joined Herrera and Pages in the mix, with Pages pushed into a limited bench role. That setup lasted until Crooks began to struggle with contact and Bernal forced his way into the conversation in Memphis. The Cardinals made the swap, kept Herrera and Pages in their same roles, and Bernal took off from there.
Unlike Crooks, Bernal seized the opportunity and now looks like the catcher of the future. Crooks has done well again in Memphis, and Rainiel Rodriguez has kept climbing into the discussion as one of the top prospects in baseball. That kind of depth gives the Cardinals flexibility, and it also raises the possibility that one of these catchers has to go to clear room elsewhere.
Pages looks like the most obvious candidate. He is 28, defense-first, and carries a career 75 wRC+.
His bat also took a noticeable step back in a split role this season. Even with the offense and pitching both underperforming while Crooks and Bernal were productive in Memphis, the Cardinals never moved off Pages in the majors.
That could change now. Bernal’s rise, Crooks’ upside, and Rodriguez’s surge may push the front office toward a different answer this winter. Pages, because he seems to be close to his ceiling, may not bring much extra value to the big league roster beyond what he already provides.
What St. Louis does with him could reveal the rest of the plan.
If Pages is traded, Crooks could become Bernal’s backup. If Pages stays, Crooks could emerge as the trade candidate, with Pages backing up Bernal in a limited role again.
However it plays out, the decision could ripple further down the line and affect Rodriguez, too.
In Other News...
Cardinals Face A Rebuild Defining Choice At Third Base
Third base is shaping up as one of the more important decisions on the Cardinals road map to 2027, with the front office already looking ahead to how the position can help lift the offense. St. Louis is expected to explore both internal answers and outside help as it tries to improve the lineup, and the fit there will say plenty about what kind of roster it wants to build next.
Two very different names sit near the center of that conversation. Eugenio Suarez brings the kind of power that can change a game with one swing, while Luis Arraez offers a contact-heavy profile and the flexibility to move around the infield. The Cardinals do not have to choose immediately, but the direction they take at third could become a defining part of this rebuild. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Face An Uncomfortable Nolan Gorman Decision This Offseason
The Cardinals go into the offseason with a roster that looks far less ripe for turnover than it did a year ago, which makes their decisions more pointed than plentiful. Most of the club is young and under team control through 2027, leaving St. Louis with only a handful of obvious avenues to reshape the roster, and that puts a spotlight on the players who no longer fit cleanly into the long-term picture.
Nolan Gorman sits at the center of that conversation after an uneven season that ended with a Triple-A demotion. With other internal options available at third base, the Cardinals are weighing whether to try to move him in a trade rather than let the situation drift toward a non-tender and free agency, a choice that would say plenty about how quickly the organization is willing to pivot from a once-promising bat. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Face An Offseason Temptation That Could Derail Their Progress
The Cardinals are heading into an offseason that could say as much about their direction as any move they made during the season. With a young core in place, a strong farm system behind it and Chaim Bloom now entering his second year running baseball operations, the organization has reason to feel good about where it stands. Bloom has stressed patience and discipline as the club looks to build on its 2026 progress, even as the temptation grows to accelerate the timeline.
St. Louis does want to add veteran pitching and stay in the hunt for a Wild Card spot, which is where the tension comes in. The challenge is making those upgrades without getting pulled away from the long-term plan that has given the Cardinals a clearer foundation than theyve had in a while. Bloom called it a dangerous time to lose focus, and for a team trying to win now without shortchanging what comes next, the line between aggressiveness and drift may be awfully thin. [Read more 🡒]