Cardinals Catching Logjam Could Force A Tough Jimmy Crooks Decision

Amid a catching surplus, the St. Louis Cardinals may part with underperforming Jimmy Crooks to address roster needs elsewhere.

The Cardinals’ catching surplus keeps pointing back to the same name, and this winter it’s Jimmy Crooks who looks like the likeliest piece to move.

MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand is the latest to put that idea on paper, calling Crooks St. Louis’ most obvious trade candidate this offseason.

That fits the way the roster is built right now. If Leo Bernal is set as the starter and Pedro Pagés is the backup, the Cardinals already have their major league catching spots spoken for.

Iván Herrera can handle the position in a pinch and would presumably be the third option, which leaves Crooks squeezed out fast. Rainiel Rodriguez, the undspited catcher of the future in St.

Louis, only tightens the logjam.

Crooks’ 2026 season didn’t help his case at the big-league level. In 195 plate appearances, he produced a 51 wRC+ and -0.4 fWAR, and he still hasn’t found a clear path to regular playing time with the Cardinals unless injuries open the door.

But he’s not a throwaway trade chip, either. Crooks mashed at Triple-A in 2026, hitting .300/.432/.574 with a 160 wRC+ while also showing better defense behind the plate, including +4 Framing Runs with the Cardinals. That combination makes him a 25-year-old catcher with real upside, even if the major-league results haven’t caught up yet.

The market only adds to his appeal. Ryan Jeffers’ surprising decision to accept the qualifying offer from the Twins thinned out the free-agent catching pool, and the remaining names - Carson Kelly and Tyler Stephenson - are both older and much more expensive than a pre-arbitration player like Crooks.

If St. Louis puts him on the block, there should be plenty of interest.

Of course, it’s still possible the Cardinals move one of their other catchers instead. But if they deal only one player from that group this offseason, Crooks is the one who makes the most sense.

In Other News...

Cardinals Just Gave Fans Two New Prospects To Watch Closely

The Cardinals used their latest minor league honors to shine a light on a pair of rising names in the system, with catcher Rainiel Rodriguez and left-hander Mason Molina earning the organizations top player and pitcher awards for 2026. It is the kind of recognition that usually says as much about steady development as it does about raw production, and both players spent the season giving St. Louis plenty to like as they moved through Double-A Springfield and High-A Peoria.

Rodriguezs bat made him impossible to ignore, while Molina drew notice for the way he handled his work on the mound. For a Cardinals organization that always seems to be balancing the present with the next wave of talent, these awards are another reminder that there are prospects worth tracking closely, even if the bigger league picture still has a few layers to sort out. [Read more 🡒]

Cardinals Face A Tough Third Base Call They Can't Ignore

The Cardinals search for stability at third base has pushed them into the trade market, and Casey Schmitt has emerged as a name worth watching. The Giants utility man can handle multiple spots, including the hot corner, and his breakout season in 2026 gave him enough value to draw attention from clubs looking for infield help. For St. Louis, the appeal is obvious: a player with defensive versatility who could help patch a position that has been a lingering question.

What makes Schmitt more complicated is the profile that comes with him. He has shown enough upside to interest teams, but his plate discipline remains a concern, which is the kind of issue that can shape how aggressively a front office moves. The Cardinals are reportedly weighing whether a deal centered on Michael McGreevy could make sense, and if they decide to keep pushing, the real question is how much risk they are willing to take to finally settle third base. [Read more 🡒]

Cardinals Add Lefty Bullpen Depth With A Real Chance To Push This Spring

The Cardinals appear to be adding another left-handed arm to the mix, with social media reports indicating the club has agreed to a minor league deal with Steven Perez and invited him to spring training. Perez, a former Cleveland Guardians prospect, has worked his way as high as Triple-A but has not yet made his major league debut, giving St. Louis a low-risk look at a pitcher who is still trying to carve out his path.

For a bullpen that is always in search of useful depth, the appeal is obvious: a live lefty with some upper-level experience and a chance to make an impression in camp. The Cardinals have not officially announced the signing, but if the report holds, Perez will get an early opportunity this spring to show whether he can turn that minor league invitation into something more meaningful. [Read more 🡒]