If Fernando Tatis Jr. is actually out there, the Cardinals ought to be in the mix.
That’s the kind of swing St. Louis has made for generations, and the track record is obvious.
Ozzie Smith, Lou Brock, Willie McGee, Mark McGwire, Jim Edmonds, Scott Rolen, Matt Holliday, Paul Goldschmidt, Nolan Arenado - the Cardinals have long built around stars brought in from outside the organization. Tatis would fit that mold in a hurry.
The Padres’ situation is what makes this even worth talking about. San Diego has new ownership, major financial uncertainty ahead, and enough bad contracts on the books to make any clean solution difficult. USA Today’s Bob Nightengale has already raised the possibility that Tatis Jr. or Mason Miller could surface as trade candidates, and AJ Preller is once again the executive everyone is watching to see how creative he gets.
There’s also a Cardinals angle here that goes beyond the rumor mill. Fernando Tatis, Jr.’s father, Fernando Tatis, played for St.
Louis years ago. The Cardinals also had a chance to sign Tatis as an amateur free agent before the Chicago White Sox beat them to it with a better offer.
That miss still stings, but it doesn’t mean Chaim Bloom can’t bring him to St. Louis now, in the middle of his prime.
Tatis won’t turn 28 until January, and he has been one of baseball’s most productive players since debuting in 2019. He has never finished a season with an fWAR below 3.0, and he’s coming off three straight years with a wRC+ above 130 while also providing elite defense.
There is, though, a Busch Stadium question hanging over the whole idea. Petco Park in 2026 ranked third for home runs by right-handed hitters and 15th in park factor for righties.
Busch Stadium, by contrast, ranked 24th in park factor for right-handed hitters and allowed the second-fewest homers to right-handed bats. Some of that is tied to the Cardinals’ lack of right-handed power, but it’s still part of the evaluation.
Even with that concern, Tatis brings a level of defensive flexibility that few stars can match. He started his big-league career at shortstop, moved to the outfield, and in 2026 split time between second base and right field. Third base would not be out of the question either, and that kind of versatility would give the Cardinals room to move pieces around depending on how the roster settles.
The contract is the obvious hurdle. Tatis has eight years and $266 million left, and the final six seasons run from ages 30 through 36 at $36 million per year. He also has a full no-trade clause through the 2028 season, and after that he can submit a list of 10-13 teams each year that he would not want to join.
Still, the market may not be as crowded as it once would have been. The Dodgers, Mets, Yankees, Phillies, and other clubs in that tier may not be eager to make a huge commitment right now if the sport is moving toward a new salary cap era and those teams need to trim payroll instead of adding to it while surrendering premium prospect capital. That’s part of why the Cardinals could have an opening.
St. Louis also has something many teams do not: flexibility.
Right now, the Cardinals only have JJ Wetherholt under a long-term deal on the roster. That gives them room to chase a major addition, though it also means they have to be careful not to do something reckless.
Tatis, at least on paper, doesn’t feel reckless.
They also have the kind of asset base that could make a serious run without gutting the organization. The Cardinals could put together a package built around cost-controlled young players and prospects, and they could even leave themselves with a strong farm system and young core afterward. If needed, they could also structure an offer that helps San Diego pay down part of the contract.
On the major-league side, St. Louis could offer Masyn Winn, Ivan Herrera, Joshua Baez, Jimmy Crooks, or even Jordan Walker. On the pitching side, Kyle Leahy and Michael McGreevy would also fit the kind of cost-conscious return San Diego might want.
The prospect pool gives them even more room to maneuver. If the Padres wanted an outfielder, the Cardinals could point to Tai Peete, Josiah Ragsdale, Alexander Frias, Trevor Condon, Emmanuel Luna, Won-Bin Cho, and more.
If they wanted catching help, Sammy Hernandez or Crooks would be in the conversation. For infield depth, there’s Jesus Baez, Rocco Maniscalco, Yairo Padilla, Sebastian Dos Santos, Miguel Hernandez, Jack Gurevitch, and more.
And the pitching options run deep too: Tanner Franklin, Liam Doyle, Brandon Clarke, Tegan Kuhns, Daniel Eagen, Jurrangelo Cijntje, Yhoiker Fajardo, Quinn Mathews, Tekoah Roby, Cooper Hjerpe, Jacob Odle, Mason Molina, Sandro Santana, Brian Curley, and more.
That’s why this is the sort of opportunity the Cardinals should at least explore. Whether they should actually close the deal is another question entirely. But if they believe Tatis can be one of the centerpieces of the next good Cardinals team, the combination of payroll flexibility and prospect depth gives them a real path to make the move.
In Other News...
Cardinals Face A Delicate Pitching Balance This Offseason
The Cardinals are heading into the offseason with a fairly clear pitching checklist, even if the exact names remain fluid. The rotation has a promising young core, but St. Louis is still expected to shop for a starter with upside while also looking at one or two veteran relievers to steady the bullpen. It is the kind of balancing act front offices face when they want to improve now without boxing out the younger arms they hope will matter down the line.
There is also a specific opening to address after the departure of Dustin May, which adds a little urgency to the search. Free agency has already produced a familiar list of possibilities for the Cardinals, including Kris Bubic, Casey Mize, Shota Imanaga and Jack Flaherty, but no moves have been made yet. For now, the plan seems to be as much about fit and timing as it is about talent, with St. Louis trying to strengthen the staff without clogging the path for its next wave of pitchers. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Interest In J.P. Crawford Sparks A Bigger Third Base Debate
The Cardinals search for help at third base has opened the door to an interesting possibility in J.P. Crawford, whose bat against right-handed pitching makes him a plausible platoon fit. On paper, he would give St. Louis a more established option at a spot where the club has been weighing short-term stability against long-term development.
But any move in that direction would come with a familiar cost: fewer reps for Blaze Jordan and Thomas Saggese, two young players the organization seems intent on evaluating. Crawford could make the lineup look cleaner in the moment, yet the Cardinals may decide the bigger priority is keeping those at-bats available for the younger group rather than narrowing the path with another veteran stopgap. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals May Reunion Could Be Tougher Than Fans Expected
The Cardinals long-range pitching picture already has a few familiar pieces in place, with three arms viewed as likely members of the 2027 rotation and more internal options still in the mix. That makes any outside addition a matter of fit as much as talent, and it is why the idea of bringing back Dustin May has lingered around the conversation. Mays past with St. Louis only adds to the appeal, especially for fans who remember him before he was dealt to the Milwaukee Brewers.
Derrick Goold of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch has pointed out the catch, though, and it is a significant one: May is looking for a multi-year contract, and that is not the kind of commitment the Cardinals appear ready to make right now. So while the reunion idea is easy to understand from a baseball and emotional standpoint, the market may be pushing it into tougher territory than some expected. For a club trying to balance present needs with future payroll flexibility, that could be the difference between a nice fit and a deal that never gets close. [Read more 🡒]