Mariners Suddenly Have A Rotation Problem That Could Reshape Everything

As Bryan Woo confidently returns to the Seattle Mariners' rotation, the team faces crucial decisions on managing their newly expanded six-man pitching roster.

Bryan Woo is set to rejoin the Mariners’ rotation Wednesday against the Phillies, and that decision gives Seattle something it didn’t have before: a clear read on a starter who had been dealing with right shoulder discomfort.

Woo told club officials he “feels 100% confident” he’s ready to take the ball, and that opens the door for the Mariners to sort through what suddenly looks like a six-man rotation. General manager Justin Hollander said Monday night that the team is still weighing its options and won’t treat six starters as a permanent identity.

“We're going to continue to talk about that as a staff,” Hollander said before Monday’s game at T-Mobile Park. “We haven't made any decisions as of today.

I don't anticipate a six-man rotation as like a new thing the Mariners are going to do for the rest of ‘26 and ‘27 and ‘28, and we're just going to be a six-man rotation team. We'll evaluate the situation as we go.”

Woo’s status had been the key reason Seattle brought up top prospect Kade Anderson over the weekend, and the left-hander made his MLB debut Saturday in the spot Woo would have occupied. Anderson was always part of the Mariners’ late-season thinking, though, and now that MLB Pipeline’s No. 5 overall prospect is in the majors, Hollander indicated he’s staying put.

That pushes Seattle back into the same kind of starter surplus it had earlier this season before Luis Castillo was moved at the Trade Deadline. For now, the club intends to keep rolling with six starters, but Hollander said the final shape of the rotation will depend on how those arms hold up through the late-season stretch and how they’re performing.

He also left open the possibility of going back to a piggyback setup.

“The results do matter, as do how guys are feeling,” Hollander said. “So we'll take all that into account, and we'll make a call as we need to make a call.”

Woo’s latest scare came after he left his Aug. 16 start in Houston following 75 pitches with what he called an “unusual” issue. But after his first bullpen session off the mound, he sounded upbeat about where things stood.

“He had never felt anything like that before,” Hollander said. “He has not been able to reproduce it since then.

It felt a little sore in the couple days afterward; felt nothing out there [on Sunday]. He felt great.

So he feels ready to go.”

Seattle has also been managing extra rest for George Kirby and Bryce Miller since the All-Star break. Hollander said Miller dealt with lat discomfort during a July 24 outing at Texas, which led to him being pushed back a day before his next start.

Miller’s results have been rough for a while now. The Mariners have lost his last eight outings, and over that stretch he has a 7.19 ERA. That run includes Sunday’s 19-2 loss to the Cubs and last Tuesday’s 22-0 defeat in Milwaukee.

“We checked in with Bryce again yesterday ... and he's not concerned about how he feels right now, was the report that I got,” Hollander said.

“Bryce is not making excuses at all, and I don't think he wanted it to come off that way. I do think he was a little bothered by some lat soreness when we pushed him back.

He has not been on the injury report since Aug. 2.

He did not want to have an MRI at that time, and even as late as 20 minutes ago, [he] expressed that he feels good and ready to go.”

The rotation question also ties directly into Seattle’s bullpen, which has been stretched thin. Since the All-Star break, that group has a 6.81 ERA, second highest in MLB. Carrying six starters means one fewer arm in the bullpen, a real squeeze under the current 13-pitcher, 13-position-player roster limit.

There may be some relief coming on Sept. 1, when roster expansion allows clubs to add one pitcher and one position player.

“There’s just different challenges,” Hollander said. “It’s not as much of a challenge if you have six starters and they’re all pitching six innings at the top.

When you have six starters and getting much shorter outings than that, it's a huge challenge. But we will figure out a way to do the right thing for the Mariners and the right thing rest-wise for the starters.”

In Other News...

Mariners Just Took A Brutal Colt Emerson Hit

Colt Emersons season has come to an abrupt end with wrist surgery, a tough blow for a Mariners prospect who had been part of the organizations broader infield picture. He is on the 10-day injured list now, and the club plans to move him to the 60-day injured list, a procedural step that gives Seattle some roster flexibility while it waits out the final stretch of the season.

The Mariners are still juggling the infield around J.P. Crawfords impending return, so Emersons absence lands at an awkward time for the depth chart. Even so, the team is expecting him back in time for spring training next year, which at least gives Seattle a clear target as it tries to absorb a painful setback and keep the bigger picture intact. [Read more 🡒]

Mariners May Need A Roster Shakeup After Deadline Bat Disappoints

Taylor Ward was supposed to give Seattle a much-needed jolt after the trade deadline, but the early returns have been rough. Limited by leg soreness and still trying to find his timing, Ward has hit just .136 since joining the Mariners, a stretch that has done little to settle the clubs outfield picture or answer the lineup questions that led to the move in the first place.

Meanwhile, Lazaro Montes has kept forcing his way into the conversation with a huge season in the minors, including 37 home runs and a strong OPS at Triple-A Tacoma. With roster expansion on September 1 looming, the Mariners have a possible path to shake things up if they decide the bat they need is already in the organization, even though no official move has been made yet. [Read more 🡒]

Kade Andersons Mariners Debut Put One Pitch Under Immediate Scrutiny

Kade Andersons first big league start came with the kind of close inspection that follows any top Mariners prospect the moment he reaches Seattle, and the attention only intensified once he was asked to work 5.2 innings and allow three earned runs in his debut. Promoted straight from Double-A, Anderson stepped into a new level where every pitch gets judged not just by results, but by how it moves, how it spins and whether the stuff that played so well in the minors still looks the same under major league lights.

One layer of that adjustment is the baseball itself. The majors use a different ball than Double-A, with changes in composition and stitching that can alter pitch movement, including spin and vertical break, and pitchers making that jump often see subtle changes right away in how their offerings carry or finish. For a young arm like Anderson, that makes his first outing less of a verdict than a starting point, with one pitch in particular now under the kind of scrutiny that can shape the conversation around his next turn. [Read more 🡒]