Mariners Trade Buzz Around Logan Gilbert Just Got More Serious

While the Mariners remain firm on keeping Logan Gilbert, persistent trade inquiries suggest his value is being tested amidst navigating future uncertainties.

Logan Gilbert may be getting attention on the trade market, but that doesn’t mean the Mariners are ready to move him.

Ken Rosenthal and Will Sammon of The Athletic reported that Gilbert is among several prominent pitchers drawing trade interest even though they’re slated for free agency after 2027. For now, other clubs are only “inquiring,” and that doesn’t necessarily mean Seattle is entertaining offers.

The timing makes the whole thing tricky. With the looming lockout hanging over the sport, nobody knows how much of next season will actually be played, which muddies the value of pitchers who are controlled only through next year. That uncertainty has fueled talk that teams could try swapping post-2027 free agents one-for-one, but the pool of realistic deals is small, and plenty of those ideas don’t line up cleanly for both sides.

One example that feels like a stretch: Gilbert to the Cleveland Guardians for Steven Kwan.

Even if teams are probing, the Mariners may not be eager to part with Gilbert at all. FanSided’s Robert Murray said in a Reddit AMA last week, “I also did not get the sense Logan Gilbert is someone they want to move. I expect him to stay.”

There’s still a chance Seattle believes an extension is possible. If not, the club may simply prefer to keep him anchoring the rotation next season, even if that ends up being his final year in a Mariners uniform.

Alden Gonzalez of ESPN identified Bryce Miller, Emerson Hancock and George Kirby as the “more attainable” names in Seattle’s rotation surplus. Those arms don’t carry the same trade value as Gilbert, but that only becomes a real issue if the Mariners are aiming for a headline return like Elly De La Cruz. A more realistic target could be someone along the lines of Jordan Westburg or Matt Shaw.

So if teams are calling about Gilbert, Jerry Dipoto and Justin Hollander have every reason to listen. Still, unless Seattle can turn him into a controllable bat or two, it’s tough to see a deal involving another post-2027 free agent making much sense. William Contreras, Trevor Megill and Jeremy Peña would fit the idea, but those belong in the “Not Bloody Likely” folder.

In Other News...

Mariners May Have Found A Victor Robles Replacement With One Big Catch

The Mariners may already be looking ahead to life without Victor Robles, and Jonny DeLuca has surfaced as a possible fit if they want to keep the outfield defense sharp. Tampa Bay is reportedly considering moving DeLuca, who remains under club control for three more seasons, and Seattle is said to have interest in him as a glove-first option who could help fill the same kind of role Robles has occupied.

DeLucas appeal is clear: he brings strong defensive skills, even if the bat has been more average than impact-driven. The catch, of course, is the one that usually decides whether these ideas become real, since any deal would hinge on what the Rays ask for in return. For a Mariners club that has already declined Robles' team option for 2027, that makes DeLuca a name worth tracking, even if the price tag ends up being the bigger story. [Read more 🡒]

Randy Arozarena Just Made Seattles Offseason Feel Even More Tense

Randy Arozarenas first career Silver Slugger award only sharpened the sense that the Mariners have a big decision hanging over their winter. Announced during FanSideds The Baseball Insiders podcast, the honor capped a season in which he led Seattle in major offensive categories and earned All-MLB Second Team recognition, a reminder of how much he mattered in the lineup when the club needed consistent production.

Now the part that matters most for Seattle is what comes next. Arozarena is a free agent after declining the Mariners qualifying offer for the 2027 season, which leaves the team weighing the value of keeping one of its most productive bats against the reality that his market is officially open. For a club trying to build on last years progress, that uncertainty makes the offseason feel a little less settled than it did a day ago. [Read more 🡒]

Mariners Linked To A Polarizing Outfield Fit Fans Will Debate

The Mariners are at least kicking the tires on one of the offseasons more intriguing outfield names, with a report saying they are exploring a possible deal for Boston Red Sox outfielder Jarren Duran. It makes sense on paper why Seattle would be in the mix. Duran has emerged as a prime trade candidate, and his recent performance trends point to a player who could bring a different kind of energy to the lineup and the outfield mix.

At the same time, he is the sort of target that can split a fan base pretty quickly. The appeal is obvious, but so are the questions, especially given the disciplinary and personal challenges that have followed him at times. For now, there is no official trade or agreement in place, which leaves the Mariners with a familiar offseason dilemma: chase the upside and live with the risk, or keep looking for a cleaner fit. [Read more 🡒]