Offer sheets have been back in the NHL conversation this offseason, but the St. Louis Blues have been living in that world for a long time.
The latest wave of attention started when the Philadelphia Flyers stunned the league by signing Anaheim Ducks center Leo Carlsson to a five-year offer sheet worth $18 million per year, which would have made him the richest player in the NHL. Anaheim chose to match. The New Jersey Devils also tried their hand at it, signing Utah Mammoth center Barrett Hayton to a one-year, $4.775 million offer sheet, only to see that one matched as well.
That put the spotlight on two failed bids. But the Blues were the last team to actually land a player through the tactic, pulling both center Dylan Holloway and defenseman Philip Broberg away from the Edmonton Oilers.
St. Louis gave up a second- and a third-round pick in 2025 to make it happen.
For newer fans, though, the Blues’ place in offer-sheet history runs much deeper than that. They were involved in 11 offer sheets overall, making them one of the real pioneers of the strategy after the offer sheet was introduced in 1984 as part of the collective bargaining agreement.
The Blues made one of the biggest early splashes in 1990, when they signed defenseman Scott Stevens away from the Washington Capitals to a four-year, $5.1 million offer sheet. Washington declined to match, and St.
Louis sent five first-round picks the other way. Stevens spent one season with the Blues before being traded to the New Jersey Devils, though that move was unwillingly made.
Then came the Brendan Shanahan drama in 1991. St.
Louis signed him to a three-year, $3.015 million offer sheet, but the Blues did not have the five first-round picks needed as compensation. That kicked off a messy dispute with the Devils.
The Blues also landed Petr Nedved and Shayne Corson through successful offer sheets, while failed attempts included Michel Goulet, Matt McSorley, and Stevens again in 1994.
The Shanahan fight became one of the defining offer-sheet stories in league history. With no five first-round picks available, St.
Louis tried to send Rod Brind'Amour and Curtis Joseph to New Jersey, but the Devils wanted Stevens instead. The issue went to arbitration, and the arbitrator sided with New Jersey, which received Stevens.
St. Louis later tried to swing back at the Devils by signing Stevens to another offer sheet, this one worth $17 million over four years. New Jersey matched it and went on to start its dynasty run in the 1990s and early 2000s.
Offer sheets became far less common after the 2004-05 lockout, when the salary cap changed the way teams handled their rosters. With a ceiling and a floor in place, clubs became more careful with their money and more determined to keep restricted free agents from ever reaching that stage. Since the lockout, there have only been 14 offer sheets signed.
The Blues still found ways to use the tool after the lockout. They retained David Backes on a three-year, $7.5 million contract and saw their offer sheet for Steve Bernier matched by the Vancouver Canucks. Then Doug Armstrong arrived and, to this day, delivered the most successful offer sheets in history.
That came with Holloway and Broberg. Both were restricted free agents after Edmonton’s failed 2024 Stanley Cup bid, and St.
Louis went after both. The path wasn’t simple.
The Blues had to reacquire their 2025 second-round pick from the Pittsburgh Penguins, who had it from the Kevin Hayes trade, before including it in the Broberg offer. The two sides worked out a deal, and St.
Louis got the pick back.
Armstrong needed a center and a defenseman, and he used the rare offer-sheet route to get both.
This offseason’s failed bids by the Flyers and Devils suggest the tactic may be getting another look, especially with a weak free-agent class and a salary cap ceiling that keeps rising. History says the Blues have never been shy about using it when they see a player they want.
In Other News...
Blues Veterans Are Running Out Of Time In This Reset
The Blues are heading into a season where the roster churn feels less like a possibility than a deadline. For a team in reset mode, that means established names are no longer being judged only by what they have already done, but by how well they fit the next version of the club. Jordan Binnington, Pavel Buchnevich, Joel Hofer, Colton Parayko and Logan Mailloux all sit in different spots on that spectrum, yet each one has some stake in how this transition unfolds.
Buchnevich has been trying to shake a long slide since arriving from the Rangers, and another step backward would only sharpen the questions around his place in St. Louis. Hofer is waiting for a larger opening in goal, Parayko is feeling the pressure of younger defensemen coming fast, and Mailloux still has to show he can carry his strong finish into a full season. For the veterans, this is the kind of year that can either steady their standing or quietly push them toward the edge of the picture. [Read more 🡒]
Blues Just Made A Franchise Defining Bet On Mason McTavish
The Blues have made a clear bet on upside with Mason McTavish, a 23-year-old center whose blend of size, skill and long-term potential has made him one of the more intriguing young names in the league. Former Ducks coaches Greg Cronin and Craig Johnson both see a player who can grow into a key piece in St. Louis, which helps explain why the organization was willing to move aggressively to get him.
There is still a reason this deal comes with some risk, though, and it starts with the same trait that has followed McTavish since his days in Anaheim. His skating speed remains the question scouts keep circling back to, even as the Blues clearly believe the rest of his game can outweigh it. With other teams, including the Rangers, also in the mix, St. Louis did not just add a promising center, it chose to make him a centerpiece of what comes next. [Read more 🡒]