The Cardinals didn’t get much help from Dustin May after bringing him in on a one-year deal last offseason, but they did get enough to stabilize a rotation spot before moving him at the trade deadline. That’s part of why the deal with Milwaukee looks better for St. Louis now than it did in the moment.
Dayn Perry of CBS Sports put together a list of trade deadline wins and losses, and May’s move landed on the wrong side for the Brewers. Perry called out the price Milwaukee paid and the fact that the right-hander still hasn’t delivered in his new uniform.
"Acquired from the division-rival Cardinals at significant cost, May, a pending free agent, has not delivered so far as a Brewer," Perry wrote. "In five post-trade starts, May has put up an ERA of 6.41 in five trips to the mound since the trade, and he's averaged less than five innings per start over that span.
The stuff and underlying fundamentals with the Cardinals were strong, so this is probably just the small sample size at work. As well, the Brewers are a pitching-forward organization - one of the best at such things.
Thus far, though, May hasn't been the fortifying addition they hoped he'd be. "
Before the deadline, May had been giving St. Louis exactly what it needed. He went 6-9 with a 4.69 ERA in 26 starts and 128 2/3 innings pitched, serving as a steady mid-rotation arm even if he wasn’t dominating lineups.
The Cardinals sent May and JoJo Romero to Milwaukee on deadline day, and in return they landed two prospects who have already helped deepen the organization’s future. Outfielders Alexander Frias and Josiah Ragsdale were described as elite prospects, and the move has only strengthened a farm system that needed the boost.
That’s why this trade now reads as a smart step forward for St. Louis.
The Cardinals could still use another starter with Andre Pallante and Hunter Dobbins out, and Dobbins is also expected to miss most of 2027 after surgery. Even so, St.
Louis was never built like a true contender this season, and the deadline deal fit that reality.
What the Cardinals have now is a stronger pipeline and a brighter outlook than they’ve had in quite a while, and the return for May and Romero is a big reason why. It’s also a sign of how Chaim Bloom is reshaping the organization.
In Other News...
Cardinals Trade Regret Keeps Growing At Their Biggest Weak Spot
The Cardinals decision to move Tommy Edman in a three-team deal with the Dodgers and White Sox was supposed to help them patch a playoff race without giving up the kind of prospects they wanted to keep. St. Louis came away with Erick Fedde and Tommy Pham, and it briefly looked like a win-now gamble that fit the moment, especially with the organization trying to squeeze value out of the roster it had built.
Now the long view looks far less kind. Miguel Vargas, the young third baseman sent to Chicago in the swap, has developed into one of baseballs best hitters in 2026, while the Cardinals have continued to search for stability at third base. The part of the deal that once felt like a manageable price has become a reminder of a bigger issue for St. Louis, especially after the club eventually shifted away from pushing for immediate contention and toward a rebuild. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Just Took A Rotation Hit That Changes One Recent Trade
The Cardinals pitching depth took a jolt this week when Hunter Dobbins underwent elbow reconstructive surgery Wednesday, a setback that changes the picture for one of the clubs more recent trade additions. Dobbins had given St. Louis a useful stretch before the injury, posting a 3.67 ERA in 11 appearances this season, and his arrival had offered another arm to help stabilize a rotation that can never seem to have enough certainty.
Instead, the focus now turns to recovery, with a Cardinals official saying he will face a 12-month rehabilitation period after his second surgery on the same right elbow. The timetable points to him missing the rest of the 2026 season and most of 2027, leaving St. Louis to rethink how it fills the innings it expected to get from him and how this move fits into the broader plan for the staff. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Suddenly Face A Riley O'Brien Decision They Can't Ignore
Riley OBriens recent stretch has turned a once-comfortable Cardinals bullpen discussion into a real point of tension. The St. Louis closer, who entered the season as one of the National Leagues most reliable finishers and earned an All-Star nod, had built a strong case with a 2.94 ERA through 53 appearances before things started to wobble.
Over his last five outings, OBrien has been hit hard, allowing multiple runs and carrying a far less forgiving ERA across that span. It has forced the Cardinals to at least consider whether the ninth inning needs a different look, even if his broader body of work argues for patience and a little more time to sort through the rough patch. [Read more 🡒]