For Seattle, the Kyle Shanahan story has long been simple: the 49ers coach has owned the matchup, but the shine around him has never quite matched the results on the biggest stage.
Shanahan is heading into his 10th season in San Francisco, and his record against the Seahawks sits at 14-4, including the playoffs. That kind of dominance has been hard for Seattle to ignore over the years.
But FanSided’s latest head coach rankings suggest the broader NFL view of Shanahan is shifting, too. Jason Reed placed him No. 7 on a list of the league’s most overrated head coaches.
"Nobody outside of the Bay Area expected the 49ers to be as good as they were last season but the lasting image is the absolute beatdown in the playoffs against the Seattle Seahawks. That didn't help Shanahan's case as he enters his 10th season as 49ers head coach with two Super Bowl losses as his best achievements," FanSided's Jason Reed wrote.
The Seahawks, meanwhile, have had the upper hand against Shanahan when it matters most in recent meetings. Mike Macdonald is 3-1 against him, and Seattle won both matchups last season. The 49ers didn’t score a touchdown in their last two games against the Seahawks, including the 41-6 NFC Divisional Round rout that ended with Macdonald lifting the Vince Lombardi trophy.
That’s where the criticism of Shanahan comes from. He has been attached to loaded rosters and elite talent, yet the big-game payoff has never quite matched the expectation. The source of that skepticism extends to Brock Purdy as well, with the same argument that his play looks different when the support around him isn’t as strong.
None of that erases what Shanahan does well. His offensive designs remain sharp, and the 49ers’ running game has stayed efficient no matter who is on the field. But the source of the doubt is hard to miss: blown leads, shaky clock management in major games, and a track record that hasn’t silenced the criticism.
The counterpoint is obvious, too. Great coaches need good players, and Shanahan has had plenty of them.
But the bar for true coaching greatness is higher than that. It’s about elevating a team, not just managing one.
On that front, the case against Shanahan has only gotten louder.
Macdonald’s side of the ledger is different. Critics can point to Seattle’s talent, sure, but his defense has stood out because of the way he moves pieces around and squeezes the most out of each player’s skill set. In just his second season as a head coach, he’s already done something Shanahan still hasn’t managed: win the Super Bowl.
In Other News...
Seahawks Mourn A Respected Coach Who Helped Shape A Super Bowl Unit
Charles Kippy Brown left a real footprint on the Seahawks side of the NFL, long before the current era of Seattle football took shape. A trailblazer at Memphis State as the schools first Black quarterback, Brown went on to build a lengthy coaching career in both the NFL and college football, earning respect wherever he landed and collecting a Super Bowl ring along the way. His work in Seattle was part of a run that helped shape a championship-level unit, and his passing at 71 prompted immediate remembrance from around the game.
Pete Carroll and former players were among those sharing condolences and stories about the impact Brown had on their careers and lives. The common thread in those tributes was simple enough: Brown was more than a coach, he was a steady, positive presence whose influence extended well beyond game plans and film rooms. For a franchise that still values the people behind its best teams, his death is one more reminder of how much of the Seahawks history was built by figures who never sought the spotlight. [Read more 🡒]
Russell Wilson Just Gave Seahawks Fans Another Reason To Appreciate Him
Russell Wilsons latest nod from Pro Football Focus offered Seahawks fans another reminder of why his Seattle years still resonate. The longtime quarterback, who spent 14 seasons in the NFL and helped bring the franchise its first Super Bowl title, was ranked highest among quarterbacks for big time throws, adding another line to a career that already places him among the games most notable dual-threat passers.
Wilsons reaction was the part that landed with Seattle supporters. Rather than making it about himself, he used social media to praise his former teammates, and the response from fans reflected how much his humility still matters to them. For a player whose legacy in Seattle is already secure, moments like this help explain why so many around the Seahawks continue to appreciate him. [Read more 🡒]
Michael Wilson Deal Came Down To The Wire For Cardinals
Arizonas long-running effort to keep its receiver room intact finally reached the finish line when Michael Wilson agreed to a three-year, $75 million extension after negotiations dragged close to the deadline. For a division that has spent plenty of time measuring itself against big-money skill players and premium defensive deals, the timing mattered almost as much as the total, especially with the Cardinals clearly determined not to let a core piece drift toward uncertainty.
For Seattle, the larger roster backdrop is just as familiar. Leonard Williams locked in his own three-year, $90 million extension with substantial guarantees and bonuses, a reminder that the Seahawks have been willing to pay to preserve one of their most important defensive pieces. Across the division, contract talks and comeback stories continue to shape the offseason conversation, even as San Francisco watched Nick Bosa make his return to practice after a long recovery that included more than one obstacle. [Read more 🡒]