The St. Louis Cardinals may not be done shopping for familiar faces this offseason.
Dustin May has already been floated as a possible reunion target, but he is not the only former Cardinal who could fit the club’s plans. MLB.com’s Will Leitch pointed to Jack Flaherty as another name that makes sense for St. Louis as the team looks to keep building for 2027.
“Perhaps a reunion would make some sense for both parties. Flaherty is no longer the electric young phenom he was seven years ago, but he still has good stuff, with a 26% strikeout rate in 88 1/3 innings in 2026,” Leitch wrote.
“Flaherty didn’t pitch much this year because he went on the IL in July with right forearm flexor inflammation and didn’t return until the season’s final day. He just turned 31, which is relatively young, and only slightly older than May was when he signed his deal with St.
Louis last year.”
May signed a one-year contract with an option last December, and Flaherty could be looking at a similar kind of arrangement.
For the Cardinals, the appeal is pretty clear. The starting rotation is a spot they can upgrade, and Flaherty brings a track record in St.
Louis that still carries weight. He started his career there in 2017 and even picked up Cy Young votes after a dominant second half in 2019.
Health, though, is the big question. Injuries became an issue for him in 2021, and that will be part of any conversation the Cardinals have about bringing him back.
In 2026, Flaherty made 19 starts and one relief appearance for the Detroit Tigers, finishing 3-8 with a 4.48 ERA while striking out 103 batters in 88 1/3 innings.
If he stays on the field, he could make sense as a fit for where St. Louis is right now.
He could also become a trade candidate if the season goes sideways. And with Busch Stadium’s pitcher-friendly setup, there’s a case that he could benefit from the environment.
Flaherty also arrives with some notable October experience. He helped the Los Angeles Dodgers win the World Series in 2024, and he was the winning pitcher in the clinching Game 5 of the NLDS for St. Louis in 2019.
If the Cardinals do pursue him, the price tag may not be far off from what May received a year ago.
In Other News...
Cardinals Have 3 Obvious Low Cost Fixes To Debate Right Now
The Cardinals offseason search for low-cost help is already taking shape well before the winter market opens, and the board includes a few names that fit the clubs needs without forcing a major financial commitment. Jason Adam brings the kind of steady relief profile teams value late in games, Tyrone Taylor offers a possible answer in center field, and Ryan Yarbrough stands out for his durability and unusual pitching look. Each would give St. Louis a different way to patch a roster hole while keeping the payroll plan intact.
What makes these options worth debating is how modestly they could reshape the roster if the Cardinals decide to be aggressive on the margins rather than chase a headline move. Adam would deepen the bullpen, Taylor could stabilize the outfield, and Yarbrough would add innings with a different look than most rotation depth options provide. The real question is which path best matches the Cardinals priorities, because all three point to the same idea: finding useful production without paying premium prices. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Fans Found A New Reason To Feel Good All Season
For Cardinals fans, the good feelings this season did not stop on the field. The clubs television broadcast team drew a bigger audience across the board, with Chip Caray and Brad Thompson landing third in baseballs broadcast rankings while posting a 4.98 household rating and a 29% jump in total viewership.
The numbers got even stronger around the edges of game day, with pregame and postgame shows also seeing meaningful gains along with streaming subscriptions. Caray helped frame the seasons early success and some of the biggest moments along the way, and the audience response suggests Cardinals viewers stayed locked in from first pitch to the final wrap. [Read more 🡒]