The Blues had the crowd, had two leads, and still left their home opener with only a point.
St. Louis fell 3-2 in overtime to the Sharks at Enterprise Center after Darnell Nurse beat Joel Hofer just 1:03 into the extra frame. The loss dropped the Blues to 1-2-1 to start the season, a frustrating result in front of a fan base that spent the night cheering and chanting for a win that never fully materialized.
The game turned on a stretch where St. Louis lost its edge. The Blues led twice, but the energy and detail that had carried them early faded enough for San Jose to hang around, force overtime, and cash in quickly when 3-on-3 began.
One of the few clear bright spots came from Dillon Dube, who delivered a short-handed goal 1:39 into the third period. The fourth-line winger took the puck from his own blue line and finished the job himself, scoring his first NHL goal since Nov. 16, 2023.
St. Louis also continued to shine on the penalty kill, even as the Sharks went 0-for-4 with the man advantage.
Blues defenseman Cam Fowler pointed to the group effort behind that success. "We're letting the goalies see the puck, and that's everybody.
That's not just the defensemen."
The Blues’ best five-on-five work came from the McMichael-McTavish-Berggren line, which produced the team’s only even-strength goal. Connor McMichael scored again, giving him goals in back-to-back games, with Mason McTavish and Jonatan Berggren collecting the assists. McTavish added five shots and went 10-for-18 on faceoffs, while Berggren picked up his first point of the season and drew praise from Montgomery afterward.
"Ever since we put Berggren up with those two, that line's been our best line for two games in a row. Generating the most chances, controlling the game."
McMichael said the fit has felt natural. He described it as a breath of fresh air and said the three have been bouncing ideas off each other and getting results.
But the night belonged more to what went wrong after St. Louis built its leads.
Montgomery said his team has to be able to win 2-1, and he pointed to the mistakes that opened the door for San Jose. "It's like we want to try and win 3 or 4-1, and it's the mistakes we made that allowed them to score that second goal and then end up in overtime, and anything can happen in 3-on-3."
He was even sharper when discussing the offense. "Right now, if we fell out of a boat and we were trying to score a goal, we would not hit the ocean, and it's causing problems. There's frustration coming because we're not scoring, and it's hard to stick with the process when you're getting frustrated."
Robert Thomas was at the center of that struggle. The Blues captain played 20:37 and finished minus-2 with two shots and three misses, and he was on the ice for both the tying goal and the winner. He and Holloway entered the night still searching for their first points; Holloway was minus-1 with two shots, while Jimmy Snuggerud had one shot in 17:12.
In Other News...
Blues Are Finally Giving Berggren The Chance He Needed
Jonatan Berggrens early run with the Blues has been defined more by where hes starting shifts than what hes been asked to create. Through his first three games, the offensive results have been limited, but the usage has leaned heavily toward the defensive zone, making it hard for him to get into the kind of rhythm that shows off his playmaking touch.
An upcoming matchup with the Sharks could offer a cleaner read on what the Blues think he can do. St. Louis is looking to give Berggren a more favorable role and a chance to work alongside Connor McMichael and Mason McTavish, a setup that should put the puck on his stick in better spots and, at least for one night, let the offense come to him a little more naturally. [Read more 🡒]
Mason McTavish Is Forcing A Blues Lineup Decision
The Blues brought in Mason McTavish to stabilize the middle of their top six, but the early returns have already turned the conversation into something bigger than a simple second-line fix. With the season still young, the coaching staff is sorting through line combinations and watching how McTavish fits with the players around him, because his arrival has the kind of ripple effect that can change more than one spot in the lineup.
What makes this even more interesting for St. Louis is that McTavish has played well enough to at least raise the question of whether he belongs on the first line instead. If that door opens, the Blues would have to shuffle a winger down and rework the depth chart again, leaving the staff with a decision to make before the next round of games arrives. [Read more 🡒]
Colton Parayko Just Reached Rare Blues Territory
Colton Paraykos latest milestone says plenty about both his durability and his place in Blues history. With his 804th regular season game, the veteran defenseman moved past Barret Jackman to become the franchises all-time leader in games played among defensemen, another reminder of how long he has anchored St. Louis blue line through different eras and expectations.
Parayko has spent his entire NHL career with the Blues, and his run has already included a defining chapter for the organization. He is now second on the teams all-time games played list behind Bernie Federko, a spot that underscores just how rare his staying power has been for a franchise that has leaned on him for nearly everything along the way. [Read more 🡒]