Richard Sherman Just Poured Cold Water On Seattle's QB Debate

As speculation swirls around the Seahawks' quarterback choices, Richard Sherman argues that quality of competition should weigh heavily in the decision-making process.

Richard Sherman isn’t buying the noise around the Seahawks’ quarterback situation, and he’s got a simple reason why: the matchups haven’t been equal.

Seattle fans have watched the split play out this season. When Drew Lock has been under center, the Seahawks have won.

When Sam Darnold has played, the team has struggled. That has naturally fueled the question of whether a change at QB1 is coming.

Sherman, though, pushed back on that idea while reacting to Week 10 on his podcast.

The Seahawks legend said Mike Macdonald has a call to make, but also suggested the answer may already be in place: once Darnold is healthy, he’ll likely get the job back.

Sherman laid out the case plainly: "(Drew Lock) has not been really challenged with great defenses yet. It's hard to compare what Sam Darnold does against a Denver Broncos...

Then you watch Drew Lock against the Arizona Cardinals and the Raiders, and you go, 'Oh! He's better!'

Not everything is created equal... Do we give Drew Lock a ton of credit?

No question about it. But the circumstances are different."

That’s the heart of the debate. Lock has been clean with the football, throwing no interceptions in four games.

But the defenses he’s faced haven’t exactly been a gauntlet. He’s seen the Cardinals twice, the Patriots in Week 1 beginning on the second drive, and the Raiders.

Those are favorable spots to operate in. Arizona and New England are tied for 25th in yards allowed per play at 5.7, while Las Vegas is dead last at 6.2. The Patriots are 25th in quarterback rating allowed at 100.4, the Raiders are 30th at 107.3, and the Cardinals sit last at 110.1.

Darnold’s slate has been tougher. He’s gone against the 49ers, who rank third in yards allowed per play at 4.9, and the Broncos, who are 10th in YPP at 5.2 and eighth in quarterback rating allowed at 83.3. He’s also faced the Chiefs and the Bears, who had just traded for elite defensive lineman Jeffery Simmons.

So while Lock has looked sharper, Sherman’s point is that the picture is incomplete. Darnold has been taking on oranges, and Lock has been facing moldy oranges. That doesn’t settle the argument either way, but it does explain why Seattle’s staff won’t treat the results as identical.

It would be a surprise if Darnold doesn’t reclaim the starting job once he’s healthy enough to return. He’s dealing with a cracked rib and a quad injury, and with the Seahawks on a bye in Week 11, there’s a chance he still won’t be ready by Week 12.

If Lock gets the nod after the bye, the 49ers would be next. That would be his first real test, and if he handles it well, then the quarterback conversation in Seattle could get a lot more interesting. The Seahawks will just be hoping for a win in Week 12, no matter who lines up behind center.

In Other News...

Seahawks Win Included A Bizarre Sideline Scare Fans Did Not Expect

The Seahawks 21-13 win over the Raiders in Week 10 had plenty to sort through, from Drew Locks efficient night to Las Vegas rookie Fernando Mendozas uneven first career start. Lock threw for 240 yards and two touchdowns, giving Seattle enough offense to control the game and leave with a needed victory as the team continued to settle into its rhythm.

A far stranger moment came on the Raiders side of the field, when an errant Mendoza pass struck Seahawks team physician Dr. Ed Khalfayan in the face on the sideline. Khalfayan later said he was doing well after the incident, and head coach Mike Macdonald also addressed the scare, which briefly turned an ordinary regular-season game into something nobody in the building expected. [Read more 🡒]

Seahawks Head Into Bye With One Big Reason For Concern

The Seahawks went into their bye week with a win in hand and a little more clarity on what they have in Drew Lock. After a rocky start that included two fumbles, Lock settled down and finished 14 of 17 for 240 yards and two touchdowns in Seattles 21-13 victory over the Raiders, with Jaxon Smith-Njigba providing the kind of explosive play the offense has been waiting for on a 71-yard scoring catch.

Seattle also got the kind of defensive finish that can carry a team through a stretch of uncertainty, holding Las Vegas to just 27 yards after halftime. Still, the bye arrives with one major concern hanging over the offense, because the flashes from Lock were real even as the early mistakes reminded everyone how fragile the situation can be when the Seahawks need steadier play under center. [Read more 🡒]

Seahawks Win Came With Two Officiating Moments Fans Wont Forget

The Seahawks 21-13 win over the Raiders came with a couple of officiating moments that stood out almost as much as the football itself. NFL officials were already working through a mixed crew because of flight delays, and the game produced a controversial kickoff return by Seattle along with some late first-half confusion over the down marker.

Klint Kubiak and Mike Macdonald both weighed in after the game, with the two coaches offering their takes on the sequence and the way it was handled. The officials ultimately decided not to rekick after discussing the situation, leaving Seattle with a victory and a couple of calls that are likely to linger in the memory long after the final whistle. [Read more 🡒]