Mariners Trade Talk Keeps Coming Back To One Frustrating Problem

With limited trade options and high stakes this offseason, the Mariners are evaluating their starting pitchers as potential trade candidates amidst concerns about their trade value.

There’s plenty of chatter around the Mariners finally using a starting pitcher to swing an offseason deal. The problem, at least from Seattle’s side, is that the list of arms that actually make sense to move keeps getting shorter.

Logan Gilbert looks like he’s out of the conversation. So does top prospect Ryan Sloan, who Justin Hollander all but labeled “untouchable” during the GM Meetings.

Kade Anderson, who is rated even higher and is expected to pitch out of the rotation next season, would seem to belong in that same protected category. Bryan Woo also hasn’t surfaced in trade talk, and for good reason: with three seasons of club control left, Seattle would be taking a big risk selling low after 2026 when his 2025 season still showed Cy Young-caliber upside.

That leaves the more familiar names. FanSided’s Robert Murray said in a Reddit AMA on Friday that he doesn’t expect the Mariners to land Seiya Suzuki or Ian Happ, and he also doesn’t think Gilbert is getting dealt.

The broader industry read, especially with a looming lockout in the background, is that pending free agents may only move for other pending free agents. That makes a Gilbert-for-Steven Kwan type of swap a tough sell.

So if Seattle does move a starter, the market appears to be pointing toward George Kirby, Emerson Hancock or Bryce Miller. ESPN’s Alden Gonzalez specifically called those three the “more attainable” trade chips among Mariners starters, and each one has the kind of profile that can get a team’s attention: years of control, and enough production to at least look like rotation anchors.

Kirby was an All-Star in 2023. Miller led Mariners pitchers in rWAR in 2024. Hancock broke out this year and posted a 3.57 ERA across 25 starts.

But none of them comes without baggage. Kirby and Miller have both dealt with injuries and some fading results over the last two seasons. Hancock, meanwhile, had been a bust before 2026, and the underlying ERA estimators are skeptical that his breakout will hold.

That’s reflected in Baseball Trade Values, where the three pitchers come in with fairly modest surplus value numbers:

George Kirby: 28 years old, 2 years of control, $34.1M
Emerson Hancock: 27 years old, 4 years of control, $23.1M
Bryce Miller: 28 years old, 3 years of control, $20.6M

Those figures matter because they help explain why Seattle may be limited in what it can chase. Take Gunnar Henderson, for example.

His surplus value is listed at $50.3 million, which means none of Kirby, Hancock or Miller would be enough in a straight one-for-one deal. The Mariners would have to add prospect talent on top.

And that’s before you get to Baltimore’s asking price, which Adam Jude and Ryan Divish of The Seattle Times described as “exorbitant.” If that’s the bar, it’s fair to wonder whether a package built around one of Seattle’s available starters even gets the Orioles to pick up the phone.

The same question applies to other bats the Mariners have been linked to. Jude’s list includes Otto Lopez, Zach Neto and Elly De La Cruz.

If those are the targets, then the price could get steep fast. Would it take a Woo to get in the door?

A Sloan? Maybe even an Anderson?

If so, the Mariners have to decide how far they’re willing to go. From here, moving Kirby, Hancock or Miller for Otto Lopez or Zach Neto would be a hard call. For De La Cruz, it’s a different story.

Still, if Seattle’s only realistic trade chips are Kirby, Hancock and Miller, the ceiling on what comes back may not be as high as fans want. Those arms might land a Jordan Westburg-type return. Maybe a Matt Shaw if the Cubs decide to jump in.

That’s something. But with how much help the Mariners need this winter, it’s probably not the time to close off options.

In Other News...

Mariners Fans Have A New Reason To Worry About That Donovan Trade

The Mariners got a useful look at Brendan Donovan after bringing him over from St. Louis in a three-team deal that sent Tai Peete to the Cardinals and Ben Williamson to the Rays. In 39 games with Seattle this past season, Donovan hit .277 with three home runs, but injuries kept him from giving the club the kind of extended run it hoped for when the trade was made.

Tai Peete has only added to the sense that this deal could become a talking point for years. The young infielder has been productive in the Cardinals minor league system and carried that momentum into the Arizona Fall League, where he won Offensive Player of the Year honors and helped his team to a championship, giving Seattle fans a fresh reason to wonder how this one might age. [Read more 🡒]

Mariners Just Got One More Reason To Spend Like Contenders

The Mariners may have a little more room to operate than previously thought as they look ahead to 2027. Ryan Divish of The Seattle Times reported that Seattle could be working with a payroll in the $175 million to $180 million range, a step up from earlier projections that had the club closer to $165 million to $170 million. For a front office that has spent years trying to thread the needle between contention and caution, that kind of shift matters.

A bigger budget would not guarantee a splash, but it would widen the list of possibilities if Seattle decides to act like a team ready to push deeper into October. Names such as Seiya Suzuki and Adrian Morejon would fit the kind of upgrade the Mariners could chase, and the club also has trade assets that could create even more flexibility. Jerry Dipoto has usually leaned on trades more than major free-agent bets, so the real question is whether this added spending power changes the way Seattle approaches its next big roster move. [Read more 🡒]

Mariners Prospects Just Gave Fans A Telling Offseason Snapshot

The Arizona Fall League wrapped up with a championship for the Peoria Javelinas, who beat the Surprise Saguaros 8-3 at Peoria Stadium, and it offered a useful offseason snapshot for the Mariners. Seattle had a strong presence on the title team, with Brandon Eike, Ty Cummings, Reid Easterly, Calvin Schapira, Matthew Ellis, Boston Smith and Adam Smith all part of the roster that finished on top.

For a club that has spent the fall sorting through young talent from the 2024 and 2025 MLB Drafts, the result matters beyond the trophy itself. The AFL is often where organizations get a cleaner read on how prospects handle advanced competition, and this group gave Seattle plenty to evaluate as the winter begins, even if the bigger question is how much of that momentum can carry into next season. [Read more 🡒]