The Cardinals’ search for a long-term answer at third base has a name that’s impossible to ignore: Jackson Holliday.
Jeff Jones of the Belleville News-Democrat wasn’t reporting that St. Louis is gearing up for a full-court press on the Baltimore Orioles infielder, but he did say there are people in the organization who would “move heaven and earth” to get him. That kind of speculation lands differently when the player in question is the son of Cardinals Hall of Famer Matt Holliday and a former No. 1 prospect who could fit a glaring need.
Holliday has been a hot topic because ESPN’s Jeff Passan reported that Baltimore has talked about him in trade negotiations. That naturally put him on the radar for a Cardinals club with a clear opening at third base. From there, the fit starts to make a lot of sense.
At 22, Holliday is still young enough to carry plenty of upside, and he’s showing more of it this season. He’s hitting .252/.359/.397 with five home runs and four stolen bases for the Orioles, good for a 116 wRC+.
He’s mostly played second base, but there’s little reason to think he couldn’t slide over to third and handle the job in St. Louis.
That’s why the idea has real appeal for the Cardinals. If Baltimore were willing to talk seriously, Holliday would be the kind of major-league talent that fits the club’s long-term timeline. He’s not just a short-term fix; he’s the sort of player who could matter in 2027, 2028, 2029 and beyond.
Jones made it clear he was speculating, not reporting, when he suggested the Cardinals might be willing to go big for Holliday. In that scenario, St.
Louis would not be looking to give up Jordan Walker, JJ Wetherholt, or prospects such as Rainiel Rodriguez. But the organization does have the kind of farm depth that could support a real swing if the Orioles ever decided to move him.
And that’s the balancing act here. The Cardinals already have one of the better farm systems in baseball, and they just had one of the best drafts in the sport.
They also have more pieces they could move this offseason, including Lars Nootbaar and Riley O’Brien, while Dustin May and Ryne Stanek are expected to be dealt for prospect capital. The front office wants future assets, but it also wants cornerstone young talent.
Holliday would check both boxes.
If St. Louis were to land him, the long-term infield picture would suddenly look a lot more interesting, with Holliday alongside Wetherholt, Masyn Winn and Alec Burleson.
Of course, there’s another side to this. The Cardinals already have several young players coming who could fill some of these same future needs.
Joshua Baez is close to an MLB debut, though he still has swing-and-miss issues to clean up. Jesus Baez, acquired from the Mets in the Ryan Helsley trade last trade deadline, is having a breakout year and has already slugged 26 home runs, making him a possible future third baseman.
Rainiel Rodriguez, meanwhile, remains one of the best-hitting prospects in the sport and could be in the mix by the end of 2027 or early 2028.
So the Cardinals’ decision, if Holliday ever truly becomes available, would come down to one question: do they wait for their own young talent, or do they make a bold move for a player who could change the shape of the lineup for years?
In Other News...
Blues MVP Debate Is No Longer Just About Robert Thomas
Robert Thomas has long been the obvious answer whenever the Blues most valuable player conversation comes up, and for good reason. He has been the sort of steady center around whom the roster has been built, but the outlook for 2026-27 suggests the debate could get a little more interesting if St. Louis younger core keeps taking shape the way the organization hopes.
Jimmy Snuggerud is expected to skate with Thomas and get first-line minutes, Joel Hofer is lined up to take over in goal, and Philip Broberg is moving into a bigger role on the blue line. Thomas still looks like a strong MVP candidate, but the point is no longer whether he matters most. It is whether the next wave of Blues talent can make a real case to share, or even steal, that spotlight. [Read more 🡒]
Pavel Buchnevich Enters A Make Or Break Year For The Blues
Pavel Buchnevich arrives at next season at something of a crossroads for the Blues, with his game no longer looking quite as sharp as it did before his move out of New York. St. Louis still views him as a candidate to anchor the second line, but the margin for error is getting slimmer as the club tries to sort out its forward mix and decide which players fit its long-term plan.
The pressure around him is only growing because the Blues have other options pushing for those same minutes, including younger forwards Mason McTavish and Connor McMichael. Add in the wave of prospects waiting in the wings, and Buchnevich is not just trying to hold a job, he is trying to re-establish himself as a player the Blues can trust in a meaningful role. [Read more 🡒]