The Maikel Garcia deal may have done more than settle third base for the Mariners. It also changed the way Seattle can think about its next move, especially if the front office wants to add a right-handed outfielder.
Garcia gives the Mariners a Gold Glove third baseman under contract through 2030, while Colt Emerson is lined up for a shot at shortstop in 2027 and is signed through 2033. Cole Young is under control through 2032. With that left side of the infield looking clearer, Seattle can at least picture putting Felnin Celesten in the middle of a trade conversation.
That doesn’t mean the Mariners have to move him. In fact, they still have every reason to keep him. But the Garcia trade makes it easier to see why they might listen if the right outfield bat comes along.
Celesten has already given Seattle plenty to dream on. He hit .314/.409/.534 with 13 home runs and 18 steals in 80 games at High-A Everett, won Northwest League MVP, and showed the kind of switch-hitting shortstop profile that can change a lineup.
The Mariners gave him a franchise-record $4.7 million signing bonus in 2023, and for a stretch this summer, he looked like exactly the kind of player that kind of investment buys. MLB Pipeline has him fifth in the system, and he’s ranked 60th in MLB’s Top 100 prospects.
Then came Double-A Arkansas, where the picture got messier. In 31 games, Celesten slashed .171/.239/.268 and struck out 45 times in 134 plate appearances. The strikeouts stand out even more than the line itself.
That’s why Seattle has to be careful here. Emerson still needs to prove himself in the majors, and there’s real value in having another young shortstop waiting behind him. Even if Emerson settles the position for years, Celesten could raise his stock with a stronger second look at Double-A.
The Mariners’ rotation situation also matters. Jerry Dipoto already sent Bryce Miller and Logan Evans in the Garcia deal and said afterward that he was finished dealing from the rotation.
Ryan Sloan is next in line behind the projected five, and Seattle has already moved Luis Castillo at the 2026 trade deadline. One injury could make the club very happy it kept Sloan.
So if Seattle is going to use Celesten in a deal, the return needs to justify it. The Mariners already have Dominic Canzone and Lazaro Montes in the mix for right field and DH, and they know where their left-handed power is coming from. What they need is an everyday right-handed corner outfielder who can change the look of the lineup against lefties and give Jason Kanzler more flexibility with Canzone and Montes.
That’s why the easy name to toss out, Teoscar Hernández, doesn’t really fit the standard. He still crushed lefties with a .907 OPS against them for the Dodgers in 2026, and he did hit 12 home runs at T-Mobile Park in 2023.
But he also hit .217 with a .643 OPS that season in Seattle, and the empty at-bats in between still loom large. At 34, he’d need to offer a lot more proof that a return would go differently.
That’s not enough to move Celesten.
Jo Adell makes for a more interesting debate. He’s younger, can handle right field, and hit 23 home runs between the Angels and Guardians in 2026.
But he also posted a .298 on-base percentage and struck out 157 times. Seattle is trying to cut down on strikeouts, and Adell hasn’t shown he can consistently be the kind of hitter who keeps an inning alive.
That’s the standard the Garcia trade sets. Seattle paid a real price because Garcia could step in at third every day, strengthen the defense and bring a contact bat under control for several seasons. Any outfield addition should clear the same bar: everyday value, a fit in the lineup, and a profile the Mariners can still believe in a year from now.
If that player is out there, Celesten should be available in the conversation. If the market only offers a reunion Seattle has already seen or another bet on raw power, the safer move is to let him keep developing in Arkansas and make the next offer more expensive.
In Other News...
Mariners First Offseason Move Comes With One Big Question
The Mariners opened their offseason by taking a low-cost flier on Michael Toglia, claiming the switch-hitting first baseman off waivers from the Reds. It is the kind of move that fits this time of year for Seattle, a club looking for upside without much risk, especially when the player in question has shown some encouraging signs in the minors.
Toglias profile is still easy to read and hard to trust. He has long carried the strikeout concerns that have followed him through the majors, and his recent shoulder surgery only adds another layer of uncertainty, even after a stronger 2026 run at Triple-A with better barrel rates and improved expected slugging numbers. The question now is less about whether the tools are interesting and more about where, exactly, he fits on a Mariners roster that still has to decide how much patience to give him. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners 2027 Lineup Is Taking Shape But One Concern Still Lingers
By the time the Mariners start mapping out a 2027 Opening Day lineup, the picture is beginning to look familiar in a few spots and a little less settled in others. Maikel Garcia has emerged as the kind of third-base option who can help stabilize the infield, while Brendan Donovans time in left field gives Seattle another way to balance the lineup against a right-handed starter. Between those moving parts and the roster changes already in the background, there is at least a workable blueprint taking shape.
Still, the lineup conversation is not just about where everyone fits on paper. Health remains part of the equation, and that can change both the order and the defensive alignment in a hurry. Seattle may like the direction this group is heading, but until those concerns clear, the Mariners are left with a roster that looks promising and just uncertain enough to keep the discussion going. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Trade Just Created A Bullpen Problem Fans Cant Ignore
The Mariners latest trade reshaped the roster in a big way, bringing in third baseman Maikel Garcia while sending Bryce Miller, Logan Evans and Jose A. Ferrer to Kansas City. It was the kind of deal that can change both the lineup and the pitching staff at once, and for Seattle the immediate conversation has shifted to what it means for a bullpen that already had to be managed carefully.
Ferrer, in particular, looks like the piece fans will miss most because of his pitching potential and the workload he was able to handle. Seattle can still look to free agency for help, but the trade leaves the bullpen picture less settled than it was before, and the front office will have to sort out how to replace that depth while making the rest of the roster work around the new additions. [Read more 🡒]
