The Blues are still searching for the player who can truly own the spotlight.
That was supposed to be Robert Thomas going into the 2026-27 season, but a slow start has reopened the conversation around who finishes the year as the team’s top player - and whether St. Louis has the kind of star power a Cup team usually needs.
Philip Broberg has made the strongest early case. He entered the season off a career-high 34 points and a plus-16 rating, and he has taken another step with 13 points in his first 20 games while logging nearly 25 minutes a night.
More than the numbers, he has become the Blues’ first real top-pair defenseman in years. Add in the fact that he was named an assistant captain and is in the first season of his six-year extension, and the 25-year-old has put himself in position to become the face of the franchise going forward.
Jimmy Snuggerud has also pushed his way into the discussion. After a rookie season that produced 21 goals and 51 points, he has gone beyond expectations and is on pace for more than 40 goals this year.
At 22, that kind of leap naturally invites bigger dreams. Still, there are reasons to be careful.
Snuggerud has benefited from being in the right place at the right time, and questions remain about his skating and strength.
Thomas, though, is far from out of the picture. Even with what has looked like a rough opening stretch, he is still tied for the team lead in points.
It remains absolutely possible - and, as the source notes, probably likely - that he ends up being viewed as the team’s best player by the end of the season. The concern is less about whether he can produce and more about whether his ceiling is high enough to make him a true star on a Cup-contending roster.
The other issue is bigger than one season. Since the Cup run, the Blues have chased outside help, with Matthew Tkachuk, Noah Dobson and Jason Robertson among the names they pursued. None of those moves happened, and the franchise has been left without a true star for several seasons.
That matters because the Blues currently do not have a single player in the top 100 in points, and no team has ever won a Stanley Cup without one. Only two teams in NHL history - the 2022-23 Vegas Golden Knights and the 2002-03 New Jersey Devils - have won without a top-50 scorer, which makes the path forward look steep for St. Louis.
Finding a point-per-game-or-better player on the trade market is no simple fix, either. Dylan Larkin is viewed as the top available option, but he has never topped 80 points, is now 30, carries a large contract and is not on the Blues’ list of acceptable destinations.
So the answer may have to come from somewhere else. With a strong pipeline, the Blues could be waiting for the next Tkachuk-type player to reach the market. For now, though, the face-of-the-franchise role is still up for grabs, just as it has been for much of the time since the 2019 Cup win.
In Other News...
Shane Wright Is Giving Predators Fans A New Trade Debate
Shane Wrights early run in Nashville has added a fresh wrinkle to a trade that already had plenty of intrigue around it. Since arriving from Seattle in the deal for Matthew Wood, Wright has chipped in three points in six games for the Predators, while Wood is still looking for his first goal with the Kraken.
For a Blues team that has already been tracking injury updates across the league, including news involving Philip Broberg and Jake Neighbours, these kinds of roster swings matter because they can shape the standings race in a hurry. Nashville is still waiting to see whether Wrights start is a sign of something bigger, and the longer Wood stays quiet in Seattle, the louder the debate gets about which side got the better end of the swap. [Read more 🡒]
Blues Are Getting Clarity On Who Is Carrying This Offense
Through 20 games, the Blues have settled into a revealing early-season picture at 9-9-2, and the offense is starting to show who is driving it and who is lagging behind. Robert Thomas and Jimmy Snuggerud are among the players trending up in scoring, giving St. Louis a clearer sense of which skaters are helping carry the attack as the team tries to find more consistency night to night.
The other side of that ledger is harder to ignore, with Pavel Buchnevich, Connor McMichael, Cam Fowler, Mason McTavish and Jonatan Berggren all seeing their offensive production dip. The article digs into individual statistics, playing time and contract details to separate noise from a real trend, and that context matters for a Blues team still trying to figure out whether this scoring balance is a short-term blip or something more lasting. [Read more 🡒]
Blues Prospects Are Giving Fans More To Watch Than Springfield
Justin Carbonneaus first taste of pro hockey has given the Blues plenty to track even if Springfields results have been uneven. The first-round pick from the 2025 NHL Draft has produced four goals and four assists in 15 games for the Thunderbirds, a promising start for a player St. Louis is hoping can grow into a real piece of its future.
And Carbonneau is hardly the only prospect giving the organization something to watch. Adam Jiricek, Tynan Lawrence, Dmitry Buchelnikov, Maddox Dagenais, Arseni Koromyslov, Colin Fitzgerald and Carter Stevens have all turned in notable performances in their own leagues, giving Blues fans a broader reason to follow the pipeline even while Springfield sits in last place in the Atlantic Division. [Read more 🡒]
