The NFL on CBS X account stirred up plenty of reaction yesterday when it tier-listed teams by one question: “Which teams have best set their QB up for success?” Seattle landed in the “average incubators” tier alongside the Las Vegas Raiders, according to Jared Dubin.
That placement hit a nerve because it landed in the middle of a broader conversation about the Seahawks, who are already being picked by plenty of people to take a big step back after winning Super Bowl LX. On the surface, the graphic looked like another shot at Seattle’s standing in the league.
Dubin’s longer piece this week lays out the thinking behind the ranking and the criteria he used. The explanation helps make sense of why Seattle ended up where it did, even if the result still feels like a surprise when reduced to a social media graphic.
The comparison with Las Vegas also brings Geno Smith into the picture. Smith finished 25th of 26 quarterbacks in PFF passing grade among passers with at least 378 dropbacks in 2025 with the Raiders. Before that, he had ranked 7th of 25 in 2024 and 11th of 24 in 2023 while with the Seahawks.
His results under Pete Carroll were similar in both 2023 and 2025, while he performed better in 2024 with Ryan Grubb. Grubb was Mike Macdonald’s hire, even though Macdonald still got fired that year.
Dubin’s reasoning leans on the fact that Brian Fleury is new and that several Seahawks names, as he framed it, took major leaps last season. That context explains the ranking, but it also feeds the growing sense that Seattle is being overlooked in national NFL discussion heading into 2026.
In Other News...
Seahawks Sale Could Reset What Fans Think This Franchise Is Worth
The Seahawks are on the verge of changing hands in a deal that would reset the NFLs financial ceiling, with the estate of Paul Allen agreeing to sell the franchise to the Khosla family and limited partners for $9.612 billion, pending league approval. Beyond Seattle, the number is already reverberating around the league because it gives owners, bankers and prospective buyers a fresh benchmark for what a top-tier franchise can command in todays market.
For Baltimore, the ripple effect is especially interesting. The Ravens are currently valued at around $6 billion, but a Seahawks-style premium could make that figure look conservative in a hurry, even though Steve Bisciotti has given no indication he wants to sell. Bisciottis long-term hold on the team has kept Baltimore off the market, but this sale suggests the practical price of even a non-selling franchise may be climbing faster than the public estimates have been willing to admit. [Read more 🡒]
Seahawks Just Reset What An NFL Franchise Can Be Worth
The Seahawks pending sale has done more than reset the market in Seattle. It has also forced another hard look at what the NFLs most valuable teams might really be worth, because once a franchise can command a price in that neighborhood, the old assumptions about the ceiling start to look outdated fast.
Philadelphia is now part of that conversation, even if there is no sign Jeffrey Lurie intends to sell. The Eagles have already had minority stakes traded at a valuation just north of $8.3 billion, and a full-control transaction would almost certainly push the number higher, with the market now making a case for a figure well above that. [Read more 🡒]
Seahawks Could Make Their Biggest Win Now Gamble Yet
Seattles edge-rusher outlook still has room for another swing, and that is why the idea of pursuing a major name has lingered around the team. With Boye Mafe gone and Dante Fowler Jr. stepping into a bigger role, the Seahawks can at least make the case that they are not done adding help up front, especially if they want to keep pressure on opposing quarterbacks from becoming a weekly concern.
The bigger question is whether the price would be worth it. Seattle has draft capital to work with, and Las Vegas could be open to dealing from its rebuild, which makes the framework of a move easier to imagine than most big-name trades. Even so, any serious push would require the Seahawks to decide how far they want to go in win-now mode, and whether this is the kind of gamble that changes their ceiling or just drains resources they may need elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]