The St. Louis Cardinals’ 2026 deadline sell-off already produced real value, and one of the pieces who left town may be the easiest winter target to circle back on.
Dustin May is expected to hit free agency again this offseason, with a mutual option that is all but certain to be turned down. That puts the Cardinals right back in the market for a veteran starter, and May’s name has already surfaced as a possible reunion. MLB.com’s Will Leitch laid out the case for it.
"May still has a lively fastball and is relatively young compared to the market, as he won’t turn 30 until next September. You could argue that he still has a bit more to prove, and perhaps a return to St. Louis could help both parties once again," Leitch wrote.
The fit is easy to see from the Cardinals’ side. St. Louis is still rebuilding under president of baseball operations Chaim Bloom, and the club added two interesting prospects in the trade with the Milwaukee Brewers that sent May and JoJo Romero to the National League Central champs: No. 5 prospect Alexander Frias and No. 11 prospect Josiah Ragsdale.
May’s run in St. Louis was solid, even if it came in a season shaped by the larger decision to move him at the deadline.
He posted a 4.38 ERA across 21 starts, with a 106-to-35 strikeout-to-walk ratio over 109 innings. More importantly for the Cardinals, he stayed healthy and showed the kind of ability that once powered his breakout with the Los Angeles Dodgers.
The Brewers version of May was a different story. He put up a 5.65 ERA in 10 regular-season starts, then logged a 5.63 ERA in the playoffs over four appearances, including one start. The production hasn’t matched the tools, but the health has been there, and that matters for a pitcher whose career was defined by injuries from 2021 through the 2025 season.
Money should not stand in the way of a return, either. Last winter, the Cardinals gave May a one-year, $12.5 million deal with a $20 million mutual option. After his 31 starts and 4.70 ERA in the playoffs, a similar price range looks reasonable again.
And if St. Louis again finds itself in the middle of a rough 2027 season, the Cardinals could use the same formula that worked this year: sign a veteran, get innings, and, if necessary, move him at the deadline.
May already proved he can be part of that kind of plan. This winter, there’s a strong case for calling him and seeing whether he wants to run it back.
In Other News...
Matthew Liberatore Put The Cardinals In A Tough Offseason Spot
Matthew Liberatore gave the Cardinals a heavy workload in 2026, taking the ball for 31 starts and logging 155 innings, but the season did not leave St. Louis with an easy read on where he fits next. His run prevention slipped, his opponent OPS climbed and the numbers pointed to a pitcher who had a harder time as games went deeper, especially when hitters saw him multiple times.
The bigger concern is what happened when his secondary pitches lost their bite, because that opened the door for right-handed hitters and made the rest of his profile look far less stable. St. Louis now has to decide whether that means a move to the bullpen, a trade possibility or simply a different role inside the organization, even though Liberatore is expected to be around next season in some capacity. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals May Have Found A Faster Path For Rainiel Rodriguez
Rainiel Rodriguez turned enough heads with a breakout 2026 season to push himself all the way to Double-A, and now the Cardinals are looking at an even more aggressive way to move their top prospect along. Rodriguez is still a catcher by trade, but St. Louis has been willing to test him at third base, a spot that could give his bat a clearer route to the majors and address an area where the organization has less depth.
Cardinals president of baseball operations Chaim Bloom confirmed Rodriguez has taken reps there, which is enough to show this is more than idle speculation. The appeal is obvious: if Rodriguez can handle a new position, the Cardinals may be able to keep his offensive momentum moving while removing some of the traffic jam that often slows a young catchers climb. The real question is whether the organization pushes that experiment far enough to change his long-term path. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Fans Get A Tough Reality Check On This Rebuild
The Cardinals spent much of the season hanging around the wild card picture, but the broader message from Chaim Bloom was a sobering one for a fan base used to thinking in October terms. He made clear that St. Louis is still in the middle of a rebuild, and that the organization is focused on laying a stronger foundation rather than chasing quick fixes that might look good in the moment but not hold up over time.
Blooms framing matters because it speaks directly to where the Cardinals are in the bigger picture: competitive enough to stay relevant, but not yet at the level needed to make a real World Series push. The caution now is not to rush the process, even if the temptation is there after spending so long in the race, because the front office believes long-term sustainability has to come before any serious championship hopes. [Read more 🡒]