What exactly was the point of Ross Johnston?
That’s the question hanging over the Blues after a summer that already reshaped the roster and narrowed their room to maneuver in free agency. St.
Louis made some major trades, and at first those moves looked like possible wins. Lately, though, those additions have gone quiet.
A byproduct of those deals - along with the contract Connor McMichael signed - left the Blues with less flexibility, and their biggest free-agent splash wound up being Ross Johnston on a three-year deal with a $2-million AAV.
That decision already looks shaky.
Johnston is a 6-foot-5, 235-pound winger who has been around the league for more than a decade and has appeared in 317 NHL games. The scoring line is light - 14 goals and 33 assists - but that has never really been the selling point with him. What teams have valued is the edge he brings, and the 591 career penalty minutes that mostly came from heavyweight fights.
Maybe that profile mattered more in another era. In today’s NHL, it’s hard to justify giving a roster spot and cap hit to a player whose main job is to drop the gloves.
Through 10 games with the Blues, Johnston has one assist and 17 penalty minutes. For a player brought in to fight, that’s not much fighting at all, especially when the league has fewer and fewer players built for that kind of role.
The Blues talked about wanting to be “harder to play against” entering the season, but a brawler doesn’t solve the issue that matters most: scoring. And with roughly half a dozen credible fourth-line options already available between the active roster and the Springfield Thunderbirds, plus prospects coming behind them, the fit never made much sense.
The usage has been part of the problem too. St.
Louis has played 19 games, and Johnston has appeared in 10 of them. That’s a lot of runway for someone who probably doesn’t belong on a Stanley Cup-caliber roster.
It also sends the wrong message if the goal is to look like a serious playoff team.
For now, the cleanest fix is simple: keep Johnston in the press box and hand those minutes to someone who can do more than skate 8:49 a night. Maybe down the road, the Blues can find a club willing to take on the contract. If so, it would be because that team buys into the same old-school thinking.
The bigger issue is what this says about the front office’s approach. One bad signing won’t wreck a season, but the concern is whether Johnston was a one-off mistake or a sign of a larger roster-building problem that could show up again next summer.
In Other News...
Blues Win Exposed A Bigger Problem For Jim Montgomery
Philip Brobergs workload in the Blues 1-0 shootout win over Utah stood out almost as much as the result itself. He logged nearly 30 minutes of ice time, a massive share for a defenseman in a tight, low-scoring game and well ahead of the rest of St. Louis blue line, which only sharpened the conversation around how Jim Montgomery is deploying his group.
Brobergs minutes may have helped the Blues survive a night when every shift mattered, but they also pointed to a bigger issue for the coaching staff. The concern is not just what he can handle in one game, but what happens if that kind of usage becomes the norm, especially with other defensemen seeing limited time and the risk of burnout starting to creep into view. [Read more 🡒]
Blues Slide Puts Jordan Binnington At Center Of A Tough Decision
The Blues uneven start has put a familiar name back in the middle of the conversation, and this time it is Jordan Binnington. St. Louis sits 9-8-2 through 19 games and seventh in the Central Division, a standing that has only sharpened the scrutiny around a roster that has not found much traction yet. Binnington is in the final year of his contract, and with his performance trending down, the question is no longer just how the Blues steady themselves, but whether they keep riding with the veteran goalie or use the moment to rethink the position entirely.
There are other names circulating in the background, too, including Dalibor Dvorsky, Brandon Carlo and Pius Suter, which tells you the Blues are at least being discussed as a team that could make multiple kinds of moves if the slide continues. Nothing has been confirmed, and that is part of the tension here: St. Louis is still early enough in the season to change the story, but not so early that the front office can ignore where things stand. Binningtons future may end up being the clearest signal of how aggressively the Blues decide to respond. [Read more 🡒]
Blues Enter A Stretch That Could Define Their Playoff Hopes
The Blues have given themselves a little breathing room with a shootout win over the Utah Mammoth, but the larger picture still looks familiar: they sit seventh in the Central Division and are trying to close a five-point gap behind Colorado in third. With the unofficial NHL Thanksgiving benchmark looming, every game starts to carry a little more weight for a club that cannot afford to drift much longer in the standings.
Consistency has been the missing ingredient, and so has a steadier attack. St. Louis knows it needs better scoring to turn close games into points and keep its playoff hopes from slipping into a chase it can no longer control. The next stretch will say plenty about whether this group can build on the Utah result or whether it remains stuck trying to catch up. [Read more 🡒]