Mariners Still Have One Roster Problem Fans Know Too Well

While the Mariners boast a strong roster for 2027, strategic acquisitions at shortstop and left field could transform them into serious World Series contenders.

The Mariners don’t look like a team that needs a total overhaul. If anything, the projections say they’re already sitting in that familiar Seattle zone: good enough to matter, not quite built for a full-on sprint to the top.

FanGraphs’ Depth Charts has them opening the offseason at 88-90 wins, which would make them the third-best roster in baseball at this point in the winter. That’s a little better than the writer’s own recent napkin math and a lot better than the 2026 active roster produced. The computers are basically pushing back against the gloom that’s settled around the club over the last six months.

That’s also why a quiet winter feels more likely than a dramatic one. The Mariners appear to be in the same neighborhood they occupied heading into 2026, with a roster that should still be favored in a middling AL West.

The expectation here is that they’ll try to lift the floor rather than chase the kind of huge swing that changes the whole shape of the roster. Dylan Crews, Alesia Vesia, and Kevin Ginkel are the kinds of additions the piece points to as examples of that approach.

But if Seattle were to get aggressive, the clearest place to do it is shortstop.

The Mariners are projected to be average or better everywhere except shortstop and left field, and shortstop stands out as the real problem area. Colt Emerson is still viewed as a strong prospect and likely a good major leaguer, but his rookie season leaves questions about his health and performance in the short term, and there isn’t much behind him if things go sideways. The message is blunt: the Mariners have to address the position this offseason.

And if they’re going to address it, the upside of going big is obvious. Shortstop is one of the easiest spots to separate from the pack, and a true difference-maker there can push a solid team into serious contender territory.

That’s where the dream names come in. Elly De La Cruz is one of them.

He’s projected as the fourth-best player in the majors for 2027, and the piece says he would give Seattle three of the top 15 players by Depth Charts. If he were on the roster today, he’d add five wins and give the Mariners the best roster in baseball.

Gunnar Henderson is the other headliner. He’s projected as the 11th-best player in baseball, sitting right between Julio and Cal, which feels fitting since all three are expected to bounce back next year.

For a team built around two star bats at premium positions, adding a third one would be a massive shift. If Henderson landed in Seattle, the whole outlook for 2027 would change.

There are other shortstop options too - Otto Lopez and Jeremy Peña among them - but they don’t carry the same kind of impact. Zach Neto and CJ Abrams are mentioned as well, though the piece jokes that they’re shortstops in much the same way Bryce Miller is a starting pitcher. They’d help, just not in the same way Elly or Gunnar would.

The catch, of course, is that neither De La Cruz nor Henderson is a free agent. Getting either one would mean paying a huge price in major league talent and future value, and the article makes clear that this front office has never shown a willingness to take on a true blockbuster of that size.

The question is simple enough: why would the Reds or Orioles move club-controlled stars? Until Seattle actually does something that bold, it’s hard to believe.

Still, the Mariners don’t have to chase only the biggest fish to improve. The piece notes that there are other ways to add wins, even if the gains are smaller.

Seiya Suzuki would help in left field. Teruaki Sato would help wherever he ends up playing.

Adrian Morejon would help too, even if the value of relievers is always a tricky thing to pin down.

The bottom line is that Seattle has options. Some are modest.

One or two are enormous. And if the Mariners really want to turn a good roster into something scarier, shortstop is where the projections say the biggest upgrade lives.

In Other News...

Mariners Face A Tough Rule 5 Call On One Prospect

The Mariners have a familiar winter roster puzzle on their hands with Carlos Jimenez, one of the organizations more intriguing young outfielders, now eligible for the Rule 5 Draft. Seattle must decide whether to add the 23-year-old international signing to the 40-man roster before the deadline, a choice that carries a little more weight because Jimenez has only recently reached Single-A and is still viewed as a longer-range prospect with a major league arrival projected for around 2028.

What complicates matters is the larger backdrop around the Rule 5 process itself. Because of the ongoing lockout, the draft may not even take place, which could affect how aggressively the Mariners feel they need to protect Jimenez right now. For a front office trying to balance present roster flexibility with future upside, it is the kind of decision that can sit in limbo until the last possible moment. [Read more 🡒]

Mariners May Have Found A Victor Robles Replacement With One Big Catch

The Mariners have spent the offseason sorting through ways to keep the outfield defense steady, and Jonny DeLuca has emerged as a name to watch. Sources say the Rays are considering moving the 26-year-old, who remains under club control for three more seasons, and Seattle is reportedly interested in him as a possible defensive answer for Victor Robles after declining Robles team option for 2027.

DeLucas appeal is obvious from the Mariners perspective: he brings strong glove work and the kind of range that can help stabilize the outfield. The catch is the offense, which has been more average than impact, and any deal would come down to what Tampa Bay wants in return. For Seattle, its a familiar kind of winter calculation, weighing defense, control and cost before deciding whether a fit is worth the price. [Read more 🡒]

Mariners Bullpen Plan Just Got A Lot More Complicated

The Mariners have spent the early part of the offseason looking for ways to make the bullpen sturdier, and Adrin Morejn has emerged as one of the more intriguing names on their board. After declining the Padres qualifying offer, he suddenly becomes a more complicated pursuit, but also a more appealing one for a Seattle club that wants reliable relief help and is weighing whether to commit real money and draft capital to get it.

Morejns recent track record is exactly the kind of profile that can tempt a front office trying to tighten the margins late in games. Seattle still needs more than one answer in relief, and the bullpen conversation is tied to a broader roster picture as well, with lineup upgrades also on the list of priorities. The question now is how far the Mariners are willing to go to land one of the better arms available, and what that means for the rest of their winter plans. [Read more 🡒]