The Seahawks used a third-round pick on Jalen Milroe in the 2025 NFL Draft, and that swing still looks like a miss.
Seattle had extra capital to work with, so taking the quarterback made sense at the time. But after what unfolded in preseason Week 2 against the Tennessee Titans, the case for keeping him around is getting harder to defend.
The question now is whether Milroe should be one of the roster cuts on August 30. The answer from the performance side is pretty clear, even if the team is unlikely to go that route.
Milroe’s night captured exactly why the Seahawks are stuck on him. He entered after halftime with Seattle ahead 16-6, even though Drew Lock and the backups had spent the first half working against Tennessee’s starters. From there, the game tilted the other way fast, and Milroe’s play was a major reason.
He threw two interceptions, and both were ugly.
The first came on a throw over the middle that went about 10 yards and landed right in linebacker Anthony Hill Jr.’s arms. Whatever Milroe thought he saw there, Hill clearly wasn’t accounted for. It was the kind of throw quarterbacks are drilled not to make at any level, and it fed the same concern that has followed Milroe: the tools are there, but the fundamentals are shaky.
That’s the tension with him. He has elite speed and a strong arm, but the accuracy and decision-making haven’t come close to matching the physical gifts. At this point, he looks like a quarterback whose issues are deeper than a bad night.
The second interception came late in the fourth quarter with Tennessee leading 19-16. Milroe threw in the direction of Emmanuel Henderson Jr., who slipped on the play.
But the slip wasn’t the whole story. The throw was off target, and Henderson’s attempt to adjust only turned it into a turnover.
By the end of the game, Milroe was 6 of 11 for 52 yards with those two picks. His quarterback rating sat at a brutal 27.7. More than anything, he looked like what he has been too often for Seattle: a turnover waiting to happen.
That has shown up in practice, too, and it already surfaced once in a real game as a rookie. In Week 5, Milroe delivered a bad pitch to Zach Charbonnet that became a fumble recovered by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. A promising drive ended the moment Milroe got involved, and the mistake helped the Bucs win.
There’s also the roster math to consider. Seattle may need that spot for a defensive back, especially now that the secondary is taking hits.
Rookie safety Bud Clark broke his ankle in the game and is expected to miss many months, likely the whole season. Fellow safety Rodney Thomas recently had surgery on his right hand and has no timetable for a return.
Milroe did at least flash the running ability that made him appealing in the first place, including a 16-yard scramble against the Titans. But that’s not enough to carry a quarterback who still has to function as a passer. And right now, he can’t be trusted to do that.
The Seahawks will probably keep him because he was a third-round pick just a year ago. They may feel compelled to keep hoping. But on merit, Milroe has not earned that patience.
In Other News...
Three Seahawks Suddenly Look Like Theyre Losing The Roster Battle
The Seahawks second preseason game brought another small but telling setback, a 19-16 home loss to the Tennessee Titans, and it came with a few roster questions getting louder rather than quieter. For a team still sorting out the back end of the roster, preseason snaps are supposed to help fringe players build momentum, but this one left several of them with more ground to make up.
Velus Jones, Logan Brown and Jalen Milroe all came out of the game looking like their recent showings may have hurt their chances to stick. None of them helped themselves enough to feel secure, and with the roster battle tightening, the margin for error is shrinking fast as Seattle moves deeper into the preseason. [Read more 🡒]
Seahawks Cornerback Search Just Found A Big Name Worth Watching
The Seahawks are already looking ahead to 2026 when it comes to one of the rosters most important weak spots, and Joey Porter Jr. has emerged as a name worth tracking. Seattle has the draft capital and salary-cap flexibility to get creative if it wants to address cornerback in a big way, and Porters profile makes him the sort of player teams can imagine building around rather than just patching a hole with.
Porters situation in Pittsburgh adds another layer. He is currently on the physically unable to perform list while also reportedly seeking a contract extension, and several Steelers teammates have publicly backed the idea of him getting paid. For a Seahawks team exploring every avenue at cornerback, that combination of availability, upside and contractual uncertainty is exactly the kind of opening front offices monitor closely, even if no deal has surfaced yet. [Read more 🡒]
Seahawks Backfield Suddenly Has A Name Fans Need To Watch
Jadarian Price has started to draw a little more attention in Seahawks camp, and not just because the backfield is open enough for anyone to make a case. Sam Darnolds comments about Price pointed to the kind of profile coaches tend to like early: a versatile runner who can help in more than one way and potentially carve out a real role on offense as camp moves along.
For Seattle, that makes Price worth keeping an eye on in a backfield that still feels like its sorting itself out. Training camp is where these things begin to take shape, and when a quarterback is already talking about a young backs adaptability, it usually means the player has done enough to get noticed. The next question is whether that early buzz turns into something more concrete once the pads stay on and the rotation starts to narrow. [Read more 🡒]