The Cubs were closing in on a postseason berth when Alex Bregman went down in a moment that looked far too familiar to Cardinals fans. Bregman, Chicago’s starting third baseman, took a foul ball near the left eye while standing in the on-deck circle, and the sight instantly brought back an old Cardinals wound.
That wound belongs to Juan Encarnación.
Encarnación opened 2007 as St. Louis’ starting right fielder and was hitting .283 with a .769 OPS on Aug. 31 when disaster struck.
While taking practice swings and waiting for his turn at the plate, he was hit near the left eye by a foul ball off Aaron Miles. The impact shattered his orbital bone, fractured the eye socket in several places and left him with a concussion.
At the time, Cardinals medical director George Paletta called it "the worst trauma I've ever seen," and the damage was severe enough to end Encarnación’s career. He lost a significant amount of vision in his left eye and never played baseball again.
For Cardinals fans, that injury still sits among the painful reminders that came with those otherwise exciting 2000s and 2010s teams. The organization also endured the deaths of highly touted prospect Oscar Taveras, starting pitcher Darryl Kile and reliever Josh Hancock. In Taveras’ case, the loss may have helped speed up the franchise’s decline.
There was also Rick Ankiel, whose pitching career was derailed by a sudden loss of control before he later reinvented himself as a solid outfielder with a cannon arm. Encarnación’s injury came while Ankiel’s comeback was nudging him out of the starting job.
Bregman’s status was still unclear as of this writing. One detail that may offer some relief is that the ball bounced before hitting him, which likely meant it didn’t come in with the same force that struck Encarnación 19 years ago.
Still, even if Bregman only misses a few games, the moment should ring a bell for anyone in St. Louis who remembers how quickly a baseball incident can turn serious.
And that’s the bigger point here. Baseball can get petty, loud and tribal, but sometimes it asks for something simpler.
Cardinals fans know what that fear feels like. They’ve lived it before.
In Other News...
Rival Manager Sees Something In The Cardinals Fans Can't Ignore
Even with the 2026 season rolling along as a struggle, there is still outside belief that the Cardinals are not nearly as far off as the mood around them might suggest. Giants manager Tony Vitello offered a surprisingly upbeat read on the clubs direction, pointing to Oliver Marmols work and the presence of Alec Burleson as reasons to think the organization has a real base to build on, even as attendance has sagged and the roster still shows obvious holes.
The larger question for St. Louis is whether that optimism can be turned into something tangible soon enough to matter to a frustrated fan base. The Cardinals have leaned into a younger roster under Chaim Blooms rebuild, and the next step is finding answers in the places that have hurt them most, including the bullpen. Vitellos view cuts against the local gloom, but it also underscores the reality that the Cardinals still have work to do before the promise starts looking like progress. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Make A Late Season Masyn Winn Decision Fans Will Notice
The Cardinals are using their final home game of the 2026 season to take a closer look at some different pieces, with Quinn Mathews set to make the start against the Washington Nationals. It is the kind of late-season move teams make when the standings have already settled, and St. Louis is in that spot at 75-80 with a losing record at home already secured.
Masyn Winn is the notable name absent from the starting lineup, with Thomas Saggese sliding in at shortstop instead. For a club that has leaned on Winns glove all year, the decision is one fans will notice right away, and it adds another layer to a night that already feels more about evaluation than results. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Fans Will Never Forget What This Scary MLB Injury Brought Back
A scary scene around the Cubs this week immediately sent longtime Cardinals followers back to one of the most sobering moments in recent franchise memory. Alex Bregman was struck near the left eye by a foul ball while standing in the on-deck circle, and while the ball bounced before impact, potentially softening the blow, the prognosis remains unclear and the sight alone was enough to make the injury feel all too familiar.
For St. Louis fans, the parallel is hard to miss because it recalls what happened to former Cardinal Juan Encarnacin in 2007, when a similar incident changed the course of his career. Injuries like this linger far beyond one game, especially when they involve the face and eye area, and the uncertainty around Bregmans condition gives the moment an unsettling weight that Cardinals fans know all too well. [Read more 🡒]