Arch Manning enters the 2027 NFL Draft conversation with all the buzz you’d expect from a Texas quarterback, but not nearly the kind of lockstep support that usually comes with a projected No. 1 pick.
That’s the key thing as draft boards start to take shape before Week 1: Manning is in the mix, but he’s not running away with it. Texas opens at home against Texas State on Saturday, and the early evaluations already show a split.
The Athletic’s Dane Brugler has Manning as his QB1. The Ringer’s Todd McShay does not.
McShay slots Manning at QB4, behind Notre Dame’s CJ Carr, South Carolina’s LaNorris Sellers and Oregon’s Dante Moore. Even with that lower ranking, McShay still sees first-round upside, assigning Manning a 92 grade.
That fits the larger picture of a quarterback class that looks deep. McShay said his board includes seven quarterbacks with a 91 or better, “which is something [he's] never had this early in the process.”
Moore sits atop that group with a 95.
But Manning’s placement isn’t just about how crowded the class is. McShay pointed directly to the parts of Manning’s game that still need work.
"[Manning's] eyes, feet and overall process aren't consistently connected," wrote McShay for a story published Monday. "His mechanics can look clean and easy on one snap and completely different on the next.
And the biggest concern right now is ball placement. There are simply too many routine misses for a quarterback we're discussing as the No. 1 overall pick."
ESPN’s Mel Kiper Jr. echoed that concern on Monday’s episode of "First Draft," saying Manning has to get better at hitting precise throws instead of just "[putting] the ball in the area" and trusting the receiver to finish the play.
The numbers back up the criticism. Last season, Manning completed 61.4 percent of his passes, which is below average.
Even after accounting for drops and spikes, his accuracy still didn’t stand out. Pro Football Focus had his adjusted completion percentage at 73 percent, good for 72nd among 168 eligible quarterbacks.
Ohio State sophomore Julian Sayin led that category at 82.5 percent.
There is some reason to expect improvement. Manning’s completion percentage should rise with the addition of wide receiver Cam Coleman. Still, the broader point remains: for a player being talked about as a potential No. 1 overall pick, he’s not yet where past top quarterbacks have been as passers.
Manning has played 25 games in three seasons at Texas and has completed 62.3 percent of his throws. By comparison, Caleb Williams completed 65.9 percent in his first 25 college games with Oklahoma and USC before becoming the first of six quarterbacks taken in the 2024 draft, matching the record from 1983. Williams had already started more games in that stretch after taking over for Spencer Rattler in 2021, while Manning spent his first two seasons in Austin behind Quinn Ewers.
That’s part of why the early draft conversation feels different here. Manning has the name, the talent and the attention.
What he doesn’t have yet is the kind of polished passing profile that makes a quarterback an automatic No. 1.
He’ll have to show more in 2026 if he wants to separate himself from the rest of this loaded class.
In Other News...
Former Gamecock Xzavier McLeods College Path Took Another Turn
Xzavier McLeods winding college football path has taken another unexpected turn. After leaving South Carolina in 2023 and transferring to Georgia, the former Gamecocks defensive lineman became a steady part of the Bulldogs roster, appearing in 25 games over two seasons before his departure from the program.
Now McLeod is no longer with Georgia and has said he is retired from football, closing the door on a career that briefly stretched across two SEC programs. For South Carolina fans, it is another reminder of how quickly a players college journey can change, especially for someone who once looked like part of the future in Columbia before moving on and eventually stepping away from the game altogether. [Read more 🡒]
Former Gamecock DQ Smith Just Added A New Twist To Eligibility Drama
DQ Smiths path has taken another turn, and it has the kind of legal and roster wrinkle that has become increasingly familiar in college football. The former South Carolina defensive back is set to transfer to Virginia Tech for the 2026 season, giving him a fresh landing spot after entering the portal in August 2024 and navigating a complicated eligibility landscape tied to NCAA rules.
For Gamecock fans, the interesting part is not just where Smith is headed, but where he is not. South Carolinas staff opted not to pursue a reunion even with his experience and ability to play, leaving the door open for him to move on and continue his career elsewhere while the broader eligibility issue keeps shaping possibilities across the sport. [Read more 🡒]
South Carolinas Offense Has One Early Sign Fans Need To Watch
South Carolinas offense has spent the past few seasons searching for more reliable answers, and the tight end spot has quietly become one of the most important places to watch. Josh Simon gave the Gamecocks a meaningful presence there in 2024, helping stabilize a position that can do a little of everything, from sealing the edge in the run game to offering a dependable target in the passing game.
Now Simon is gone, and the question is how much of that versatility the offense can replace in 2025. New offensive coordinator Kendal Briles has made it clear the tight ends matter in his system for both blocking and receiving, which puts added pressure on South Carolina to get that room right early if it wants the offense to take a step forward. [Read more 🡒]