The St. Louis Blues have plenty of issues right now, but one of the biggest is staring them right in the face on the blue line: Cam Fowler.
With the club mired in a three-game losing streak and sitting on 16 points through a 7-8-2 start, the standings picture has turned ugly fast. The Blues are seventh in the Central Division, ahead of only the Chicago Blackhawks, and fourth-worst in the Western Conference.
There’s no single culprit for the slide. The top players haven’t delivered, the coaching staff hasn’t found answers, development has stalled, and injuries on defense have made things worse.
Still, Fowler has become a particular concern.
That’s a sharp turn from how things looked after the Blues acquired him from the Anaheim Ducks. In his first 51 games with St.
Louis during the 2024-25 season, Fowler looked like a revelation after a steep decline in Anaheim. He quickly became arguably the Blues’ best defenseman, and then-general manager Doug Armstrong moved to lock him up with a three-year extension carrying a $6.1 million AAV a year before his previous deal expired.
Right now, that move looks a lot shakier.
The strange part is that Fowler’s underlying numbers aren’t dramatically worse than they were a year ago. At 5-on-5, his Corsi percentage has ticked from 48.79 to 49.42, while his expected goals percentage has climbed from 48.48 to 50.09, according to Natural Stat Trick.
On paper, that’s close to even. But the eye test and the usage tell a different story.
The Blues’ defense has become a messy puzzle, and Fowler is stuck in the wrong spot inside it. Philip Broberg has established himself as the clear top option, while Colton Parayko and Brandon Carlo have both spent time on the top pair.
Fowler, though, has logged the second-most ice time among Blues defensemen behind Broberg at 21:19 per game. For a 34-year-old, that’s a heavy ask.
The production hasn’t matched the workload, either: Fowler’s minus-9 goal differential is the worst among Blues defensemen and second only to Connor McMichael’s team-worst minus-10. He has four points, all assists.
The simplest answer may be the one the Blues are least eager to use: take Fowler out of the lineup.
Logan Mailloux’s return from injury could help the group settle into a more logical structure, with Parayko alongside Broberg on the top pair, Mailloux with Justin Barron, and Carlo paired with Fowler on the third pair. But that setup would leave Adam Jiricek out, and he has been one of the Blues’ better defensemen - better than Fowler, at least.
If St. Louis wants the best version of its defense right now, a healthy scratch for Fowler may be the cleanest move.
It would create a handedness issue, since Barron, Mailloux, Jiricek and Parayko are all righties, but that’s usually less of a problem than coaches make it out to be. In the short term, it would give Jiricek more NHL reps, let Mailloux work back toward a top-four role, and give Fowler a reset.
The bigger problem is what comes next. Fowler still has two seasons left on his deal, and his full no-trade clause runs until January 1, 2029, the middle of the final year.
If he settles in as an overpaid third-pair defenseman, the Blues can survive that. The issue is that he’s trending toward being less than that, and the contract leaves the team boxed in.
If the Blues are going to get back on track, they need to figure out Fowler’s role - and figure it out quickly.
In Other News...
Blues Just Sent Dalibor Dvorsky A Message He Cant Ignore
Dalibor Dvorskys night against the Red Wings was a clear sign the Blues are not going to hand him anything, even as they continue to view him as one of the organizations important long-term pieces. In St. Louis 3-2 win, the young forward saw his role trimmed sharply, and the message from the coaching staff was less about one game than about the standard he is being asked to meet every time he steps on the ice.
Jim Montgomery has made it plain that Dvorskys development will be measured against the pace and detail the Blues expect from their forwards, which is why this latest benching carries more weight than a routine lineup decision. The organization still believes in where his game can go, but the path forward is starting to look more demanding, and how Dvorsky responds now will matter just as much as the promise that brought him here. [Read more 🡒]
Jake Neighbours Suddenly Faces Real Pressure In St. Louis
Jake Neighbours has reached an important point in his Blues tenure, with a contract year now carrying real weight and restricted free agency looming after the season. The winger still brings the kind of physical edge St. Louis values, but the offensive side of his game has not matched what he showed in previous seasons, leaving the organization with a tougher read on where he fits long term.
The Blues do have other young wingers pushing for ice time, which only adds to the pressure on Neighbours to steady his production. Even so, none of those options appears ready to simply take his spot, so his role remains important for a team that still needs him to be more than just a hard-nosed presence. [Read more 🡒]
Blues Face A Week That Could Decide Their Early Playoff Push
The Blues enter this week with little margin for error, sitting at 7-8-2 and seventh in the Central Division as the early playoff picture starts to take shape. A stretch against the Red Wings, Utah Mammoth and Florida Panthers gives St. Louis a chance to steady itself, but it also brings three very different tests, from a division rivalry to a pair of matchups against teams with their own roster complications.
Detroit adds another layer of intrigue because of the uncertainty around Dylan Larkin, while Florida has been working through recent roster changes of its own. For a Blues team trying to climb back into the race, this is the kind of week that can either provide a needed boost or leave the standings looking even tighter by the time it ends. [Read more 🡒]