The Mariners have already built one infield future around Colt Emerson. That doesn’t mean they should ignore another one sitting in Miami.
According to Barry Jackson of the Miami Herald, the Marlins are open to offers for Otto Lopez and Xavier Edwards. Seattle had already been linked to both in July by SoDo Mojo’s Zachary Rymer, and with Cole Young now locked in at second base, Lopez stands out as the more natural fit for the Mariners at shortstop.
That matters because Seattle still has a real question mark there. Emerson is projected as the club’s long-term answer at short, but even after his lingering left wrist issue was addressed with surgery, the Mariners can’t bank on projection alone. The safer play would be to at least explore Lopez, who has already shown he can be a dependable everyday shortstop.
The glove is the selling point first. Lopez only began playing shortstop regularly last season, yet he handled it quickly and with real authority.
In 2026, he led all shortstops in double plays started, ranked in the 98th percentile for Range (OAA), and finished in the 95th percentile for Fielding Run Value. That kind of defense would be a welcome upgrade for a Seattle club that finished this season dead last in the majors in team Fielding Run Value.
The bat took a big step forward too. Lopez had always been a steady hitter, but 2026 was the season he turned himself into something more.
He led the majors with 191 hits, piled up doubles, and finished with career bests in OPS (.786) and OPS+ (122). He also set a new personal high with 6.1 bWAR, earned his first All-Star nod, and added stolen base value to the mix.
Lopez’s age and contract situation only add to the appeal. He is under team control through the 2029 season, though that also makes the cost steep.
Jackson reported that teams would need to offer “a lot,” and Seattle would likely have to part with a major piece to get the conversation moving. The article points to Lazaro Montes or Michael Arroyo as the kind of names that could start the discussion.
Of course, this is where the Mariners’ own roster puzzle comes into view. Emerson is already a prized long-term piece, signed in the organization’s plans through at least 2033.
But adding Lopez would create the kind of problem teams usually want: too much talent for one spot. One possible answer would be shifting Emerson to third base, where he played 15 games last season.
That could also help settle a position that still needs stability, especially with Brendan Donovan offering little there in 2026 even when healthy.
The expectation, naturally, is that Seattle probably won’t chase Lopez simply because Emerson is already there. But the Mariners may need to think a little more aggressively now. Dipoto is in what amounts to the last chance saloon in Seattle, and this is the kind of move that fits a front office that can’t afford to play too safe.
The money wouldn’t be the obstacle. MLB Trade Rumors projects Lopez to make about $5.4 million next season in his first year of arbitration eligibility. The harder part would be the prospect cost.
Still, the Mariners have already seen what happens when a can’t-miss prospect misses. Jarred Kelenic was once treated that way, and he didn’t become what was promised. That alone is reason enough for Seattle to at least call Miami and ask about Otto Lopez.
In Other News...
Mariners Bullpen Fix May Come From A Much Cheaper Free Agent
The Mariners are headed into another offseason with bullpen help near the top of the to-do list after the relief corps faded badly in the second half of the 2026 season. Seattle has already been linked to free-agent relievers as it looks for a fix that fits the budget, and the market appears to include some familiar names with different profiles, from power arms to pitchers who lean more heavily on command and contact management.
Jonathan Loisiga, Evan Phillips and Alex Vesia stand out as the sort of lower-cost options that could make sense if the club wants to avoid the pricier end of the reliever market. Each comes with a track record that gives the Mariners something to weigh, and the broader challenge is finding a bullpen upgrade substantial enough to matter without forcing the front office into a commitment it has been reluctant to make. [Read more 🡒]
Former Mariners All-Star Has A Surprising New October Role
Daniel Vogelbach has found himself in a very different October setting than the one Mariners fans remember. The former Seattle slugger, who made his biggest impact in 2019, is now part of the Milwaukee Brewers staff as a hitting coach after wrapping up a nine-year major league career that also included stops with several other teams.
Vogelbach moved into coaching after his playing days ended in 2024 and joined Milwaukees staff in January 2026, putting him on a postseason stage few would have predicted when he was still taking big league at-bats. For Seattle followers, it is a familiar name in an unfamiliar role, and one that has only added to the Brewers presence in October. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners May Have Found A Shortstop Worth Reworking Everything For
The Mariners search for stability at shortstop keeps circling back to a name that would change the conversation in a hurry: Zach Neto. The Angels infielder has the kind of two-way profile that can alter a lineup and a defense at the same time, and for Seattle, that matters with more roster turnover looming and shortstop still a position that could use a long-term answer.
Netos fit is obvious enough that it raises the harder question of how far the Mariners would actually have to go to get him. Any serious pursuit would require Seattle to navigate the realities of his team control and the kind of trade cost that comes with a young shortstop who already looks established, which makes this one more than a simple upgrade search. The idea is compelling because the alternative is continuing to patch the spot, and the Mariners may not want to do that for much longer. [Read more 🡒]