Clemson’s season has been hanging on a January decision ever since Dabo Swinney took a look at his quarterback room and decided it was enough.
On January 3, Swinney reportedly told his staff, “Stop asking me about going to the portal for a quarterback. We have what we need there.”
That stance has become a lightning rod after Clemson lost its best quarterbacks since Trevor Lawrence and Cade Klubnik headed to the NFL. Christopher Vizzina sits at the top of the depth chart, with Chris Denson, Trent Pearman, and true freshman Tait Reynolds behind him.
Vizzina flashed early against SMU last year, but that’s the extent of the résumé. Denson has been converted to receiver, and Reynolds has started every game since Week 3.
The frustrating part for Clemson fans is that Swinney has shown he can use the portal when he wants to. On defense, he was willing to let Tom Allen bring in help. On offense, he drew a hard line at quarterback, and that choice has loomed over everything else.
The receivers are not the problem. The group is good.
The issue is that wideouts need someone to get them the ball, and Clemson’s offensive line still has question marks. The run game has improved, but the whole offense still keeps circling back to the same bad decision.
Larry Williams of Tiger Illustrated reported on the message Swinney gave his staff and the broader fallout from his roster approach. The reaction from around the program has only gotten sharper as the losses pile up.
So far, the common thread in Clemson’s defeats is impossible to miss. All three teams that have beaten the Tigers this season are bowl-eligible Power Four teams led by transfer-portal quarterbacks.
Sam Leavitt is on his third team at LSU. Darian Mensah is at Miami.
Ethan Grunkemeyer followed his head coach, James Franklin, to Virginia Tech.
If one of those quarterbacks were running Clemson’s offense, the argument goes, this would be a playoff team. The Tigers have the defense to match up with anyone, and few teams in the Power Four are as solid on special teams. But that advantage has been buried by an offense that has too often looked stuck in place.
That’s where the irritation has turned into open exasperation. The quarterback situation, combined with Swinney’s loyalty to Chad Morris, has become a symbol of a program refusing to adjust. Clemson has talented receivers in Tyler Brown, TJ Moore, and Bryant Wesco Jr., but they need competent quarterback play to matter.
At this point, even the critics sound worn out. The sense around the program is that the same offensive debate keeps resurfacing, and Clemson still isn’t close to settling it. As one piece of the conversation put it, maybe Paul Finebaum was right about Swinney.
Clemson may have technically started its season over Labor Day Weekend, but the damage, in this telling, was done on January 3.
In Other News...
Oklahoma Is Bracing For South Carolina At Full Strength
South Carolina heads to Norman on Saturday afternoon for just the second meeting in program history, and both teams arrive with momentum after recent wins. The Gamecocks beat Tennessee last week, while Oklahoma handled its trip to Mississippi State, setting up a meeting between two teams that have spent the week talking about what comes next rather than what came before.
Brent Venables and offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle both pointed to South Carolina as a complete challenge, noting the balance of its offense and defense and the problems its playmakers can create. For Oklahoma, the question is not just whether it can protect home field again, but whether it can do so against a Gamecocks team that appears to be arriving at full strength. [Read more 🡒]
South Carolina Faces A Prove-It Road Test As McElroy Weighs In
South Carolina heads into Week 9 with a chance to answer a few lingering questions on the road, and Greg McElroy sees a matchup that fits the moment for both teams. His preview of the Gamecocks-Oklahoma game pointed to two unranked teams coming in off recent wins, a setup that should keep the attention on execution rather than reputation as the season reaches a critical stretch.
McElroy expects a tight, low-scoring game and leaned slightly toward Oklahoma at home, a read that lines up with the market view surrounding the matchup. For South Carolina, the bigger issue is less about where the line sits and more about whether it can turn a solid recent result into something that travels, because this one has the feel of a test that could say plenty about where the Gamecocks really stand. [Read more 🡒]
South Carolinas Defensive Turnaround Against Tennessee Was About More Than Halftime Speech
South Carolinas defense looked like a different unit after halftime against Tennessee, and the improvement was about more than any fiery message in the locker room. The Gamecocks tightened up across the board, holding the Volunteers to just three points in the second half as the front started affecting the pocket and the coverage behind it grew more disciplined.
Defensive tackle Kelby Collins and lineman Noah Clark pointed to focus and effort as the foundation for the turnaround, while Shane Beamer said the staffs adjustments helped set the tone. South Carolina leaned more heavily on five-man pressures and man coverage, a combination that changed how Tennessee had to attack and gave the Gamecocks the kind of edge they were missing earlier. [Read more 🡒]