Cardinals Face A Bigger Alec Burleson Decision Than Fans Realize

The Cardinals look to secure their future by eyeing a long-term deal with breakout star Alec Burleson, underscoring his growing importance to the team's strategy.

The Cardinals have a clear candidate for a long-term deal in Alec Burleson, and the interest appears to go both ways.

Derrick Goold of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported that St.

Louis and Burleson have mutual interest in an extension. That lines up with where the first baseman stands after two straight seasons of strong production, and it also fits the club’s quick decision to shut down trade interest in him.

Burleson had already said he was open to a long-term contract.

Burleson’s path to this point started when the Cardinals took him in the compensatory round of the 2020 draft with the No. 70 overall pick. He reached the majors in 2022 but saw limited action, then posted an 89 wRC+ in 347 plate appearances in 2023.

The next year brought a real jump. He hit 21 home runs and slashed .269/.314/.420 over 595 plate appearances, good for a 106 wRC+, while striking out only 12.8% of the time despite a modest walk rate.

Then came the breakout. In 2025, Burleson batted .290/.343/.459 with a 124 wRC+ in 139 games, missing just ten days late in the year because of right wrist inflammation.

His average exit velocity climbed from 89.7 mph to 91.0 mph, and his isolated power rose by 17 points. This season, he was nearly the same player at the plate, finishing with a 125 wRC+, a career-best 8.2% walk rate and an 18.1% strikeout rate that still sat better than average.

He also settled in as a full-time first baseman after previously bouncing between the outfield, designated hitter and first base.

By wRC+, Burleson ranked among the top 10 first basemen with at least 450 plate appearances this year. He turns 28 in three days, and that combination of age and performance makes him an obvious extension target for a Cardinals team that could use him as part of its next contender.

The timing matters, too. St.

Louis controls Burleson for two more years through arbitration, and MLBTR contributor Matt Swartz projects he’ll make around $8.3MM in 2027. The Cardinals’ payroll picture is relatively open, with our Payroll Tracker showing them at $73.9MM in cash payroll next year, ahead of only the Nationals at $52.2MM on the low end.

Their long-term books are also fairly clean, with JJ Wetherholt’s eight-year, $112.5MM extension the only guaranteed contract on the roster. Wetherholt had less than a year of service time when he signed, while Burleson already has more than four years and is two seasons from free agency.

If the Cardinals want to keep him beyond arbitration, they’d need to buy out at least one free-agent year, which means any new deal would have to run at least three years. Recent first-base extensions for players with Burleson’s service-time range have been rare. In the last five years, there have been only two: Yandy Diaz’s three-year, $24MM deal with the Rays in January 2023, and Matt Olson’s eight-year, $168MM extension with the Braves in March 2022.

That leaves a pretty broad window for what a Burleson agreement could look like. He should land above Diaz, but he doesn’t have Olson’s track record.

A four-year deal around the Josh Naylor average annual value of $18.5MM would be a logical place to start. That kind of contract would keep Burleson and Wetherholt on the right side of the infield together through at least 2030, while still allowing Burleson to hit the market in his age-32 season.

For St. Louis, the bigger question may be how it sees its next competitive window.

The Cardinals finished with 78 wins in 2025 and 77 this year. If the organization wants to lock in pieces for the stretch around 2028-29, Burleson could be one of the first names it tries to secure.

Shortstop Masyn Winn and right fielder Jordan Walker could also be candidates for extension talks.

In Other News...

Cardinals Bullpen Need Makes This Available Strikeout Arm Hard To Ignore

The Cardinals bullpen issues have lingered throughout the 2026 season, and that has kept the front office looking for arms that can miss bats and handle leverage. One name that fits the profile is a recently available right-handed reliever who just finished a strong year with the Yankees, where he worked to a 3.13 ERA and showed the kind of strikeout ability that can change late innings in a hurry.

For St. Louis, the appeal goes beyond the surface numbers. The club needs help in a relief mix that has not been steady enough, and this pitchers style suggests he could slot into that conversation quickly if the Cardinals decide to get aggressive in free agency. The question now is whether they see him as the kind of arm worth prioritizing, especially with other teams likely to be eyeing the same sort of upside. [Read more 🡒]

Cardinals Face One Big Jackson Holliday Trade Problem

Jackson Holliday remains the kind of name that naturally draws attention in any trade discussion, and it is easy to see why the Cardinals would have interest if Baltimore ever made him available. St. Louis has spent plenty of time trying to find the right offensive fit around its core, and the appeal here is obvious: a young infielder with pedigree, upside, and room to grow, paired with a Cardinals hitting staff that has a history of trying to unlock more from talented bats.

The challenge is figuring out how a deal like that could even come together. Baltimore has every reason to want controllable pitching back in return, which puts the Cardinals in a familiar spot of balancing ambition against cost. If the Orioles were to listen, the conversation would likely center on useful, lower-cost pieces rather than the kind of premium prospect haul that usually comes with a player of Hollidays profile, and that is where the real tension in any potential swap begins. [Read more 🡒]

Cardinals Face A Tough Catching Decision As Young Depth Keeps Rising

The Cardinals have already made one notable roster move this winter by non-tendering Nolan Gorman and pitcher Max Rajcic, and the next decisions could be just as revealing about where the organization thinks its depth is strongest. Catching is one of those spots, with the club continuing to sort through which players fit long term and which ones may be squeezed out as the pipeline keeps getting deeper.

Pedro Pages is part of that conversation, but not an easy one. His offensive production has been inconsistent enough to leave his standing in question, even as other catchers in the system keep pushing for bigger roles. St. Louis does not appear ready to settle the issue yet, and the way it handles the position could say plenty about how it views the balance between present need and future upside. [Read more 🡒]