ESPN’s Buster Olney sees Jose A. Ferrer as the Mariners’ toughest loss in their trade with the Kansas City Royals, even more than Bryce Miller.
Seattle sent Ferrer, Miller and Logan Evans to Kansas City on Wednesday in exchange for third baseman Maikel Garcia and pitchers James McArthur and LP Langevin. The move has drawn support from some corners, but it also comes with real questions about what the Mariners gave up and what still needs to be sorted out.
On the “Refuse to Lose Territory” podcast, Olney said the Mariners had room to deal from their starting pitching, but he pointed to Ferrer as the piece that stings most.
"Ferrer. I mean, really, when you look at where the Mariners are with their starting pitching, they can absorb that.
It’s why, when you and I talked at the end of October, and I told you that you’re starting to hear some rumblings that the Mariners are poking around, looking for ways to upgrade their offensive core, and they were looking at their group of starting pitchers. That makes sense because they do have some depth in that area.
And Ferrer, probably the Mariners would be the first to tell you that they didn’t wholly tap into his potential in terms of his pure stuff in 2026. But a lot of people believe this is someone who’s going to be a high-impact reliever for a long time to come."
That lines up with the case for Ferrer being the bigger loss. The left-hander was asked to carry a massive load after injuries hit Gabe Speier, Carlos Vargas, Cooper Criswell and Matt Brash. Ferrer ended up making 73 appearances and pitched in nearly half of the team’s games, a workload that clearly wore on him at times.
There’s also the fit issue. Ferrer is a ground-ball pitcher, and Seattle’s infield defense was one of the worst in baseball this season. Plays not made behind him likely added to his pitch count and his ERA.
The challenge for the Mariners is obvious: left-handers who throw 99 mph are not easy to replace. Even with Ferrer in the bullpen, the club was already short one arm there, so this trade leaves them needing to patch multiple holes.
Miller, by comparison, may be easier to replace because the Mariners have some extra starter insurance in Ryan Sloan.
There is some help available on the market. Olney noted that there are nearly 200 unsigned free agents, and 30-40 percent of them are relievers. If Seattle is willing to spend, there are options.
And if the Mariners want to go straight after a Ferrer replacement, Adrian Morejon is there. Olney called him the best reliever available, though signing him would cost Seattle a draft pick. The Mariners do have a comp pick coming back when Randy Arozarena signs elsewhere, which puts them in position to make an aggressive move if they choose.
In Other News...
Mariners First Offseason Move Comes With One Big Question
The Mariners opened their offseason by taking a low-cost flier on Michael Toglia, claiming the switch-hitting first baseman off waivers from the Reds. It is the kind of move that fits this time of year for Seattle, a club looking for upside without much risk, especially when the player in question has shown some encouraging signs in the minors.
Toglias profile is still easy to read and hard to trust. He has long carried the strikeout concerns that have followed him through the majors, and his recent shoulder surgery only adds another layer of uncertainty, even after a stronger 2026 run at Triple-A with better barrel rates and improved expected slugging numbers. The question now is less about whether the tools are interesting and more about where, exactly, he fits on a Mariners roster that still has to decide how much patience to give him. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners 2027 Lineup Is Taking Shape But One Concern Still Lingers
By the time the Mariners start mapping out a 2027 Opening Day lineup, the picture is beginning to look familiar in a few spots and a little less settled in others. Maikel Garcia has emerged as the kind of third-base option who can help stabilize the infield, while Brendan Donovans time in left field gives Seattle another way to balance the lineup against a right-handed starter. Between those moving parts and the roster changes already in the background, there is at least a workable blueprint taking shape.
Still, the lineup conversation is not just about where everyone fits on paper. Health remains part of the equation, and that can change both the order and the defensive alignment in a hurry. Seattle may like the direction this group is heading, but until those concerns clear, the Mariners are left with a roster that looks promising and just uncertain enough to keep the discussion going. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Just Made A Luke Raley Decision Fans Will Debate
The Mariners have moved on from Luke Raley, non-tendering the veteran outfielder and sending him into free agency. It is the kind of roster decision that makes sense on paper, especially with Seattles recent changes and acquisitions trimming the need for his particular mix of versatility and left-handed power.
Raley had value because he could fill multiple roles and bring some pop, but the fit in Seattle has shifted enough that the club may now look for a right-handed bat instead. For Raley, the market is likely to be about opportunity as much as fit, with playing time a bigger selling point than a return to a crowded roster. [Read more 🡒]
