Jake Neighbours Is Forcing A Bigger Blues Decision Than Expected

Jake Neighbours might not wear the 'C' yet, but his pivotal role in the Blues' recent success underscores his growing reputation as the team's indispensable workhorse.

Jake Neighbours didn’t need a captain’s C to take over Saturday night.

The St. Louis Blues winger piled up five assists in a 9-6 win over the New Jersey Devils, matching a franchise single-game record and giving the Blues another jolt in the middle of their current surge. Neighbours didn’t score, but he still walked off with five points, a plus-five rating, and a performance that fit exactly what this team has come to expect from him.

He now has one goal and nine points on the season, and his role has only grown. Neighbours has been a steady presence on the third line, but head coach Jim Montgomery has recently moved him up to the top line in an effort to kick-start the offense.

That switch has paid off for more than just Neighbours. The Blues have scored 22 goals during their three-game winning streak, and the attack has looked far more dangerous with him in the mix.

The record he tied has some company. Robert Thomas did it in 2022, and Torey Krug matched the mark in 2024.

What makes Neighbours stand out in St. Louis goes beyond the box score.

He’s the kind of player who’ll go wherever the team needs him, won’t make noise about ice time, and brings the same edge every shift. He already wears an A, one of four alternates alongside Dylan Holloway, Philip Broberg, and Colton Parayko.

That style has made him a fan favorite. Blues supporters keep gravitating toward the way he plays, and it fits the city’s long-standing identity: hard work, board battles, finishing checks, and showing up the same way every night.

Neighbours brings that blue-collar edge as well as anyone on the roster, but Saturday also showed the other side of his game. He can hit, he can grind, and he can create.

The captaincy conversation around the Blues has lingered since the 2026-27 season, when the job was left open and the fan base split between Neighbours and Thomas. Either case was easy to understand, and plenty of supporters who wanted Neighbours for the role were watching the way he played and imagining the letter on his chest.

For now, though, he’s still in the middle of a bridge deal he signed in Oct. 2024.

Neighbours carries a $2.75 million cap hit and will become a restricted free agent in 2027 after this season. CapWages projects a five-year extension worth $7.2 million.

That makes him one of the bigger decisions ahead for the franchise, especially with multiple franchise-altering players set to hit free agency after the 2026-27 season. There are also prospects pushing hard for roster spots, including the one Neighbours currently holds.

Even with that pressure building, the 24-year-old keeps doing the same thing: driving the Blues’ forward group and pushing toward a half-point-per-game pace. Saturday was another reminder that he may be finding a new gear offensively, with or without the captaincy.

In Other News...

Blues May Finally Have A Real Binnington Decision To Make

Joel Hofer has emerged as the Blues number-one goalie, and that alone has changed the conversation around Jordan Binnington. With Binnington heading toward unrestricted free agency, St. Louis is no longer just thinking about its crease for this season. It is suddenly staring at a real roster decision involving a veteran who has been central to the franchises recent past and may now be more valuable as an asset than as a long-term fit.

Around the league, the interest makes sense. Teams such as the Rangers, Sabres, Red Wings and Utah Mammoth are all looking for goaltending help, which gives Binnington a market if the Blues decide to explore it. For now, though, there has been no confirmed trade or deal, so the situation remains one of the more intriguing watch points for St. Louis as the deadline picture and the goalie market continue to take shape. [Read more 🡒]

Robert Thomas Is Becoming The Blues Difference-Maker Again

Robert Thomas is starting to look like the driver the Blues have leaned on before, and lately he has been doing it with the kind of consistency that changes the feel of a lineup. The captain has put together back-to-back three-point performances, pushed himself to 20 points in 22 games and remains the teams assist leader, a strong sign that his playmaking touch is back in full view.

The deeper numbers back up the eye test, too, with Thomas posting some of his best work in puck possession and on-ice goal percentage this season. For St. Louis, that matters because when he is dictating possession and setting the table, the offense tends to look more connected and more dangerous, which is exactly the kind of difference-making the Blues have been waiting to see again. [Read more 🡒]